Seeking info on an Omega Geneve Dynamic online purchase.

Posts
1,733
Likes
14,794
The dial is redone, the case dont look like any known Omega Dynamic model as far as I know.
It should be a cal. 752 or 1022
 
Posts
760
Likes
807
OP, I wouldn't take any of the comments the wrong way. Being a community filled with many collectors, they are all passionate about watches and asking for more information may have spiraled in a way you didn't expect. It happens to the best of us starting out. When I made my first few purchases, I made some mistakes that members of the forum were graciously able to enlighten me about. It wasn't always what I wanted to hear, but it was what I needed to hear.

That being said, you asked if the watch was "fake" and for any issues, so I, like others, will be straight with you. At first look, it does seem like others say a machined 166.079 case. I also believe that the dial is not original and is a repaint. The lack of "Dynamic" and the font look odd to me. I took some time to check ebay and I actually came across this watch's listing. The markings inside the case don't look the ones I've traditionally seen on dynamics, so it may be possible that this case is not original.

Now these problems aside, if you like it and don't care about these few "originality" issues, then you don't have to worry about it. in purchasing the watch, your personal happiness is what matters---just expect some collectors to not see eye. I liken it to fun rat rod vs a classically restored or original '57 Chevy. Alot may like and enjoy the hot rod, but the collectors and hardcore enthusiasts will look down on it.

I do want to say one thing though, I can now see how much you paid and I want to give fair warning. I won't share it because its not mine to share, but for me personally this watch would be worth substantially less than an original and the price you paid can get you a nice original in great shape. You have alot of value between the cal 752, dynamic hands (which are hard to get), and OEM bracelet, but not enough in my mind to justify your cost. If it was cheaper, It would be really easy for you to source a replacement case on ebay (they come up all the time). if you don't like a dial or find a damaged dial, its a matter of spending $100 and sending it to a refinisher (if you are fine with that). The same seller has another dynamic for the same price with the coveted blue "bulls eye" dial that actually looks all original at first look.

In the end of the day, it is up to you and what you like. Next time, If you seek something all original, I would consider posting here in advance and everyone can give you an unadulterated view. I'll even be willing to personally review some posts for you, if you want to DM me. I'm not a pro like others, but I have learned what to look for and can weed alot of things out. Good luck and best wishes.
 
Posts
29,725
Likes
76,932
The dial is redone, the case dont look like any known Omega Dynamic model as far as I know.
It should be a cal. 752 or 1022

752 for this case.
 
Posts
29,725
Likes
76,932
Must say, my first post here has succeeded in making me despise my new watch.

It’s apparently “mangled” and “looks strange”.

Probably fake.

Wonderful.

Mission accomplished.

I’ve written the seller to see if he has any further information on the watch. If not, and in the light of the fact that the experts suggest that it is an ugly watch at best and a forgery at worst, I’ll request a return.

Well, you did ask...

"I haven't seen another one like it and was hoping that someone might be able to tell me a bit more about it."

This might sting now, in particular if the seller refuses the return, but this is education for you. First thing is, do your research before you buy. You aren't the first one to buy a watch and then ask questions, only to find out it isn't right, and you won't be the last.
 
Posts
760
Likes
807
752 for this case.

@Archer any thoughts on these case markings? It doesn't look like the dynamics that I've seen in the past, but I know Omega cases sometimes differ if there are multiple case manufacturers on older models.

I agree everyone gets stung at some point with a watch purchase and it is definitely an education opportunity. I figure that if the case doesn't check out, at least OP has a little bit more bargaining power if he chooses to return the watch and mitigate his loses.
 
Posts
13,483
Likes
31,778
Ref 166.079 is a standard Dynamic cal 752.
 
Posts
10
Likes
1
So, the seller was adamant that the watch was genuine, as I would expect from a seller with a stellar reputation. He was also immediately open to a return with no hassle. As I would also expect from an honorable seller. Having said that, I am a bit suspect of his assertion that this watch was "recently serviced" because I would think that he would've taken photos of the movement out of the case, particularly since it is a difficult operation but . . . nevertheless . . .

