Is this watch authentic??

Posts
7
Likes
0
Hi guys, another newbie to the forum with presumably the same age old question…is this watch authentic?
 
Posts
515
Likes
541
Hi, welcome to the forum! Usually a nice way to start would be to share your thoughts and research first! 😉
 
Posts
7
Likes
0
Thanks for the replies and for the advice also @theluckyluke ! My limited knowledge and research lead me to believe that it is prob legit but date was 1951 and almost certainly a redial. I believe I read somewhere else that black dial is quite typical of this and esp as it seems very clean. I’m new to both this forum and also these watches so I do appreciate the input
 
Posts
515
Likes
541
Most black dial out there are refinished, so best to be cautious when finding one!
 
Posts
13,347
Likes
31,468
Dead giveaway of this one is the lack of lume plots at the ends of the applied figures and where the printed (on this watch) squares appear, which should luminous.

 
Posts
7
Likes
0
Thanks guys for your input. It confirmed my initial thoughts esp re the dial. I know this significantly reduces any appeal/value from a collectors perspective (and presumably also monetary value) but as a layman and non collector, I’d be interested to know what a watch like this should be selling for from a private seller. It seemed popular online (60 bids) so I got a little carried away on bidding but it may not be too late to walk away with lesson learnt (check properly/ask first!). From my research it seems the prices seem to vary for these models/variations as original without redial (500-1500) so i gather now that this watch would be worth a good bit less. Nonetheless an approx guide on pricing on this would be most helpful so I can perhaps try to overcome my hastiness and also for general understanding re the impact of repainting for my knowledge. Thanks again.
 
Posts
11,217
Likes
19,663
It’s hard for a collector to value this. Most collectors simply wouldn’t buy it but would probably say around £300-400 max. However, as you say, a lay person who wants a vintage dress Seamaster with a black dial (which are much less common than their silver dial counterparts) would probably pay more. Black redials do sell for what I consider stupid money, up to and over £1000, especially for ‘Don Draper’ devilles.

Personally, I wouldn’t buy it at all, if I had to stick a value on it I’d say £300 but wouldn’t be surprised to see it sell on eBay for £500, maybe more.

I would strongly advise patience and either buy an original silver dial or settle in, do some research, keep an eye on the private sales forum here and buy an original black dial which will be much more satisfying.
 
Posts
7
Likes
0
Thanks for the advice @Davidt and appreciate that the stance is different from collectors to lay persons . I clearly fall into the latter category and my hasty (and perhaps silly based from your view) bidding took me closer to 700 gbp although I do like the look of the watch and clearly others like me do also given the other bidding that was there. I guess I have to decide whether it is over valued for my intentions/situation and make a call on it. Thanks again
 
Posts
11,217
Likes
19,663
Unless the dial was listed as original or there was some other error in the listing, id say the winning bud is binding. These kind or questions should really be answered before placing a bid.