Omega 2500(version D?)

Posts
70
Likes
59
Hello all. I am fault finding a non functioning Omega 2500 (I believe it to be version D). Before I go too far with the reassembling process I’d like to get some additional information not found on the Omega technical sheets. It might be useful if I tell you briefly what I know and what I believe I’ll need help with please.

Stuff I know / Docs I have:

  • Omega Tech sheet release ‘H’ for the 2500.
  • Omega Work Instruction 40 (section 7) 2019.
  • Studied numerous slow motion videos of the co-axial in action.
  • Aware the principle is similar yet totally different to Swiss lever escapement.
  • I know the 2500 calibre is based principally on the ETA 2892A2 with various improvements. Im very familiar with servicing the 2892 calibre so its the co-axial aspect I’m looking at here.
  • The co-axial type I have is 3 layer, with thin swept unbaced arms and no braces (sun ray appearance) which I understand to be the last revision of design (?).
  • The process to remove the balance is only as per tech sheet ie 90 degree towards movt centre.
  • lubrication isn’t required to prevent wear, but acts as a cushion.
  • Specific order for co-axial bridge screw tightening (one is a precision locator the other additional clamping force)
  • must not just nudge the pallet horn to and fro to to test as you do with Swiss lever escapement
  • I’ve watched Mark Lovick’s video, but he misses out some essential insights, plus that version of Co-axial is an early 2 layer one.

Stuff Im struggling to understand:

- Should I pre-wind the barrel before attempting to test the escapement?
  • how do I pretest the co-axial escapement prior to fitting the balance?
  • What is the function of the side lever on the pallet fork (it’s visible in a window cut into the left side of the bridge? Is this manual advancement of the co-axial escape using a fine oiler, the equivalent of banking?
  • Before reinstalling balance, which position should the pallet fork horn be set in (toward centre, towards outside or doesn’t it matter?

Sorry this is a long request for information, but I thought letting you all know specifically what I know / don’t know might be an easy way to garner some advice. Any information or answers to my questions would be greatly appreciated please, and thanks in advance.

Kind regards, Darren.

 
Posts
30,325
Likes
78,262
Should I pre-wind the barrel before attempting to test the escapement?
  • how do I pretest the co-axial escapement prior to fitting the balance?
  • What is the function of the side lever on the pallet fork (it’s visible in a window cut into the left side of the bridge? Is this manual advancement of the co-axial escape using a fine oiler, the equivalent of banking?
  • Before reinstalling balance, which position should the pallet fork horn be set in (toward centre, towards outside or doesn’t it matter?
In order...

1 - Yes, of course - you need power in order to cause the movement to advance.

2 - You don't. You do any testing and oiling with the balance installed, and in the special test holder that Omega sells.

3 - This is where the banking is.

4 - From Omega's own instructions...

"Position the pallet fork where locking takes place on the output pallet-stone"
 
Posts
30,325
Likes
78,262
One last thing...

lubrication isn’t required to prevent wear, but acts as a cushion.

Although this is the official line Omega has used, it is not uncommon at all to see pretty significant wear on the co-axial wheel teeth - you need to check those and replace if they are worn. The lubrication does help mitigate that wear.

I'm guessing from these questions that you have not had any training from Omega on these, and as much as I am not here to be some sort of gatekeeper of who works on what, without the correct training and equipment servicing one of these properly will not be easy. I just have received too many panicked emails from watchmakers who thought they would give it a go, and then realized they were in way above their heads, so proceed with caution...

The thing with co-axials that is somewhat related to what I quoted here, is that good performance on the timing machine after service in no way means that you have serviced this correctly. In this way, co-axial watches are very misleading compared to a lever escapement, because if you over oil (or even don't oil) a lever escapement you will see it in your timing machine results. Here if you don't even bother oiling it will look fine, but the watch will eat itself up over time.
 
Posts
70
Likes
59
hello Archer and thanks very much for your detailed reply.

Working backwards here, no, I’m not Omega trained at all, but I wish I was! I’m way too long in the tooth now. If I could turn back the clock by 40 years, knowing what I know now about watches, I’d remap my career path accordingly. I’m a trained aerospace engineer. But that’s been fun too! For me, watch repair started as a hobby 15 or so years ago and I am completely self taught - you have actually played a part of that learning too, insofar as I’ve read many of your articles on here and in the past asked questions which you’ve kindly answered.

