Forums Latest Members

Poorly Maintained Watches In Good Cosmetic Condition- Good Value or Not?

  1. Excalious May 15, 2019

    Posts
    18
    Likes
    54
    Hi There,

    I'm wondering how much of a one-stop-solution a good service is.

    If a vintage piece needs to be serviced anyways, does it matter if the piece is 'extra' dirty? I've been eyeing pieces like the following 167.021:

    It comes with a beads of rice, dial looks original (to me), case looks unpolished. Price seems under comparable sales for the same reference.

    But there is a ton of dirt around the bezel, around the crown, around the rim in the movement shots, even the recesses on the back. The crystal is cracked and the rotor itself has a lot of grooves that appear to be caused by wear.

    Is something like this a potential bargain where a service you would get anyways can fix everything? Or a giant headache in the making?

    Thank you.
     
    Test10.jpg Test11.jpg Test12.jpg Test14.jpg Test13.jpg Test15.jpg Test16.jpg
  2. NVWC May 15, 2019

    Posts
    150
    Likes
    384
    Hi, i think its a redial IMO.
    But other experts will surely respond to this later.
     
  3. Canuck May 15, 2019

    Posts
    13,478
    Likes
    38,025
    On occasion, the under-priced “rescue” can end up costing you more in total, than spending what you have to, to buy a pristine example. So the decision is pretty much yours. If this “rescue” watch is a grail watch you really must have, rather than an “acceptable”one that you would buy primarily for its condition, then go for it.
     
    JwRosenthal likes this.
  4. MTROIS May 15, 2019

    Posts
    1,994
    Likes
    6,998
    Why do you think that is? :thumbsdown:
     
  5. connieseamaster May 15, 2019

    Posts
    1,375
    Likes
    1,979
    I see speckled rust on some of the steel plates. This could turn into a boondoggle. Also, the Omega logo isn't symmetrical, which makes me suspicious of the dial.
     
  6. JwRosenthal May 15, 2019

    Posts
    14,932
    Likes
    40,298
    It’s a redial, movement needs work, it will be a money pit and still won’t have half the value it would due to the redial.
    Bargains rarely are that- take it from a noob that has learned the hard way.
    You are better off getting a watch that is all original and well cared for than a bargain beater that’s been cobbled. If you ever decide to sell it you won’t get nearly what you have into it back
     
  7. ATracyWatches May 15, 2019

    Posts
    227
    Likes
    668
    It all depends on the size of your bank account. If you are doing it to save money, pick a new plan.
     
    connieseamaster and JwRosenthal like this.
  8. Passover May 15, 2019

    Posts
    1,854
    Likes
    2,528
  9. JwRosenthal May 15, 2019

    Posts
    14,932
    Likes
    40,298
    I just compared this to others of The same reference- this may indeed be a genuine dial
    That said, if it is running fine and only needs a service to get it 100%, dirt grime and a crystal (and generally a new crown & case back sea to keep it water tight) are standard things cleaned up in a service.
    I’m not afraid of dirt-watches get nasty since people wear them and people are nasty. Unless the watch comes from a known seller who stands behind their watch (like many of the members who sell here), I always knock the cost of service and common wear parts off the value of the watch and consider that in my value of what I would pay. Otherwise you are indeed looking at a potential money pit
     
  10. Davidt May 15, 2019

    Posts
    10,423
    Likes
    18,128
    Looks like an original dial to me.

    There’s dirty and there’s dirty. On the whole, my best buys are dirty watches with bad pictures. Equally the biggest money pits can be dirty watches with bad pictures.

    Depends how much you back your judgement, how much knowledge you have on a particular reference and how much you’re prepared to gamble.
     
  11. connieseamaster May 15, 2019

    Posts
    1,375
    Likes
    1,979
    Why did Omega make unsymmetrical logo designs?
     
  12. kyle L Grasshopper Staff Member May 15, 2019

    Posts
    4,418
    Likes
    11,222
    Dial looks fine - it is a later Constellation with a 71X movement.
     
    bigsom likes this.
  13. Excalious May 15, 2019

    Posts
    18
    Likes
    54
    Appreciate the responses so far. Yes the dial font looks different than the earlier constellations. It seems to match the one which had been in the sales forum here for the same reference, that was referred to earlier

    https://omegaforums.net/threads/ome...66-stainless-steel-167-021-calibre-712.40525/

    I'm inclined to risk it if it ends up pricing <50% of the selling price from that post since the seller states that it is in (at least) running condition and can be returned if it doesn't match the description.

    Is this a Japan-only model? The seller is actually from North America.

    The Japanese sellers seem to offer relatively attractive prices, but I'm hesitant about the mystery import duty comes with them.

    My strategy so far has been to look for headlines with no keywords, photos that aren't necessarily the prettiest, but essentially original and intact pieces. That said, I've been lurking so have not had the regret that can come with that strategy.

    Where is the rusting on the steel? I have not spotted that.
     
  14. connieseamaster May 15, 2019

    Posts
    1,375
    Likes
    1,979
    Light rust locations: edges of the caseback, around the edge of the holding ring at 9 through 10, a bit at 2, and maybe a little bit around the bezel on the front of the case, and around the crown. It's not a rust bucket by any means, but it's definitely seen water intrusion in it's lifetime.

    Japan is generally a decent source for vintage watches as they have very strict authenticity rules for sellers and people generally like *new* vs old. But the intentional low lighting of these photos makes me suspicious that the seller is trying to hide the condition.