Looking to buy Sea Dweller 16600 this look okay?

Posts

775

Likes

715

agee

·Dec 29, 2024

After collecting Vintage Omegas and owning a Speedmaster I feel it’s now time to own a vintage Rolex. I’ve been studying and reading up on Rolexes and trying to decide between a submariner triple 0 or a Sea Dweller 16600
I found this 16600 and am interested in buying it for under $10000.
Please help me by offering opinions on this watch or steering me away from the Sea Dweller and onto the Sub. I do understand that the Sea Dweller wears larger than the sub
Thanks
agee

 

Posts

21,559

Likes

48,860

Dan S

·Dec 29, 2024

I like the 16600, although I prefer the fit of the Sub, personally. My wrist isn't very large. Can't say much from that photo except that it looks like it might be badly overpolished. The crown guards are most noticeable, but the lugs also look pretty thin. The lume looks nice, though.

Overall, I much prefer the 4-digit matte dial references without WGS markers. No comparison.

 

Posts

775

Likes

715

agee

·Dec 29, 2024

Seller states the the watch May have been polished in the past. States a recent service with no paperwork.
Just looked at a picture of the crown guards and yes the are heavily polished.
Thanks Dan

 

Posts

21,559

Likes

48,860

Dan S

·Dec 29, 2024

Compare this case. Look at the shape of the crown guards and the lugs.

 

Posts

775

Likes

715

agee

·Dec 29, 2024

Yes. Big difference
Will pass on the above sea dweller
Thanks again
Dan
Looking to buy a vintage Submariner if anyone has one they would like to part with

Edited: Dec 29, 2024

 

Posts

413

Likes

360

nkhandekar

·Jan 6, 2025

Don't give up on the sea-dwellers. They are awesome watches and a ton cooler than a submariner

 

Posts

775

Likes

715

agee

·Jan 6, 2025

Still in the market for a vintage Submariner 1680 or would consider a Sea Dweller. Contacted Bob’s but most of their 1680’s in my price range are either polished and/ or have replaced original parts like crowns or bezel inserts. I like that their watches are all serviced before sale. Any advice or help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks OF

 

Posts

1,461

Likes

2,354

asrnj77

·Jan 6, 2025

Tons of these watches for sale. If you’d prefer to buy retail instead of buying from a private seller you can check out places like HqMilton.com

 

Posts

21,559

Likes

48,860

Dan S

·Jan 6, 2025

agee

Still in the market for a vintage Submariner 1680 or would consider a Sea Dweller. Contacted Bob’s but most of their 1680’s in my price range are either polished and/ or have replaced original parts like crowns or bezel inserts. I like that their watches are all serviced before sale. Any advice or help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks OF

What is your budget?