Removing a broken ratchet screw in a barrel arbor.

Posts
16
Likes
2
I have a Minerva movement that is branded Enicar. The ratchet screw is broken off in the winding arbor.
Suggestions for removal of the broken screw?
 
Posts
27,924
Likes
71,114
That’s a tough one. How stuck is it?

I would try running it some cleaning solution in an ultrasonic tank to see if you can loosen it. You could try drilling it out, or laser welding something to it to help turn it out.

Or, find a replacement...I’ve had to get them mad on occasion, when nothing else would work.
 
Posts
14,552
Likes
42,074
Frequently, the screw for the ratchet wheel is a left hand thread. Most watches use a screw with a right hand thread in this position. If this screw is a left hand thread, on occasion the screw might be broken off in the arbor when someone forces the screw in the wrong direction. Try “teasing” the screw out by “tickling” it clockwise, rather than counter clockwise.
 
Posts
49
Likes
8
I would recommend to get one useful tool Bergeon no 30209 - broken screw extractor
does the job accurate and saves the time
 
Posts
2,056
Likes
4,183
I was able to use a a smaller arbor pin vise puller on the broken nub on one I broke recently.
 
Posts
25
Likes
5
Here are a few steps that may help you remove the broken ratchet screw from your Minerva movement:

  1. Apply penetrating oil: Apply penetrating oil to the area around the broken screw. Allow the oil to sit for a few hours or overnight to help loosen any corrosion or debris that may be holding the screw in place.

  2. Use a screw extractor: If the broken screw is protruding slightly from the arbor, you may be able to use a screw extractor to remove it. Choose an extractor that is slightly smaller than the diameter of the screw and gently turn it counterclockwise with pliers or a wrench until the screw comes out.

  3. Drill and tap the screw: If the screw is broken off below the surface of the arbor, you may need to drill into the screw to remove it. Choose a drill bit that is slightly smaller than the diameter of the screw and drill straight down into the center of the screw. Then, use a tap to create new threads in the hole you just drilled. You may need to repeat this process several times with increasingly larger drill bits and taps until the screw comes loose.