Omega Constellation 168.0065 Pie Pan: Worth It?

I think an unpolished one with some dings and scratches would be worth more than one with a polishing job like the one you are showing. That is, of course, only if it is noticeable and disclosed by the seller. If not, I am pretty sure a lot of people will easily overlook it and pay the higher price for the one you show. Even though, once you see it, you cannot unsee it, I think your watch looks beautiful.
To answer your question: One with rounded edges from bad polishing, I would definitely rank below the polishing job you have!

Enjoy it and don't overthink it. With these vintage pieces, we have to accept that not everything can be perfect, especially if price matters.

Awesome purchase, what a great souvenir from Japan!

Hello guys,

A few weeks after getting my watch, I can say that I don’t overthink it anymore and just enjoy it. It’s very clean, and I’ve received many compliments on it. It’s also running really well so far 😀

Reggie_v mentioned that it might be a lug tolerance issue from the factory, which would be interesting. And maybe it even increases the watch’s value? I’m joking (maybe), but in some areas like trading card games (Yu-Gi-Oh I have in mind), factory misprints can significantly increase prices because they make items more unique.

Great to hear. And you've answered your own question, albeit with a different watch from the first post: it was definitely worth it!