- Posts
- 17
- Likes
- 49
seamasterspeedy
·I've owned six Omega Seamasters over the years, and I thought it might be fun to share my journey with each of them—what I loved, what I didn't, and how I ultimately ended up settling on the two that remain in my collection today.
My Seamaster journey starts with my firstborn, my pride and joy, and still my favorite Omega of all time: the 2254.50.
This was my first Omega and a wedding gift from my wife. To me, it's as close to the perfect daily, do-everything watch as exists. The early 2000s Omega design language just speaks to me in every way, and the 2254.50 captures it perfectly.
It looks just as at home with a suit as it does with a T-shirt and shorts. The size is wonderful—large enough to have wrist presence without being overbearing, slim enough to fit under any cuff, and with alternating polished and brushed surfaces that strike the ideal balance between shine and tool-watch practicality. I've worn this watch a minimum of five days a week for almost 15 years, and somehow it has never gotten old. So now that I've gotten that out of the way and revealed my obvious bias...
About ten years later came my second Seamaster—and yes, there have been four more since then. It's also the only one I truly regret selling: the Aqua Terra >15,000 Gauss.
I only owned it for about a year, but I really enjoyed it. It was just a touch too large and a touch too shiny for me, but it's the only Omega I've sold that I fully intend to own again someday. It's a beautiful piece, and I love the history behind it as one of the first watches to showcase Omega's groundbreaking anti-magnetic movement technology.
Next came the Speedmaster Racing on the rubber strap with the touches of yellow.
I really liked the look of it in photos, but I realized pretty quickly that I didn't reach for it very often. To me, it was a summer watch, and if I'm being honest, I have absolutely no use for a chronograph. Beautiful watch, just not one that fit my lifestyle.
After that came the blue Seamaster 300 Heritage.
I fell in love with this one the first time I saw a photo of it. If I had to pinpoint the reason, it was the lollipop seconds hand. I absolutely love that detail.
Unfortunately, this was the quickest realization of all six watches that it simply wasn't for me. After only a few days on the wrist, I knew it wasn't a long-term fit. It felt a bit too thick to comfortably slide under a cuff, yet the polished finishing and lack of a helium escape valve made it seem like it was trying to lean dressy. It occupied an awkward middle ground that just didn't work for me. I enjoyed it for a short period of time, but I've honestly never looked back after selling it.
Ironically, it's probably still my favorite Omega to look at in pictures.
Then came what I thought would never leave my collection: the 2201.50, the original 42mm Planet Ocean.
I've always loved the Planet Ocean line but never thought I could pull off the size. When I finally bought one, I was completely smitten for about six months.
I only wore it on weekends because I never considered it much of an office watch. It was simply too thick and heavy for my tastes and uncomfortable under a cuff. The biggest issue, though, was that it never fit quite right. No matter what adjustment I made, I couldn't get it to disappear on the wrist the way my favorite watches do.
I loved looking at it in the watch winder far more than I enjoyed wearing it. After a handful of wears over several months, I realized it was time to let someone else enjoy it.
Which brings me to the newest addition to the collection—and easily my number two behind the 2254.50—the 2231.50, the titanium counterpart to my first love.
This watch has been an absolute joy every single time I put it on.
It has all of the qualities I've grown to love about the 2254.50, while somehow feeling completely different at the same time. The titanium construction transforms the wearing experience. It's incredibly comfortable and disappears on the wrist in a way few watches can.
I've generally found that two or three watches is the sweet spot for me. As of today, I'm perfectly content with the 2254.50 and 2231.50, even if they are, on paper, remarkably similar.
Along the way I've owned pieces with both in-house movements and Omega's co-axial escapements. Despite that, I've had such a positive experience with the humble caliber 1120 that I'm completely unbothered by the fact that it lacks the prestige of an in-house movement. It's a tried-and-true workhorse that's reliable, easily serviceable, and has earned my trust over many years of ownership.
If you've made it this far, thanks for reading.