I completely missed the note about setting the pallet such that output (exit) stone is ‘locked’. So if I understand that correctly, that would mean the pallet dart is away from the movt centre rather than innermost?

From what you say, there’s no way to carry out even a perfunctory test of the escape whilst the balance is out of the movement?

Regards, Darren.
Edited:
 
Posts
30,325
Likes
78,262
What "test" is it that you are trying to do exactly?

Unlike a lever escapement, there's really no adjustments to be made here - you never move pallet stones for example, and the banking is fixed, so what test is it you are trying to do?
 
Posts
70
Likes
59
Hi Mr Archer.

By “perfunctory test”, I was wondering if there is the equivalent of what I call the “nudge test” of the pallet fork in a usual Swiss lever escapement whereby I use a fine bronze wire nudging tool which I made to gently tease the dart from banking pin to banking pin. The fine bronze wire is far too thin to impart any damage on the escapement and by experience it gives an early ‘feel’ as to whether or not decent power is getting to the dart.

The photo attached is the tool I made from a single bronze wire pulled from a ‘suede boot brush’. I’m sure Bergeon will want to copy it when they see it 😉

So I was wondering if it’s possible to nudge the coaxial pallet fork, then the sun wheel in such a way as to simulate the two balance jewels swinging through ?

My question is somewhat a moot point now, as I’ve stripped, cleaned oiled and re-assembled the watch (paying especial attention to the pallet position and how to load the balance).

Happy to say the watch is now running again (for now anyway), which is an immediate win win since it wasn’t a strong runner and would intermittently stop.

I noted it’s a 25,200 beater, which seems wrong (I believe 4Hz is the best rate) but my weishi 1900 is auto-detecting and is probably confused by the co-axial? It’s also showing 340 amplitude at 52 lift angle which is ridiculously high. What I will say is the balance looks and sounds strong. I’ll slow motion video it tomorrow and get a fundamental amplitude amp reading.

Rate is -4 to -8 across all positions which surprised me for my first off coaxial movement with a dubious history. I’ve a lot to learn, especially the lubrication of the coaxial sun wheel!

Enjoy your weekend Mr Archer

Kind regards, Darren

Edited:
 
Posts
2,684
Likes
2,872
Hi Mr Archer.

By “perfunctory test”, I was wondering if there is the equivalent of what I call the “nudge test” of the pallet fork in a usual Swiss lever escapement whereby I use a fine bronze wire nudging tool which I made to gently tease the dart from banking pin to banking pin. The fine bronze wire is far too thin to impart any damage on the escapement and by experience it gives an early ‘feel’ as to whether or not decent power is getting to the dart.

The photo attached is the tool I made from a single bronze wire pulled from a ‘suede boot brush’. I’m sure Bergeon will want to copy it when they see it 😉

So I was wondering if it’s possible to nudge the coaxial pallet fork, then the sun wheel in such a way as to simulate the two balance jewels swinging through ?

My question is somewhat a moot point now, as I’ve stripped, cleaned oiled and re-assembled the watch (paying especial attention to the pallet position and how to load the balance).

Happy to say the watch is now running again (for now anyway), which is an immediate win win since it wasn’t a strong runner and would intermittently stop.

I noted it’s a 25,200 beater, which seems wrong (I believe 4Hz is the best rate) but my weishi 1900 is auto-detecting and is probably confused by the co-axial? It’s also showing 340 amplitude at 52 lift angle which is ridiculously high. What I will say is the balance looks and sounds strong. I’ll slow motion video it tomorrow and get a fundamental amplitude amp reading.

Rate is -4 to -8 across all positions which surprised me for my first off coaxial movement with a dubious history. I’ve a lot to learn, especially the lubrication of the coaxial sun wheel!

Enjoy your weekend Mr Archer

Kind regards, Darren



View attachment 3438416
That is definitely a test I do, I have an oiler just for that purpose. The idea is "before I mess with the balance again and risk screwing up the balance spring, make sure we are getting a good 'snap' to the pallet fork to make sure I didn't screw anything up so far".
 
Posts
30,325
Likes
78,262
I noted it’s a 25,200 beater, which seems wrong (I believe 4Hz is the best rate) but my weishi 1900 is auto-detecting and is probably confused by the co-axial? It’s also showing 340 amplitude at 52 lift angle which is ridiculously high. What I will say is the balance looks and sounds strong. I’ll slow motion video it tomorrow and get a fundamental amplitude amp reading.
Lift angle is 38, but in any case your machine doesn’t have the capability to read the amplitude correctly. It requires a special program specifically for the sounds of the co-axial, and only professional grade machines (like Witschi) have this capability.

