Forums Latest Members

Review of the Maen Hudson MkIII

  1. wagudc Jun 3, 2020

    Posts
    4,389
    Likes
    11,063
    Hi all, I thought I would share my experience with this vintage inspired micro-brand. I have no connection to the company, but I thought this mini review would be a way for me to contribute to the forum. Maen watches began around 2016 with Kickstarter. They started by offering quartz dress watches, and then introduced a Submariner inspired dive watch called the Hudson with a 2824-2 ETA automatic movement. Their latest project is a 38mm chronograph using 2894-2 movement.

    20200529_182437.jpg

    The Hudson has undergone a few refinements, the first few iterations had some minor issues with lume and the bezel was difficult to move. I pre-ordered the latest version (the MkIII) back in November and it just arrived last week. According to Maen this version has fixed the prior issues and improved the fit and finish of the case. I have found this to be true. They have also switched to the STP 1-11 Swiss made movement.

    So far I really like the watch, and the price is quite low for what you get (only 400 euros). It is a nice size, 38mm and only 12mm thick. In spite of its vintage size and some resemblance to a Rolex 5508, it brings some unique and modern aspects. It doesn't try to fool anyone with Mercedes hands or fauxtina. The box ssapphire crystal with anti-reflective coating that imparts a blue hue in certain light, the applied indices, and unique hand shape give it a very modern but understated feel. The screw-link bracelet is quite comfortable, but does have only one micro-adjust hole. The dial is super easy to read, and the lume is good. It is 200m rated and has an exhibition caseback. The movement is nicely decorated with perlage. Here are some mediocre cellphone images for you all. Excuse the dirt in the bezel in the last image, I like to garden. Also, see:

    https://www.maenwatches.com/pages/hudson-automatic-collection

    20200603_101523.jpg 20200603_101628.jpg

    IMG_20200530_174730.jpg

    20200601_182528.jpg 20200603_101243.jpg

    This shows the blue hue that I assume comes from the AR coating. 20200603_135620.jpg

    EDIT 8/9/2021: Review of warranty process and photo of movement used in more recent versions included in a followup post below.
     
    Edited Aug 9, 2021
    DaveK, mcemeren, thelinendial and 9 others like this.
  2. chanbar Jun 6, 2020

    Posts
    367
    Likes
    1,101
    I like the Hudson a lot. I have the first version

    B9A53D5F-7A6E-4AE3-AF8D-49E145248FB2.jpeg
     
    wagudc likes this.
  3. High Hope Jun 6, 2020

    Posts
    566
    Likes
    2,115
    That is a nice looking watch, it seems like a high quality piece. I just ordered the deep blue (with what appears to be a white chapter ring.) Will post up impressions once it arrives. Thanks!
     
    wagudc likes this.
  4. Dsloan Jun 6, 2020

    Posts
    2,610
    Likes
    16,640
    Thanks for this write-up. Glad to hear that the details and finishing have improved. I keep thinking about getting one of their new chronographs. I really enjoy a chronograph with a timing bezel.
     
    wagudc likes this.
  5. chanbar Jun 6, 2020

    Posts
    367
    Likes
    1,101
    I will have the skymaster on my wrist Monday. I will post a picture of it!
     
    wagudc likes this.
  6. wagudc Jun 6, 2020

    Posts
    4,389
    Likes
    11,063
    The all white is very nice.
     
    chanbar likes this.
  7. wagudc Jun 6, 2020

    Posts
    4,389
    Likes
    11,063
    The quality seems great to me. I feel like you get a 800 euro watch for 400. Although, you have to deal with preorders and delays. I wonder what their margins are, and even more what kind of margins the big companies have. They did save some on the box, it is barely a step up from a cardboard shipping box. I could care less about though.
     
  8. rbob99 Jun 6, 2020

    Posts
    1,196
    Likes
    5,059
    No date is a big plus for me.
     
    DaveK and wagudc like this.
  9. wagudc Jun 6, 2020

    Posts
    4,389
    Likes
    11,063
    It is so hard to find a new watch these days without the date complication.
     
    rbob99 likes this.
  10. rbob99 Jun 6, 2020

    Posts
    1,196
    Likes
    5,059
    Agreed. That is one of my pet peeves.
     
    wagudc likes this.
  11. wagudc Jun 11, 2020

    Posts
    4,389
    Likes
    11,063
    Just a quick update, over the last week the watch has average +1.4 sec/day. It is surprisingly consistent and well regulated.
     
    chanbar likes this.
  12. wagudc Aug 9, 2021

    Posts
    4,389
    Likes
    11,063
    I thought I should give you all another update. I had an issue with the watch stopping and so I sent it in for a warranty claim. The process was less than painless. Part of the problem is that I live in a rural area not served by DHL. After a ridiculously long email transaction, I sent the watch all the way back Sweden. It took 3 months from the time I shipped it, for them to be ready to ship it back. They swapped out the movement with a new one. The original movement was a nicely decorated STP 1-11 movement (see photo above), and they replaced it with an undecorated Ronda R150 (picture below). All new versions of this what come with the Ronda movement. They did include a free rubber tropic strap. I am glad that they took care of the watch, and time will tell if the new movement performs well.

    P8091386.JPG
     
    DaveK likes this.
  13. chanbar Aug 9, 2021

    Posts
    367
    Likes
    1,101
    Bummer on the movement issue. My original one (I think it was the 2824 elabore is still running strong at about +5s day
     
    wagudc likes this.