Certifications work more for business and production. Home hobby probably does not really fit into any category. Such things are probably not in Omega's best interest which is to sell new watch. Vintage watches are great advertising and much the same as a loss leader.
Production watchmakers, are unlikely to visit forums like this. So the members here are more likely to be enthusiasts. To such who make a living from repair, time is of the essence.
Back in the day pivoting was considered standard practice. Sure it would be nice to get a new escape wheel or pallet fork. These tend to be the priciest parts out there. I have noticed that there are those who sell aftermarket setting springs. Mainsprings, gaskets crystals. Or have access to the old equipment and do short production runs.
Granted post WWII watches use alloys and heat treating. It is sad when a NOS part bought second hand fails. Tolerances can also come to task.
Then there are questions like what exactly is the difference between a 470 1312 and a 550 1312. Such seems to extend to the 1316 complete assembly. Yet the pallet jewels themselves 1314 and 1315 have the same part number. Most likely this is due to bridge height. 470 and 500 watches having different plate heights than 55x/56x/75x watches. So can the sub assembly parts be exchanged? The books on go into great detail on the angles and things what affect the timing. One can not tell these parts from one another without sophisticated measuring equipment.
The gray area happens when one starts making replacement parts. I have been considering putting some of the scrap movements into older generic cases. It is sad when replica cases cost more than genuine examples. The thing is these are eventually going to make it back into the wild. No one really needs 30 restored ratwatches. I am still considering dial repainting. What happens if I put something with attribution on eBay or etsy cleaned up with a custom strap. There is no way to control what other will do with such things.
Some have personal standards for collectability, originality and desirability. Others make due what what interests them.
Small laser engravers, cnc machines, edm machines etc controlled by simple robot controllers are much more accessible. What happens when someone downloads the watchco drawings and makes a new case. I am considering that as well. Of course there are forums for such things, but the focus on those is more about the visual results. No one is going to save money that way, and chances are they will find something that is not so desirable.
I guess this is what happens when one gets 20 thirty year old soda pop marketing executives trying to apply commodity marketing to things they have no business in. Same goes for entertainment where everything is a commodity like corn and soy beans.
Not really disagreeing here. I actually idealistically agree with "one makes the effort to get certified." Otherwise it is rusty eBay parts or getting out the lathe and making due.
People like George Daniels, Derick Pratt or Phillipe DuFour could make any part or a whole watch from scratch. I grew up with them and they were my inspiration. They did not keep techniques to themselves or belittle others. Quite the opposite.
What I find annoying are the deleted post, broken links and missing pictures.