How did you oil the 30 different spots on the escapement?
 
Posts
70
Likes
59
Lift angle is 38, but in any case your machine doesn’t have the capability to read the amplitude correctly. It requires a special program specifically for the sounds of the co-axial, and only professional grade machines (like Witschi) have this capability.

How did you oil the 30 different spots on the escapement?
The weishi 1900 is ‘supposed’ to work with co-axial. From my experience of using it on Swiss lever escapements it is ‘barely adequate’ for my work at present. It will need upgrading if I intend to progress further I know!

I oiled the co-axial escapement as per omega WI40 section 7. That is all I have to work with just now. I’m not sure if there are any other documents that give greater detail? 30 points! I recall doing 16, (two layers of escapement, each 8 arms, one tiny dot per arm). Where have I missed please? Is there an omega image summarising the 30 points you can point me to? Any assistance would be greatly appreciated.

Kind regards, Darren
Edited:
 
Posts
30,325
Likes
78,262
The weishi 1900 is ‘supposed’ to work with co-axial. From my experience of using it on Swiss lever escapements it is ‘barely adequate’ for my work at present. It will need upgrading if I intend to progress further I know!
It will "work" in terms of giving you a rate, but without specific program selections to measure co-axial balance amplitudes, it won't be accurate on that aspect.

I oiled the co-axial escapement as per omega WI40 section 7. That is all I have to work with just now. I’m not sure if there are any other documents that give greater detail? 30 points! I recall doing 16, (two layers of escapement, each 8 arms, one tiny dot per arm). Where have I missed please? Is there an omega image summarising the 30 points you can point me to? Any assistance would be greatly appreciated.
Sorry - the 30 points is for the 2-level, and for the 3 level that you have you place 10 drops of oil. One on each of the lower teeth, and two on the upper pinion teeth.

My questions was more how did you actually do the oiling? As I mentioned this is typically done in the holder Omega has for this specific task - oiled through the dial side of the movement and under a microscope, being able to carefully control the balance wheel to get the escapement into the exact position needed for each drop of oil. How did you actually do this...
 
Posts
70
Likes
59
It will "work" in terms of giving you a rate, but without specific program selections to measure co-axial balance amplitudes, it won't be accurate on that aspect.


Sorry - the 30 points is for the 2-level, and for the 3 level that you have you place 10 drops of oil. One on each of the lower teeth, and two on the upper pinion teeth.

My questions was more how did you actually do the oiling? As I mentioned this is typically done in the holder Omega has for this specific task - oiled through the dial side of the movement and under a microscope, being able to carefully control the balance wheel to get the escapement into the exact position needed for each drop of oil. How did you actually do this...
Apologies for the delay responding. The answer is, I did it with a lot of difficulty and with extreme care!

First I found a very small diameter watch crystal die, and modified it so that pinion and the pivot of the coaxial wheel (top layer) just fitted into a recess I created. The die then became the 'cradle' for the coaxial wheel whilst out of the watch being oiled.

I oiled as per Omega WI40 section 7 using a super fine oiler I also made especially for this job. I loaded this oiler from the tip of another 'medium' charged up oiler as it was just not possible to pick up a small enough quantity of HP1300 from the reservoir otherwise. That was the only way I could keep the quantity of oil small enough yet still in a droplet form that could be transferred to the tips of the coaxial 'arms'.

The process seemed impossible (at least for me) under a microscope as I needed to view from an oblique angle to see what I was doing. I gave up with the microscope and instead used a compound loupe which an old watchmaker once made up and gave to me. It's about 20+ magnification and superb optical clarity, just very little field of view.

I would say I still slightly over-oiled, and as for creating a drop of 1/5 width of the tip width I'd like to see it done! After 6 attempts (washing part each time) I decided that what I had achieved was as good as I it would get by hand.

Anyway, the watch is running very well indeed with 290+ deg amp in the horizontal and 265 deg amp in the vertical (38LA). Rate is -4 to -11 across all positions (after 12h from full wind). Technically it is not what I want as I personally rather the rate to be be overall fast and never overall slow as this currently is. But I am not going to risk everything now by attempting to mess with the 'micro-stellar type' balance system for such a small gain. One mistake and the watch will not run at all! That's for another day perhaps.

