Is this an original Pie Pan Constellation?

Posts
13,476
Likes
53,021
Fundamentally with these watches it’s all about the dial and a sharp case … this doesn’t cut it.
 
Posts
9,523
Likes
52,445
Fundamentally with these watches it’s all about the dial and a sharp case … this doesn’t cut it.
100%.
 
Posts
33,445
Likes
38,152
100%.
Yep, they should look sharp enough to shave with like this example
 
Posts
6,061
Likes
9,372
100%.
I would put @gbesq 's watch in the rare-bird category also - not because there weren't many made but because of the exceptional condition.
The lugs are so sharp that you could easily mistake the watch for solid gold - which just goes to show how well the case makers manufactured them originally.
 
Posts
8
Likes
3
Thanks again everyone. I have learned a lot reading each of your comments. If anyone wants to sell me their constellation, I'd love to buy it.
 
Posts
3,727
Likes
6,322
I’m going to be a bit of a contrarian on this one.

I don’t care for patinated dials and the case is pretty much toast and has lost any collector’s value as a dogleg Constellation IMHO.

However, if correct, (I.e if the dial started life with this case) the watch itself is a bit of a rare bird.
Arrowhead dials are quite uncommon in any dogleg but this must be the last of the arrowhead dials, which appeared in only a very few post-reference-number-change Constellations. (and IIRC only doglegs)

Would I pay a thousand dollars for it?
Most definitely not - but some collectors might acquire it just to fill an uncommon slot in their collection.
That was my first impression, too.
But after looking closely at the minute markers and the distance to the pie pan edges, I guess it could be the work of fake masters, the art of antiquing at its best and the art of redial.