I figured before sending the watch back based solely on the advice of the internet I should probably take the watch to a bona-fide expert.

I took it to Timekeepers in Creve Couer. He has serviced my Flightmaster and is no slouch. He did not want to take the crystal off to view the movement but he did say that in his opinion the watch was uncommon but genuine.

Good enough for me. However, after chatting with someone at Omega (their online chat service), it was suggested that I take it to the Omega Boutique at Plaza Frontenac where they may have more information on it. Not sure that they'll be able to tell me anything but still worth a stop, if for no other reason than to look at things I realllly can't afford and don't need.

I don't feel that I have overpaid for this watch because it is unusual and, in my opinion, quite beautiful.

If you can find one cheaper, I would like to know where. Maybe I'll buy two.

Yes, indeed, this has been a learning experience. It is an interesting watch. I will continue to look for answers as to it's exact provenance. If it turns out to be a fake or a frankenwatch after all . . . then I guess this forum is correct in it's suggestion that the watch is basically shite.

Thanks.

Until then, I'll go with the opinion of the only expert who's seen it up close.
 
Posts
10,451
Likes
16,345
There are none so blind as those that will not see. Glad that you are happy and have found people to tell you what you want to hear.
Edited:
 
Posts
760
Likes
807
Best of luck in your search. Respectfully, I doubt you will access a better collection of experts/collectors/enthusiasts than you will on this forum. I would specifically beware the advice of people at the Omega boutiques. They are notorious for missing redials and they are not experts on vintage models. Typically, their expertise is almost completely centered around modern offerings.
 
Posts
10
Likes
1
"Respectfully, I doubt you will access a better collection of experts/collectors/enthusiasts than you will on this forum."

Respectfully, see the post immediately preceding yours.

You know, the experts here can insult me all they like . . . I'm no professional, but when they insult the professional integrity of someone who has spent a lifetime "in the business", well . . . yeah, I guess that's what internet experts are best at.

I'm out. Have fun tearing the next guy apart.
 
Posts
3,184
Likes
3,856
Here is my

Yep. That is what this reference should look like, apart from the day/date window of the cal.752 versions.

No idea if the OP is still around, but he seems to have a "genuine" Omega that has been butchered and redialled. The case might even be a third party replacement, but it's so odd that it's hard to tell from the available pics.

If OP is wary of internet "experts", I have been collecting and analyzing this model for around 10 years. Never seen anything like this & the dial is 100% refinished.

If OP likes it & will use it, then he's getting some value out of his watch. If he wants a "genuine collectible", this isn't it - nicer ones are usually to be found with a bit of effort.
 
Posts
29,725
Likes
76,932
I figured before sending the watch back based solely on the advice of the internet I should probably take the watch to a bona-fide expert.

I took it to Timekeepers in Creve Couer. He has serviced my Flightmaster and is no slouch. He did not want to take the crystal off to view the movement but he did say that in his opinion the watch was uncommon but genuine.

Is that this place?

Home - Timekeepers-Olive

I watched the movie near the bottom of the page. It's interesting that in this video he describes others as "butchers, not watchmakers"...and then you see him work on a pocket watch...
 
Posts
10,451
Likes
16,345
I think the OP feels under attack and has moved to a mental place where nothing we say will satisfy him, but I would add that he is under the false impression that he has no way of checking his movement. In fact there was a movement shot on the original ebay listing, and it is this photo that which @masteroftime shows above. Thus we can see that the movement is right for the model and certainly geniune, it is the cut down case and dial where the controversy lies since the case number shown there is indeed that of an oval case dynamic. The watch sold for circa £590/ $800, pretty steep noob tax.
 
Posts
316
Likes
287
Is that this place?

Home - Timekeepers-Olive

I watched the movie near the bottom of the page. It's interesting that in this video he describes others as "butchers, not watchmakers"...and then you see him work on a pocket watch...

I can't unsee that bench or those parts bins. Perhaps in time....