Would I do one again? Probably if another bargain comes my way, but I'm going to refine the oiling process first.

You mentioned you do all of this from the dial side, presumably through one of the appropriately positional mainplate apertures? That sounds like trying to decorate your entrance hall through the letterbox!

Do you have any photos or maybe Omega instructions that detail this please?

Kind regards
Darren
Edited:
 
Posts
30,325
Likes
78,262
Okay, well oiling parts like this outside the movement is quite unorthodox, but thanks for letting me know. Of course it's all supposed to be done with the parts in the movement.
I would say I still slightly over-oiled, and as for creating a drop of 1/5 width of the tip width I'd like to see it done! After 6 attempts (washing part each time) I decided that what I had achieved was as good as I it would get by hand.
As I've said before, in the training at Omega there were 5 in my class. One of the watchmakers spent an entire week just trying to oil the escapement on a 2500 correctly just once. He finally did it on the very last day. Of course you had to do it right and get the instructor to pass your work before you could move on. The rest of us serviced 2 complete watches - mine was an Aqua Terra with a 2500, and then a PO Chronograph with a 3313 inside.



Back then the amount of oil they allowed on these was smaller than what the current WI40 indicates, and yes it's tricky, but for a skilled watchmaker with a little practice meeting that requirement is pretty easy, in particular if you service these regularly. Initially they took maybe 20 minutes longer for me to service, but in the end it was really just a couple of extra minutes compared to a regular watch.

Since the version you did is a 3 level, this is what the max oil applied was like when I took the training...



Do you have any photos or maybe Omega instructions that detail this please?

Well, that's what the training is for, and why I generally don't recommend that people who have not been trained, work on these. But here is a movement in the holder...



The hole at the head of this straight pin is what you oil through...



Here is the head of that pin against the co-axial wheel...



And the view of a proper sized drop applied to the teeth...



It's all done under the microscope of course.
 
Posts
2,005
Likes
3,902
I knew Pointillism from the art world, and you just gave that a whole new meaning and set a precision bench mark 👍
 
Posts
70
Likes
59
Thanks for the time you have taken putting this reply together Mr Archer it much appreciated. Honestly I do feel quite envious of your training, and all the special tools you get to work with. It I were much younger it would be my first choice as a career route. I didn’t know back then!

I don’t want to sound argumentative here, so please don’t take this the wrong way, but I don’t think it’s unorthodox to oil this part out of the movement and fit afterwards. My justification for challenging this if based on the fact that if I were to purchase a new co-axial wheel from Omega, it is pre-oiled (presumably by human somewhere) and the data sheet is clear that the part must not be washed as it’s a) treated with Fairite (?) and b) pre-lubricated to specification I can imagine it’s in some sort of mini stillage in the packaging and not rattling around. It also mentions a further lubrication check and addition of oil if needed must be done after 24h of running.

The special movement holder: this looks to just simulate a case but with crystal and dial removed? But I’m confused…. as I said previously, I was unable to manually advance the escapement and it seems only possible when the balance is fitted, since two unlocking actions seem to take place at the underside of the balance. I may be wrong. I only used a fine bronze wire to try, as I was concerned that I might cause damage if I forced the pallet dart too hard. Does the special holder have any other function other than holding the calibre?

Looking at your photos, I am absolutely certain that I’ve slightly over oiled. But not shamefully so. Achieving a droplet size of 1/5 the thickness if the tooth is remarkable! Unfortunately being almost 60 now, I worry that degradation of standards through natural aging might be more predominant than my future improvements. That’s life I guess🙂

Finally… I think I must just say this. My personal opinion of the co-axial escapement is that it’s an Englishman’s folly that has gone too far. Not wishing to speak ill of George Daniels, but I see no reason in a discussion to ever promote the co-axial escapement over and above the regular Swiss lever escapement. In fact quite the contrary. In my humble opinion it’s just a technical virtuoso gone wrong. Something that was designed to reduce the high frequency of events and thus prevent wear, with the additional benefit of requiring zero lubrication. Yet here I am learning just how critical it is to get the lubrication absolutely correct, else the device will eat itself with wear after a while. 🙂. Seems ironic.

Many thanks again for your time and help!

