- Posts
- 478
- Likes
- 489
Lurk41
·For me it would be: 39mm Explorer <<<< RM < 36mm Explorer << Denim RM (this one is just amazing)
Railmaster vs Explorer?
- Posts
- 1,456
- Likes
- 19,254
KeithS
·I prefer the 36 mm Explorer. The 39 mm MK2 version is also nice, but seems slightly less well-proportioned to me. I don't like the coloration of the lume on the Railmasters (too brown on the 1957 re-edition and too green on the older non-limited editions). I may, however, be slightly biased...
- Posts
- 6,832
- Likes
- 13,796
Nobel Prize
·Both watches are great. I tend to go for the explorer but I like the one with the applied numerals better. The rail master is a little busier but it remains a pure simple design. I think is a "damn if you do damn if you don't" sort of thing and you will always have a little but of FOMO no matter your choice. Ultimately no matter what way you go you'll be left with a great watch....and without a great watch.
- Posts
- 1,158
- Likes
- 8,014
ReturnOfUltraman
·Explorer 36mm 114270 > Railmaster Trilogy > Explorer 39mm > Railmaster standard production.
- Posts
- 3,369
- Likes
- 6,571
fskywalker
·Railmaster 36 had replaced the 39; definitely on the 36 mm size the Railmaster wins!
- Posts
- 91
- Likes
- 317
NyCSnEaK
·My 36mm Railmaster is my favorite watch. It fits proportionately perfect on the wrist.
- Posts
- 231
- Likes
- 510
Theognosis
·The true winners here are the lucky gentlemen who own both the Railmaster 60th LE and the Explorer 36mm.* This thread reminds me that owning the RMLE is not enough and that I need to get an Explorer 36 sometime in the future.
Here’s the groom waiting for his bride.
* - vintage collectors who have both the CK-2914 and the 1060 are LEGENDARY!
Here’s the groom waiting for his bride.
* - vintage collectors who have both the CK-2914 and the 1060 are LEGENDARY!
Edited:
- Posts
- 735
- Likes
- 2,973
robinhook
·The true winners here are the lucky gentlemen who own both the Railmaster 60th LE and the Explorer 36mm.* This thread reminds me that owning the RMLE is not enough and that I need to get an Explorer 36 sometime in the future.
Here’s the groom waiting for his bride.
* - vintage collectors who have both the CK-2914 and the 1060 are LEGENDARY!
Personally I think the 36mm RM has a better proportion than the 60th anniversary version. Also like the hands on the 36mm better, and not a fan of the faux patina...
Edited:
- Posts
- 735
- Likes
- 2,973
- Posts
- 68
- Likes
- 33
MustWatch
·I'm a guy who looks at his wrist several times a day to see the date. Can't break myself of that habit. But I'd love to own an Explorer or a 1957 Trilogy Railmaster (I even like the faux-patina!). These watches are perfect, sans date. If Rolex ever reissued the 36mm Explorer, I'd go into hock to get one.
- Posts
- 300
- Likes
- 197
gvids
·
Damn I started this thread two years ago, and this post brought me back to it today...and now, I miss my railmaster! 😀
- Posts
- 49
- Likes
- 343
Amice
·Love the Explorer 14270. Perfect size and the earlier ones have a tritium dial. Also looks great on leather.
Here is mine from 1996 with tritium, mostly worn on leather straps:
Here is mine from 1996 with tritium, mostly worn on leather straps:
- Posts
- 68
- Likes
- 493
- Posts
- 123
- Likes
- 151
AriTheWatchmaker
·IMHO the explorer 1 is a snoozfest...the railmaster wins everytime...but explorer 2 vs what omega gmt ?
I had a titanium Seamaster Pro Auto, and always wanted a SeaProGMT because it has a lot going for it, and isnt a stinky rolex with now no independent wm able to buy parts...Omega rulez!
I had a titanium Seamaster Pro Auto, and always wanted a SeaProGMT because it has a lot going for it, and isnt a stinky rolex with now no independent wm able to buy parts...Omega rulez!
- Posts
- 886
- Likes
- 471
Duckie
·IMHO the explorer 1 is a snoozfest...the railmaster wins everytime...but explorer 2 vs what omega gmt ?
I had a titanium Seamaster Pro Auto, and always wanted a SeaProGMT because it has a lot going for it, and isnt a stinky rolex with now no independent wm able to buy parts...Omega rulez!
Are you sure about all that?
- Posts
- 123
- Likes
- 151
AriTheWatchmaker
·Which part are you asking about?
Rolex UsA cut all parts accounts not owned by ORJ's earlier this year...nobody is getting parts anymore...everyone got the green letters, so I would be very cautious about owning a rolex going forwards. All machines wear-out some of their parts over time.
If it was something else you meant, please let me know
- Posts
- 1,099
- Likes
- 1,083
pIoNeErOfThEnILe
·I must admit I love an explorer, but I lprefer the vintage ones. I think the styling of the railmaster in this particular pairing make it a winner for me.
rolex has lost it's heart. all the new beefy case lugs on their watches are very un-stylish imo....
- Posts
- 2,443
- Likes
- 4,231
wsfarrell
·all the new beefy case lugs on their watches are very un-stylish
- Posts
- 735
- Likes
- 2,973
robinhook
·I like both, imo the explorer 36 wears smaller and looks slightly smaller. I feel more connected to the RM since my grandfather was a hard working engine driver all his life, I still battle some rolex stigma but that might wear off eventually. Tough call, you love different things about them.
- Posts
- 1,296
- Likes
- 1,810
DIV
·Just over a year after my postings on page 8, I sold my 39mm Explorer. An exceptionally great watch, but it was just a bit too big and bold for my taste. It was my intention to pick up a 36mm Explorer (an early 14270), but a few things got in the way of my plans:
1) I used the funds to pay down some debts
2) I just can’t justify the prices the 36mm versions are commanding these days for the comparatively inferior timepiece you get, especially with regards to the bracelet and clasp.
3) I fell back in love with this guy and decided I don’t need any other watch, period:
1) I used the funds to pay down some debts
2) I just can’t justify the prices the 36mm versions are commanding these days for the comparatively inferior timepiece you get, especially with regards to the bracelet and clasp.
3) I fell back in love with this guy and decided I don’t need any other watch, period:
Similar threads
- Posts
- 2
- Views
- 376
- Posts
- 4
- Views
- 497