I'd love to hear your thoughts—whether you've owned any of these references, agree or disagree with my takes, or simply want to share your own Omega journey. One of the best parts of this hobby is hearing how different watches resonate differently with each of us.
My Seamaster journey starts with my firstborn, my pride and joy, and still my favorite Omega of all time: the 2254.50.
This was my first Omega and a wedding gift from my wife. To me, it's as close to the perfect daily, do-everything watch as exists. The early 2000s Omega design language just speaks to me in every way, and the 2254.50 captures it perfectly.
It looks just as at home with a suit as it does with a T-shirt and shorts. The size is wonderful—large enough to have wrist presence without being overbearing, slim enough to fit under any cuff, and with alternating polished and brushed surfaces that strike the ideal balance between shine and tool-watch practicality. I've worn this watch a minimum of five days a week for almost 15 years, and somehow it has never gotten old. So now that I've gotten that out of the way and revealed my obvious bias...
About ten years later came my second Seamaster—and yes, there have been four more since then. It's also the only one I truly regret selling: the Aqua Terra >15,000 Gauss.
I only owned it for about a year, but I really enjoyed it. It was just a touch too large and a touch too shiny for me, but it's the only Omega I've sold that I fully intend to own again someday. It's a beautiful piece, and I love the history behind it as one of the first watches to showcase Omega's groundbreaking anti-magnetic movement technology.
Next came the Speedmaster Racing on the rubber strap with the touches of yellow.
I really liked the look of it in photos, but I realized pretty quickly that I didn't reach for it very often. To me, it was a summer watch, and if I'm being honest, I have absolutely no use for a chronograph. Beautiful watch, just not one that fit my lifestyle.
After that came the blue Seamaster 300 Heritage.
I fell in love with this one the first time I saw a photo of it. If I had to pinpoint the reason, it was the lollipop seconds hand. I absolutely love that detail.
Unfortunately, this was the quickest realization of all six watches that it simply wasn't for me. After only a few days on the wrist, I knew it wasn't a long-term fit. It felt a bit too thick to comfortably slide under a cuff, yet the polished finishing and lack of a helium escape valve made it seem like it was trying to lean dressy. It occupied an awkward middle ground that just didn't work for me. I enjoyed it for a short period of time, but I've honestly never looked back after selling it.
Ironically, it's probably still my favorite Omega to look at in pictures.
Then came what I thought would never leave my collection: the 2201.50, the original 42mm Planet Ocean.
I've always loved the Planet Ocean line but never thought I could pull off the size. When I finally bought one, I was completely smitten for about six months.
I only wore it on weekends because I never considered it much of an office watch. It was simply too thick and heavy for my tastes and uncomfortable under a cuff. The biggest issue, though, was that it never fit quite right. No matter what adjustment I made, I couldn't get it to disappear on the wrist the way my favorite watches do.
I loved looking at it in the watch winder far more than I enjoyed wearing it. After a handful of wears over several months, I realized it was time to let someone else enjoy it.
Which brings me to the newest addition to the collection—and easily my number two behind the 2254.50—the 2231.50, the titanium counterpart to my first love.
This watch has been an absolute joy every single time I put it on.
It has all of the qualities I've grown to love about the 2254.50, while somehow feeling completely different at the same time. The titanium construction transforms the wearing experience. It's incredibly comfortable and disappears on the wrist in a way few watches can.
I've generally found that two or three watches is the sweet spot for me. As of today, I'm perfectly content with the 2254.50 and 2231.50, even if they are, on paper, remarkably similar.
Along the way I've owned pieces with both in-house movements and Omega's co-axial escapements. Despite that, I've had such a positive experience with the humble caliber 1120 that I'm completely unbothered by the fact that it lacks the prestige of an in-house movement. It's a tried-and-true workhorse that's reliable, easily serviceable, and has earned my trust over many years of ownership.
If you've made it this far, thanks for reading.
I'd love to hear your thoughts—whether you've owned any of these references, agree or disagree with my takes, or simply want to share your own Omega journey. One of the best parts of this hobby is hearing how different watches resonate differently with each of us.