Kind regards
Darren
 
Posts
30,325
Likes
78,262
I don’t want to sound argumentative here, so please don’t take this the wrong way, but I don’t think it’s unorthodox to oil this part out of the movement and fit afterwards. My justification for challenging this if based on the fact that if I were to purchase a new co-axial wheel from Omega, it is pre-oiled (presumably by human somewhere) and the data sheet is clear that the part must not be washed as it’s a) treated with Fairite (?) and b) pre-lubricated to specification I can imagine it’s in some sort of mini stillage in the packaging and not rattling around. It also mentions a further lubrication check and addition of oil if needed must be done after 24h of running.
Is there a document title or number you can provide me that states this? I think you might be misinterpreting something, and no co-axial wheel I've ever ordered in has come pre-lubricated, and I would have expected this information to be published somewhere. I've just gone through Work Instruction 40, the technical guide for the 2500, and the general information document for the 2500 family. Nothing is stated there about the wheel being pre-lubricated from the factory.

I don't know what Fairite is, but the only treatment these wheels receive outside of the watch movement is epilame. There are a couple of different brands of epilame such as Moebius Fix-O-Drop, or Episurf.Neo (I use the latter personally). Epilame is used on most of the movement actually (in a factory setting), and this goes for co-axial and lever escapement watches.

This is not to be confused with Lubrifar. Luibrifar is a treatment that was applied to some lever escape wheels at the factory, primarily because it was more stable long term for watches/movements that would sit in storage for many years before being used. It is a mixture of black molybdenum disulphide and oil. It's very black on the escape wheel teeth. I've never received an Omega escape wheel that was pre-treated with this either. BTW if I do get a watch in that has this on it, I clean it off and oil as normal.

Oiling a part like this, where the teeth that are oiled interact with another part, is generally not done. It would be far too easy to inadvertently make contact and smear the oil to where it shouldn't be.

The special movement holder: this looks to just simulate a case but with crystal and dial removed? But I’m confused…. as I said previously, I was unable to manually advance the escapement and it seems only possible when the balance is fitted, since two unlocking actions seem to take place at the underside of the balance.
This is another reason why I don;t recommend that people without the proper training and equipment service these. I realize this is your own personal watch, so what you do with it is up to you completely - I personally have more issues with watchmakers who just try to wing it on their own, not fully understanding what is actually required to do this properly.

The holders are designed specifically to allow you to cycle the escapement as I've mentioned before. Here are 2 of mine - one for the 2500 and the other for the 3313 chronograph movement:



Inside the holder you will see a small yellow wheel that is attached to the knob that is on the exterior of the holder. When the movement is flipped over into the holder (dial up) the wheel contacts the rim of the balance, and turnong that knob allows you to rotate the balance back and forth in a controlled manner to cycle the escapement completely.

Looking at your photos, I am absolutely certain that I’ve slightly over oiled. But not shamefully so. Achieving a droplet size of 1/5 the thickness if the tooth is remarkable! Unfortunately being almost 60 now, I worry that degradation of standards through natural aging might be more predominant than my future improvements. That’s life I guess🙂

I'm older than you...just sayin' 😉

Finally… I think I must just say this. My personal opinion of the co-axial escapement is that it’s an Englishman’s folly that has gone too far. Not wishing to speak ill of George Daniels, but I see no reason in a discussion to ever promote the co-axial escapement over and above the regular Swiss lever escapement. In fact quite the contrary. In my humble opinion it’s just a technical virtuoso gone wrong. Something that was designed to reduce the high frequency of events and thus prevent wear, with the additional benefit of requiring zero lubrication. Yet here I am learning just how critical it is to get the lubrication absolutely correct, else the device will eat itself with wear after a while. 🙂. Seems ironic.

I agree. There are most certainly theoretical benafits, but as I've learned many times in both my engineering and watchmaking careers, theory doesn't always translate well to a practical end.

When I did the training at Omega, they made it 100% clear - the escapement isn't about improving accuracy, but only as a means to extend service intervals. My own observations confirmed this once I started servicing them. The 1120's that used to have a regultor and a lever escapement, performed just as well as the 2500's did with a free sprung balance and co-axial escapement.

Even more directly, the 3301/3303 chronograph movements that already had a free sprung balance,. ran just as accurately as the 3313's did with the addition of the co-axial escapement.

So whatever theoretical accuracy gains might be there (that people have argued on forums over the years) were absolutely swamped out by the rest of the movement. Omega's real accuracy improvement came with the silicon balance springs - that was a real step forward.

