Apologies for those who feel this has been beaten to death, but I would like to revive this perennial topic in case there is a new technique or tool, or someone who has become very proficient in this skill in the past couple of years.
As far as I can tell, it is still a bit of a dilemma.
As has been mentioned previously, using double-sided sticky tape (or dial dots) to attach the dial to the movement doesn't feel like a "proper" repair. On the other hand, even using the correct soldering tool (or a laser), damage to the paint side of the dial is apparently still a substantial risk. So it's hard to contemplate risking damage to the dial (and potentially losing 1/3 of the watch's value) when it can still be attractive and functional with the help of some sticky tape.
My sense after reviewing the threads on several different forums is that a major factor is the experience and skill of the person attempting the repair, which makes a lot of sense. He would need to be aware of the best type of tool, materials and solder for the particular job, experienced at positioning the feet correctly, and familiar with the least invasive approach. Someone who does repairs like this a few times a week would probably have a much better success rate than someone who does it a few times a year.
If you know of someone who has developed a bit of a speciality in dial feet repair, I'd be grateful for the suggestion. Please feel free to PM me if you're not comfortable posting in the open forum.
Click to expand...