How to assure a safe transaction between a buyer and seller?

Posts
4
Likes
0
Dear Omega watch enthusiasts,

I have recently been looking for a good-looking Speedmaster 145.022-69 with a hippocampus and a DNN bezel or a 145.022-71 with the stamped medallion caseback. I have been looking for such a piece on Chrono24, but with little success. Most of the examples there are in very rough shape. The bezel is often heavily scratched, the luminous material on the hands is either cracked or completely absent, and the case is often overpolished. Not to mention bezels that are incorrect or service hands with Luminova. The prices are also very high for such examples.

Eventho chrono is the safest place for a buyer imo, I started looking elsewhere, mainly on eBay and this forum.

How do you guys ensure a safe transaction here on the forums and on eBay? What requirements should sellers meet to be considered trustworthy? Do you prefer buying watches in person? When buying online, what precautions do you take? What are your good and bad experiences with buying watches online?

Thank you very much for your answers!
 
Posts
11,110
Likes
55,783
In my experience this forum has been a great place to buy watches. I think I’ve bought six here.

For certain things I pay a premium and go to online stores for my own peace of mind on the other hand I’ve done loads of face to face sales and never had an issue.
 
Posts
767
Likes
924
In general, a long standing member of this forum with good selling/buying feedback is a very low risk person to transact with. While nothing is risk free, I would have more faith in a seller on this forum in good standing than buying from Chrono24 or eBay. There are too many games that unscrupulous people can play on those platforms.

The biggest risk I worry about is an issue during shipment...
 
Posts
613
Likes
1,304
As above, plus I always like to encourage a video call whether buying or selling, showing the watch and identification too. What you’re looking for is a specific and make take time. Don’t rush!!
 
Posts
1,586
Likes
3,153
I've purchased dozens of watches private party and been lucky for nearly 20 years. Used PayPal, Zelle, Venmo, and credit cards through eBay. Never had an issue. It's cliché and maybe pandering, but trust your gut. Don't get excited, blow by and ignore warning signs just because you found your precious. I've sold a few watches and I try to deal plainly and in an open way.
 
Posts
3,686
Likes
8,016
There are several nice Speedmasters FS on private Watch Sales
 
Posts
4
Likes
0
There are several nice Speedmasters FS on private Watch Sales
which ones would you advice? I was looking for a piece with an omega archives extract, as that would partly assure that the movement was not replaced.
 
Posts
4
Likes
0
In general, a long standing member of this forum with good selling/buying feedback is a very low risk person to transact with. While nothing is risk free, I would have more faith in a seller on this forum in good standing than buying from Chrono24 or eBay. There are too many games that unscrupulous people can play on those platforms.

The biggest risk I worry about is an issue during shipment...
Do you have any personal bad experience with shipping on these websites?
 
Posts
2,005
Likes
3,902
is it an occupational "pre flight check" you are performing, looking at your avatar ? Good thinking !

Lots of good members here with history or recommendations so check those listings. The only scams attempts here i am aware of are those private messages from newbies with ; my friend has one and contact etc - just ignore those those and report them to our moderators.

Both Chrono24 and ebay have their guarentee`s and right of return so ususaly good places to buy. Maybe the prices on C24 are higher but a good 69 or 71 with recent service do have their value/price + the fee these platforms charge, also for your safety.
I think you can not have all the safety and quality, And the lowest price.
 
Posts
3,246
Likes
6,802
For larger amounts, I check the transfer details like this: I transfer an amount, for example 6.43, and have the seller tell me this number, then I transfer the rest afterwards to exactly this account.
 
Posts
1,586
Likes
3,153
which ones would you advice? I was looking for a piece with an omega archives extract, as that would partly assure that the movement was not replaced.

I think insisting on an extract is cool but unnecessarily restricting your potential pool of watches. Omega has been restricting and then refusing to issue extracts for some time. Further, the extract has NEVER been intended to certify anything of value. It is a historical extract of a supplied serial number. Unfortunately, it began to afford some additional value and began to take on value itself in the market. An extract can be faked. Part of the current problem with the extract system stems from Omega employees themselves rigging the system and producing questionable certificates. For a watch you own and that you have already performed your due diligence on, it's worth pursing as another aspect of collecting. That is all.
 
Posts
767
Likes
924
I would agree with this. Getting a good photo of the movement to make sure that the serial number is within range (these are very well documented) and that the movement is in good condition is far more valuable than an extract.
 
Posts
767
Likes
924
Do you have any personal bad experience with shipping on these websites?

I don’t personally and the risk seems to be more on the seller side (buyer claims package arrived empty etc) but I still much prefer a transaction with a forum member in good standing.
 
Posts
1,586
Likes
3,153
I don’t personally and the risk seems to be more on the seller side (buyer claims package arrived empty etc) but I still much prefer a transaction with a forum member in good standing.

It's funny. The buyer is rightfully concerned about receiving a box of rocks. Valid and I've been there. As a seller, I'm concerned about exactly what you describe. I've been insisting on US sales and Registered Mail for some time to at least avoid the "it never arrived" scam. Buying the seller, recognizing unrealistic deals, and not overriding your better judgment is a much better security practice than other external services and methods. They're at least the first line.
 
Posts
1,157
Likes
6,717
I always research the seller. I check forums to see if they have a following or particular reputation. I look at how they market their products (their own websites, social media posts, history on platforms like C24 or eBay, etc.). Then, if I’m ready to inquire about a particular watch with a particular seller, I always reach out with questions. This doesn’t just get the questions themselves answered, but I also like to see how a seller responds to questions and if they seem attentive and motivated to help me decide about buying the watch.

If after taking these steps, I still don’t feel comfortable with a given seller but for whatever reason I think they have a good watch that I want to try and purchase, then I might look to go through a third-party platform (assuming the seller sells on the platform), which can provide extra guarantees and buyer protections in the event something goes wrong with the sale. This will usually cost more than a direct transaction with a seller, but the extra cost is theoretically buying the extra protection.

For the specific reference Speedmasters and condition you are looking for, I recommend finding sellers who specialize in Speedmasters. They may not have what you are looking for immediately but they are more likely to have them come into their inventory over time and they are more likely to have an eye toward quality or at least know what collectors are typcially after. Here are some examples of sellers who tend to focus on vintage speedmasters, but be prepared to wait for the right example to come around:
https://speedmastersales.com/
https://www.chronoholic.com/
https://www.vintagespeedmaster.com/