The idea that this doesn't need lubrication is a flat out lie. Roger Smith admitted as much in a presentation given to the NY Horological Society a number of years ago. A lot is made about this escapement not having friction, but then you see it in action...



Is it any wonder that the co-axial teeth wear out?

In terms of extended service itnervals, as I've said many times, the number of watches I've gotten in for service just because the escapement lubrication has failed is easy to tabulate...out of the many thousands of watches that have crossed my bench that number is exactly zero.

Changing the escapement and saying this extends the service interval is like saying because you have improved wiper blades your ties will last longer.
 
Posts
30,325
Likes
78,262
I don’t want to sound argumentative here, so please don’t take this the wrong way, but I don’t think it’s unorthodox to oil this part out of the movement and fit afterwards. My justification for challenging this if based on the fact that if I were to purchase a new co-axial wheel from Omega, it is pre-oiled (presumably by human somewhere) and the data sheet is clear that the part must not be washed as it’s a) treated with Fairite (?) and b) pre-lubricated to specification I can imagine it’s in some sort of mini stillage in the packaging and not rattling around. It also mentions a further lubrication check and addition of oil if needed must be done after 24h of running.
Is there a document title or number you can provide me that states this? I think you might be misinterpreting something, and no co-axial wheel I've ever ordered in has come pre-lubricated, and I would have expected this information to be published somewhere. I've just gone through Work Instruction 40, the technical guide for the 2500, and the general information document for the 2500 family. Nothing is stated there about the wheel being pre-lubricated from the factory.

I don't know what Fairite is, but the only treatment these wheels receive outside of the watch movement is epilame. There are a couple of different brands of epilame such as Moebius Fix-O-Drop, or Episurf.Neo (I use the latter personally). Epilame is used on most of the movement actually (in a factory setting), and this goes for co-axial and lever escapement watches.

This is not to be confused with Lubrifar. Luibrifar is a treatment that was applied to some lever escape wheels at the factory, primarily because it was more stable long term for watches/movements that would sit in storage for many years before being used. It is a mixture of black molybdenum disulphide and oil. It's very black on the escape wheel teeth. I've never received an Omega escape wheel that was pre-treated with this either. BTW if I do get a watch in that has this on it, I clean it off and oil as normal.

Oiling a part like this, where the teeth that are oiled interact with another part, is generally not done. It would be far too easy to inadvertently make contact and smear the oil to where it shouldn't be.

The special movement holder: this looks to just simulate a case but with crystal and dial removed? But I’m confused…. as I said previously, I was unable to manually advance the escapement and it seems only possible when the balance is fitted, since two unlocking actions seem to take place at the underside of the balance.
This is another reason why I don;t recommend that people without the proper training and equipment service these. I realize this is your own personal watch, so what you do with it is up to you completely - I personally have more issues with watchmakers who just try to wing it on their own, not fully understanding what is actually required to do this properly.

The holders are designed specifically to allow you to cycle the escapement as I've mentioned before. Here are 2 of mine - one for the 2500 and the other for the 3313 chronograph movement:



Inside the holder you will see a small yellow wheel that is attached to the knob that is on the exterior of the holder. When the movement is flipped over into the holder (dial up) the wheel contacts the rim of the balance, and turning that knob allows you to rotate the balance back and forth in a controlled manner to cycle the escapement completely.

Looking at your photos, I am absolutely certain that I’ve slightly over oiled. But not shamefully so. Achieving a droplet size of 1/5 the thickness if the tooth is remarkable! Unfortunately being almost 60 now, I worry that degradation of standards through natural aging might be more predominant than my future improvements. That’s life I guess🙂

I'm older than you...just sayin' 😉

Finally… I think I must just say this. My personal opinion of the co-axial escapement is that it’s an Englishman’s folly that has gone too far. Not wishing to speak ill of George Daniels, but I see no reason in a discussion to ever promote the co-axial escapement over and above the regular Swiss lever escapement. In fact quite the contrary. In my humble opinion it’s just a technical virtuoso gone wrong. Something that was designed to reduce the high frequency of events and thus prevent wear, with the additional benefit of requiring zero lubrication. Yet here I am learning just how critical it is to get the lubrication absolutely correct, else the device will eat itself with wear after a while. 🙂. Seems ironic.

I agree. There are most certainly theoretical benefits, but as I've learned many times in both my engineering and watchmaking careers, theory doesn't always translate well to a practical end.

