Scammers on ETSY

Posts
37
Likes
19
Hey folks

Last year I saw a too good to be true deal on ETSY, it was an Omega Speedmaster Professional Moonwatch for sale for $300 and so I thought, why not. I have PayPal buyers protection and if its no good I just return it.

So, I went ahead and gambled my $300.
The seller provided me a UPS tracking ID and I monitored it, sure enough, a package was delivered to my zipcode. No idea what was shipped but the item never arrived at my address. So something want somewhere but not to me.

I contacted the seller and they provided me another UPS tracking ID but when I checked the tracking ID it was for a package shipped a day before I bought the watch. So what fun... I put in a dispute with PayPal and they contacted the seller and later advised me that I had no proof of my story and they have proof an item was delivered.
The seller ghosted me, naturally.

So I ended up calling UPS. UPS would not confirm the delivery address for "security reasons", so I ask them just to verify if the item was delivered to my address. UPS confirmed that the delivery address was not my address at all and advised that they would willing to talk to PayPal to solve this. So, I ended up writing a full report of the entire incident and gave that to PayPal along with the UPS phone number to call to verify the tracking ID never came to me.

Happily, PayPal refunded me 100%, after several weeks.
ESTY on the other hand had no interest and there was no procedure like there is for eBay.
So beware of sellers on ETSY offering Omega and Rolex for $300-500... last time I checked the seller had 2-3 watches at a time listed and frequently changes ETSY accounts so you will see no account history.
Edited:
 
Posts
7,801
Likes
27,123
Last year I saw a too good to be true deal on ETSY, it was an Omega Speedmaster Professional Moonwatch for sale for $300 and so I thought, why not.

This is the fundamental problem, not a specific platform. To be clear, I also dislike Etsy, and had a bad experience with them. But if you're going to chase deals that are "too good to be true", the outcome is likely to be the same, no matter what platform.
 
Posts
889
Likes
2,992
So a cautionary tale of too good to be true deals and all the hoops you had to jump through to get your money back. I honestly don't know who on OF needs to be made aware that offers of $300 ‐ 500 Omega/Rolex are not legit.
 
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,939
I honestly don't know who on OF needs to be made aware that offers of $300 ‐ 500 Omega/Rolex are not legit.
Whhhhattt???!?!!!

 
Posts
3,189
Likes
8,385
$300 for a Speedmaster huh? SMH!
 
Posts
2,710
Likes
17,410
May I ask if you actually thought you would get a genuine Speedmaster for $300 or on the other hand you were attempting to buy what you expected to be a fake?
 
Posts
254
Likes
232
I had a similar experience when I tried to buy a 1962 Ferrari 250 GTO for $5500 on ebay. I jumped on it obviously at that price. Still waiting for the tracking info. Should I be worried?
 
Posts
9,228
Likes
48,999
I had a similar experience when I tried to buy a 1962 Ferrari 250 GTO for $5500 on ebay. I jumped on it obviously at that price. Still waiting for the tracking info. Should I be worried?
Wait, you bidded on that too!?! WTF?
 
Posts
3,706
Likes
6,309
I have just inherited $1,474,484,484,393.23 American dollars, but I need $10,000 American dolllars to hire a lawyer to get my money. I’ll pay you back $1,000,000 American dollars if you can loan me the money. Please help,
 
Posts
9,228
Likes
48,999
I have just inherited $1,474,484,484,393.23 American dollars, but I need $10,000 American dolllars to hire a lawyer to get my money. I’ll pay you back $1,000,000 American dollars if you can loan me the money. Please help,
Ok, I’ll do it, but I insist that you pay me the million dollars via a personal check drawn on an account from a Russian bank.
 
Posts
37
Likes
19
May I ask if you actually thought you would get a genuine Speedmaster for $300 or on the other hand you were attempting to buy what you expected to be a fake?

lol - I was actually just gambling on the slim possibility that this was legit and no not fake but original.

BTW... I saw a CK2998 sold on eBay a couple of weeks ago, only one bid which scored at $1999 from a SriLanka seller... I was tempted but didn't due to sellers low feedback rating. I am in the market for a CK2998 but these are priced pretty high everywhere I look.
 
Posts
25
Likes
12
Personally i never spend over £100 with these type of sites. I always buy things of high value instore. Watches especially. I dont even understand people who buy a watch they have never tried on via online.
 
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,939
I dont even understand people who buy a watch they have never tried on via online.
That would be about 98% of the membership here who collect vintage.
 
Posts
2,555
Likes
3,421
lol - I was actually just gambling on the slim possibility that this was legit and no not fake but original.

BTW... I saw a CK2998 sold on eBay a couple of weeks ago, only one bid which scored at $1999 from a SriLanka seller... I was tempted but didn't due to sellers low feedback rating. I am in the market for a CK2998 but these are priced pretty high everywhere I look.

and what makes you think the buyer actually received the watch?
 
Posts
21,922
Likes
49,718
Last year I saw a too good to be true deal on ETSY, it was an Omega Speedmaster Professional Moonwatch for sale for $300 and so I thought, why not. I have eBay buyers protection and if its no good I just return it.

ESTY on the other hand had no interest and there was no procedure like there is for eBay.
So beware of sellers on eBay offering Omega and Rolex for $300-500... last time I checked the seller had 2-3 watches at a time listed and frequently changes ETSY accounts so you will see no account history.

You do realize that Etsy and eBay are different platforms, right? You seem to think they are the same.
 
Posts
37
Likes
19
You do realize that Etsy and eBay are different platforms, right? You seem to think they are the same.

Dan... what on early led you to that conclusion?
Of course I understand that they are unrelated... you assume too much.
 
Posts
181
Likes
312
lol - I was actually just gambling on the slim possibility that this was legit and no not fake but original.

Really? For reals?
 
Posts
37
Likes
19
and what makes you think the buyer actually received the watch?

Donn
I have no idea how you reached the conclusion that I assumed the buyer received anything.
I have no idea one way of the other.