Community Stories

Is this dial a disaster or does it add character?

Geezer
Posts
453
Likes
1,303
To be honest, I quite like it. This is the 28.800 version of the Defy A3651. The case has all the original finish and the Gay Freres bracelet is very nice and stiff.

IMO, this model is so underappreciated.

What are your thoughts on the dial?

20211106_103351.jpg 20211106_103222.jpg 20211106_103319.jpg 20211106_103250.jpg 20211106_103232.jpg 20210810_131348.jpg
 
Canuck
Posts
15,486
Likes
45,862
If you own it and you like it, that really is all that matters, isn鈥檛 it? If you like it and don鈥檛 own it and are considering buying it, then the opinions of others may help. How can suggestions from others, help? If you have questions, ask away.
 
Geezer
Posts
453
Likes
1,303
I do own the watch, and as mentioned quite like it. I'm just curious to hear what others think about it.

On this particular watch, the damage is really from a dial manufacturing defect, something they fixed on later models if I understand correctly. For me personally, this detail does enhance how I generally feel about the watch and its dial condition.
 
Canuck
Posts
15,486
Likes
45,862
With any kind of luck, there may have been a recall on the earlier models where dials were a problem. Very
often, such recalls (if there was one) may only apply to the original owner. Maybe check with a Zenith dealer, or correspond with Zenith, themselves.
 
NotAClue
Posts
278
Likes
356
I find that dial absolutely gorgeous 馃憤 I reckon others might have a very different opinion but if you like it does it really matter?
 
oddboy
Posts
9,217
Likes
24,057
I think it adds character. Obviously, it affects value, but that's a secondary concern.

Of primary concern is that case! Look at that case! So sharp and lovely.
 
jaguar11
Posts
2,710
Likes
17,411
All down to personal taste... To my eyes it looks really cool.
 
wristpirate
Posts
1,243
Likes
3,842
I find this dial very attractive. A lot of these A3651 have degraded dials, yours with the text all visible tips the balance between ugly and beautiful
 
paddymoran
Posts
899
Likes
1,723
NotAClue NotAClue
I find that dial absolutely gorgeous 馃憤 I reckon others might have a very different opinion but if you like it does it really matter?
Yep - agreed, for me it adds character. I particularly like that it isn鈥檛 uniform - and the Zenith logo is clearly visible.
 
Geezer
Posts
453
Likes
1,303
Really appreciate all of your responses (positive or not)!

Here is one more picture of the dial. The printed text is perfectly in tact.

20210810_133449.jpg


Here are some pictures of the movement after servicing.

20210812_131508.jpg 20210812_124939.jpg


Thanks!
 
Larry S
Posts
13,698
Likes
53,501
So this dial is the horological equivalent of a rat rod or heavily patinated Ford Bronco/Chevy Blazer/Land Rover. I like the dial. I鈥檇 look into having it stabilized like the clear coats they use on patinated vehicles.
 
pdxleaf
Posts
6,193
Likes
21,198
Tell the truth, it's hard to even see the dial past that stunning case and bracelet.

After tearing my eyes away from the case I got stuck on the hands!

Then the bitchin' chrono hand.

This is amazing.
 
3 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

Archer

Bit of a disaster...

Archer Watchmaking
CdnWatchDoc
CdnWatchDoc
Posts
32
Views
5K