When I did the training at Omega, they made it 100% clear - the escapement isn't about improving accuracy, but only as a means to extend service intervals. My own observations confirmed this once I started servicing them. The 1120's that used to have a regulator and a lever escapement, performed just as well as the 2500's did with a free sprung balance and co-axial escapement.

Even more directly, the 3301/3303 chronograph movements that already had a free sprung balance,. ran just as accurately as the 3313's did with the addition of the co-axial escapement.

So whatever theoretical accuracy gains might be there (that people have argued on forums over the years) were absolutely swamped out by the rest of the movement. Omega's real accuracy improvement came with the silicon balance springs - that was a real step forward.

The idea that this doesn't need lubrication is a flat out lie. Roger Smith admitted as much in a presentation given to the NY Horological Society a number of years ago. A lot is made about this escapement not having friction, but then you see it in action...



Is it any wonder that the co-axial teeth wear out?

In terms of extended service intervals, as I've said many times, the number of watches I've gotten in for service just because the escapement lubrication has failed is easy to tabulate...out of the many thousands of watches that have crossed my bench that number is exactly zero.

Changing the escapement and saying this extends the service interval is like saying because you have improved wiper blades your tires will last longer.
 
Posts
30,325
Likes
78,262
I don’t want to sound argumentative here, so please don’t take this the wrong way, but I don’t think it’s unorthodox to oil this part out of the movement and fit afterwards. My justification for challenging this if based on the fact that if I were to purchase a new co-axial wheel from Omega, it is pre-oiled (presumably by human somewhere) and the data sheet is clear that the part must not be washed as it’s a) treated with Fairite (?) and b) pre-lubricated to specification I can imagine it’s in some sort of mini stillage in the packaging and not rattling around. It also mentions a further lubrication check and addition of oil if needed must be done after 24h of running.
Is there a document title or number you can provide me that states this? I think you might be misinterpreting something, and no co-axial wheel I've ever ordered in has come pre-lubricated, and I would have expected this information to be published somewhere. I've just gone through Work Instruction 40, the technical guide for the 2500, and the general information document for the 2500 family. Nothing is stated there about the wheel being pre-lubricated from the factory.

I don't know what Fairite is, but the only treatment these wheels receive outside of the watch movement is epilame. There are a couple of different brands of epilame such as Moebius Fix-O-Drop, or Episurf.Neo (I use the latter personally). Epilame is used on most of the movement actually (in a factory setting), and this goes for co-axial and lever escapement watches.

This is not to be confused with Lubrifar. Luibrifar is a treatment that was applied to some lever escape wheels at the factory, primarily because it was more stable long term for watches/movements that would sit in storage for many years before being used. It is a mixture of black molybdenum disulphide and oil. It's very black on the escape wheel teeth. I've never received an Omega escape wheel that was pre-treated with this either. BTW if I do get a watch in that has this on it, I clean it off and oil as normal.

Oiling a part like this, where the teeth that are oiled interact with another part, is generally not done. It would be far too easy to inadvertently make contact and smear the oil to where it shouldn't be.

The special movement holder: this looks to just simulate a case but with crystal and dial removed? But I’m confused…. as I said previously, I was unable to manually advance the escapement and it seems only possible when the balance is fitted, since two unlocking actions seem to take place at the underside of the balance.
This is another reason why I don;t recommend that people without the proper training and equipment service these. I realize this is your own personal watch, so what you do with it is up to you completely - I personally have more issues with watchmakers who just try to wing it on their own, not fully understanding what is actually required to do this properly.

The holders are designed specifically to allow you to cycle the escapement as I've mentioned before. Here are 2 of mine - one for the 2500 and the other for the 3313 chronograph movement:



Inside the holder you will see a small yellow wheel that is attached to the knob that is on the exterior of the holder. When the movement is flipped over into the holder (dial up) the wheel contacts the rim of the balance, and turning that knob allows you to rotate the balance back and forth in a controlled manner to cycle the escapement completely.

Looking at your photos, I am absolutely certain that I’ve slightly over oiled. But not shamefully so. Achieving a droplet size of 1/5 the thickness if the tooth is remarkable! Unfortunately being almost 60 now, I worry that degradation of standards through natural aging might be more predominant than my future improvements. That’s life I guess🙂

I'm older than you...just sayin' 😉

Finally… I think I must just say this. My personal opinion of the co-axial escapement is that it’s an Englishman’s folly that has gone too far. Not wishing to speak ill of George Daniels, but I see no reason in a discussion to ever promote the co-axial escapement over and above the regular Swiss lever escapement. In fact quite the contrary. In my humble opinion it’s just a technical virtuoso gone wrong. Something that was designed to reduce the high frequency of events and thus prevent wear, with the additional benefit of requiring zero lubrication. Yet here I am learning just how critical it is to get the lubrication absolutely correct, else the device will eat itself with wear after a while. 🙂. Seems ironic.

