seiko shogun vs oris aquis

Posts
63
Likes
24
I am looking at buying a diver for about 1000 new or used. I like these two models but I can not decide. Also which lume lasts longer I am looking into a lume that can last 6 to 12 hours, another watch I was also thinking about was the stienhart ocean 1 titanium 500. any Ideas
 
Posts
17,736
Likes
26,919
Sieko lume.... Amazing.
 
Posts
8,196
Likes
19,298
....Also which lume lasts longer I am looking into a lume that can last 6 to 12 hours

be prepared for @ulackfocus to ask, do you live in the dark? 馃榿
 
Posts
1,589
Likes
5,742
I am looking at buying a diver for about 1000 new or used. I like these two models but I can not decide. Also which lume lasts longer I am looking into a lume that can last 6 to 12 hours, another watch I was also thinking about was the stienhart ocean 1 titanium 500. any Ideas

Dollars / Sterling / Rials / Pesos ?

There are some superb Seiko Marinemaster 300 Professionals, surfacing recently around the 拢1k mark - The lume is blinding

Looked at one in my local watchmakers - It is an impressive beast, possibly even more macho, than a Sea Dweller
 
Posts
17,736
Likes
26,919
Honestly if you like the Shogun, I would get the new Turtle re-release, its basically the same dial and similar movement (hacking/ winding), and way more interesting watch at 1/2 the price. Then pic up a skx 009 for something a bit different that does not hack or wind if that is your thing.
 
Posts
63
Likes
24
Dollars / Sterling / Rials / Pesos ?

There are some superb Seiko Marinemaster 300 Professionals, surfacing recently around the 拢1k mark - The lume is blinding

Looked at one in my local watchmakers - It is an impressive beast, possibly even more macho, than a Sea Dweller
dollars
 
Posts
8,710
Likes
14,611
Honestly if you like the Shogun, I would get the new Turtle re-release, its basically the same dial and similar movement (hacking/ winding), and way more interesting watch at 1/2 the price. Then pic up a skx 009 for something a bit different that does not hack or wind if that is your thing.
I agree. I went with the SRP775.
 
Posts
2,443
Likes
4,229
The Aquis in gray is one of my favorites, also less often seen than Seiko (a good thing).

 
Posts
17,736
Likes
26,919
nice looks good
It comes in about 4 different colors. Pepsi, All black, and black w/ gold highlights. Also there are 2 alt PADI varients.
 
Posts
287
Likes
473
so no one likes the oris?
If I was going to spend 1k on an Oris diver, it'd be the Sixty-Five.
 
Posts
1,306
Likes
1,456
Lum-Tec does some neat stuff with divers for less than a thou.
 
Posts
27,906
Likes
71,035
so no one likes the oris?

With the quality problems I've seen and their restrictions on access to case parts, I can't endorse the brand anymore. It used to be a brand I would recommend at these price levels, but no longer.

Also note that strap/bracelet options can be much more limited with Oris due to their designs. You can always get custom straps made, but if you are looking for a budget watch you don't want to spend 50% of the cost of the watch on a customs strap...

Cheers, Al
 
Posts
370
Likes
817
Archer, could you please tell us more about those quality problems. I like a few Oris divers although never had one. My GF has a big crown pointer date Cal. 644 and she's been wearing it for years without any issues. However, if the newer models have quality issues I'll think twice before I set eye on one.
Thanks in advance.
 
Posts
27,906
Likes
71,035
Primarily problems with the shiny metal hands getting a white film building up on them, and then pitting. Also the dials fading quite badly in some cases. I'm not sure how well the more recent watches are standing up - I don't service them much anymore since they cut off their parts supply, and I don't tend to follow the brand as closely as I once did when I was active on FOOF...
 
Posts
370
Likes
817
Primarily problems with the shiny metal hands getting a white film building up on them, and then pitting. Also the dials fading quite badly in some cases. I'm not sure how well the more recent watches are standing up - I don't service them much anymore since they cut off their parts supply, and I don't tend to follow the brand as closely as I once did when I was active on FOOF...
Thanks a lot for the info.