I'm a big fan of the '57 trilogy pieces, and have the Railmaster on my list of watches I'm looking for, along with the LE 1948 Seamaster.
But it's your watch, not mine. What anyone but you thinks is all that matters, and if you're going to base a watch purchase on what other people think, you are missing the point, IMO. It's a great watch.
My thought process when this trilogy was introduced…..
no way could I ever afford a vintage 57 Speedmaster or Seamaster in acceptable condition, that ship had sailed.
I love both. Wear them often.
100% the Seamaster is a keeper for me - and I had the same logic. My only regret is I was torn for the Railmaster which is also a lovely watch.
.