I agree. There are most certainly theoretical benefits, but as I've learned many times in both my engineering and watchmaking careers, theory doesn't always translate well to a practical end.

When I did the training at Omega, they made it 100% clear - the escapement isn't about improving accuracy, but only as a means to extend service intervals. My own observations confirmed this once I started servicing them. The 1120's that used to have a regulator and a lever escapement, performed just as well as the 2500's did with a free sprung balance and co-axial escapement.

Even more directly, the 3301/3303 chronograph movements that already had a free sprung balance,. ran just as accurately as the 3313's did with the addition of the co-axial escapement.

So whatever theoretical accuracy gains might be there (that people have argued on forums over the years) were absolutely swamped out by the rest of the movement. Omega's real accuracy improvement came with the silicon balance springs - that was a real step forward.

The idea that this doesn't need lubrication is a flat out lie. Roger Smith admitted as much in a presentation given to the NY Horological Society a number of years ago. A lot is made about this escapement not having friction, but then you see it in action...



Is it any wonder that the co-axial teeth wear out?

In terms of extended service intervals, as I've said many times, the number of watches I've gotten in for service just because the escapement lubrication has failed is easy to tabulate...out of the many thousands of watches that have crossed my bench that number is exactly zero.

Changing the escapement and saying this extends the service interval is like saying because you have improved wiper blades your tires will last longer.
 
Posts
70
Likes
59
Is there a document title or number you can provide me that states this?
Im sorry, I've read so much gumf on the internet (both good and bad) prior to embarking on the service of calibre that I really forget now where I saw it. As you say its not in WI40 section 7. The reason I put a question mark in brackets after the word FAIRITE was because I was uncertain if I'd recalled it correctly (apologies I should have made that clearer). The actual product name, as you went on later to say, was LUBRIFAR! (close eh 🙄). But I still do not know where I saw this - anyway I'm aware there is a lot of misinformation on the net these days, but take your word to be correct. If I find where I saw it, you'll get an update.
This is another reason why I don;t recommend that people without the proper training and equipment service these. I realize this is your own personal watch, so what you do with it is up to you completely - I personally have more issues with watchmakers who just try to wing it on their own, not fully understanding what is actually required to do this properly.
I get that.. really I do. That's why I spent a long time trawling the internet looking for as much information as possible before embarking on this calibre service. I prefer to be Mr Competent, rather than Mr Confident.
Inside the holder you will see a small yellow wheel that is attached to the knob that is on the exterior of the holder. When the movement is flipped over into the holder (dial up) the wheel contacts the rim of the balance, and turnong that knob allows you to rotate the balance back and forth in a controlled manner to cycle the escapement completely.
Ah ha!! Now it makes total sense. I initially saw that as a knurled movement clamp.
When I did the training at Omega, they made it 100% clear - the escapement isn't about improving accuracy, but only as a means to extend service intervals. My own observations confirmed this once I started servicing them. The 1120's that used to have a regultor and a lever escapement, performed just as well as the 2500's did with a free sprung balance and co-axial escapement.
Have to say, the 1120's and ETA2892A2's I've done in the past have always given excellent results with the benefit of easy beat adjustment and simple regulation - without jeopardising the pivot.
In terms of extended service itnervals, as I've said many times, the number of watches I've gotten in for service just because the escapement lubrication has failed is easy to tabulate...out of the many thousands of watches that have crossed my bench that number is exactly zero.
The co-axial escapement being unique to omega brand is just a wonderful piece of marketeering, and that is all - IMHO.

It's been a pleasure to read your replies Mr Archer, and I am truly grateful for the time and effort you have put into this for me and others following the thread. Thank you!

As I sit here typing this reply, I just checked the Seamaster (2500) which has been on my wrist without winding since 6PM friday when I synchonised it to my Apple clock. It's now precisely 11:00PM on Monday and the watch has gained just 4 seconds! So I'm not disappointed with it at all.

Kind regards
Darren