Community Stories

Size Check : Is this Hamilton too big ?

D
Posts
9
Likes
0
I ordered the 36mm version of this Hamilton, but the description was incorrect and I received the 43mm version. Debating if I want to go ahead and keep the watch or let it go for a smaller version 馃榾 Would love some feedback!
 
IMG_8141.JPG IMG_3799.JPG IMG_6913.JPG
C
Posts
1,579
Likes
15,222
First: I really think it's up to the wearer and what they enjoy/feel comfortable with. What other people think is just exactly that.

So with that preface, clarifying that my opinion is my opinion alone, I tend to think that if the lugs are extending beyond the wrist, the watch is too large for that wrist. I think watches look best when the bracelet or strap is clearing wrapping around the wrist, not dropping straight down because the lugs are hanging out in space. For me, 42mm is my limit, assuming a reasonable lug-to-lug distance. My Hamilton Murph is 52mm lug to lug, and that is my limit. For reference, my wrist is 191mm. The Murph is almost too big for me.

That watch on your wrist seems a little large, overwhelming your wrist.
 
C
Posts
1,579
Likes
15,222
The more I look at it, the more I wonder about the Murph. It wears large for a 42mm.

028EB4A0-9B3A-4C26-9A64-471920F01B4A.jpeg F855744D-86D2-4A65-990A-3A5A4F9F941E.jpeg
 
D
Posts
9
Likes
0
Really appreciate this feedback ( love the Murph btw ) it's the devils dance ordering on Ebay lol.
 
D
Posts
9
Likes
0
C ChiefMark
The more I look at it, the more I wonder about the Murph. It wears large for a 42mm.

028EB4A0-9B3A-4C26-9A64-471920F01B4A.jpeg F855744D-86D2-4A65-990A-3A5A4F9F941E.jpeg
So I have another Hamilton that I am obsessed with - fits about like the Murph on you - I think it looks great! Darker dials I think wear a bit smaller.
 
Professor
Posts
2,327
Likes
2,541
The Hamilton looks way too big on your wrist.
What was the problem, do they make this watch in two different sizes?
 
D
Posts
9
Likes
0
Professor Professor
The Hamilton looks way too big on your wrist.
What was the problem, do they make this watch in two different sizes?
They make the watch in a few sizes - from 36mm,40mm, to this the 43mm. I've always been drawn to the design - but could only find the 43mm version. I saw this listed on Ebay with the description noting that it was 36mm. So I jumped on it and when confirming lug size with the seller ( after the purchase ) it came to light that is was incorrectly described.
 
man winding
Posts
62
Likes
134
Looks like a nice watch, I can see why you like it! It does look a bit too big to me on the NATO but I think you could get away with it on the leather. Especially with a long sleeve (if it would fit under). But if long sleeves aren鈥檛 your thing or if you鈥檙e always going to worry it鈥檚 too big probably best get the smaller one.
 
JwRosenthal
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,981
The 36 in this form factor would be what I would go after- if I recall some retailers marketed it as a ladies watch- which I always love because it keeps the dudes with insecurity away from these perfectly sized watches.
If you have to ask, then you have your doubts. I would return it and get the one you want.
 
Nla91
Posts
206
Likes
737
The lugs are too long for your wrist. Yeah, go for the 36mm.
 
Deafboy
Posts
2,406
Likes
6,949
I like it. The large size, white dial and skinny wire chrome lugs make it indiscreetly stylish and works well with smaller wrist. Wear it with confidence!
 
Dan S
Posts
23,385
Likes
52,009
It's on the large side, but I think you can get away with it. In the end, only you will really care, nobody else notices.
 
michael22
Posts
1,790
Likes
2,001
I think it's too large. Looks to have slid down too close to your wrist joint.
 
Watchout312
Posts
214
Likes
188
I would go with the 36mm, but agree with the leather strap opposed to a nato comment.
 
dennisthemenace
Posts
2,828
Likes
4,720
Actually, it looks ridiculously large on your wrist, especially with all that extra baggage with the nato.
 
D
Posts
9
Likes
0
man winding man winding
Looks like a nice watch, I can see why you like it! It does look a bit too big to me on the NATO but I think you could get away with it on the leather. Especially with a long sleeve (if it would fit under). But if long sleeves aren鈥檛 your thing or if you鈥檙e always going to worry it鈥檚 too big probably best get the smaller one.

Thanks for the input - I'm feeling like it's just too big 馃榾
 
18 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

L

Is this Hamilton all original?

lovevintageomega Other Watch Brands Forum
SeanO
SeanO
Posts
2
Views
1K