Finally joined the club. New to me Explorer 114270.

After almost 20 years of collecting watches, I finally decided I needed to experience owning a Rolex. I didn't want anything fancy, just a 36mm-39mm Oyster Perpetual or Explorer, nothing else. I hate the Rolex cyclops and I still think my Seamaster 300 MC is better than any Submariner. 😉

After looking at ADs around town and around the country over the last three years, I became completely disillusioned with the process of buying a new version. I found none available in stock, requirements to pay 50-100% in advance to order one, or suggestions to buy a certain amount in other watches to "get on the list."

Not wanting to play these games, I decided to look used and that led me into the rabbit hole of overpriced 20-year old watches with no service history, or newer ones that were selling for 25-50% over retail. I also wanted to trade a 2017 Seamaster Pro that I no longer enjoyed. A few places were willing to take it, but only at a fraction of what I thought was fair (and I'm quite reasonable in my expectations), the rest only dealt in Rolexes.

I had pretty much decided to give up and wait out this bubble, but decided to give a jewelry dealer in Sarasota a try. They aren't a Rolex dealer, but did advertise used Rolexes and said they would accept trades from any "fine" Swiss watches. My wife and I were going down there for our first post-vaccine excursion, so it wasn't out of the way. Because we were going by car, it was easy enough to pack the box, papers, and extra links for the Seamaster "just in case."

Figured I'd find a bunch of overpriced datejusts with diamond dials and smaller ladies models. They had those, of course, but surprise, they also had an early 114270 for sale that looked to be in very good condition. The asking price was at the lower end of retail market rates (thank goodness for cell phones so you can check this on the fly) and it had been serviced last year by their onsite watchmaker and came with a 1-year warranty on that service. More importantly, they wanted my Seamaster AND offered a more than fair trade value.

Guess what I walked out with?



It's currently keeping time to about -1 s/day, so I am very happy.

One other thing about this particular jewelry store -- their customer service was SO much better than any Rolex AD I have ever been in, even before it was clear I was going to buy the watch. Case in point -- while I was still thinking about the watch, they asked if we wanted our white gold wedding bands and wife's engagement ring cleaned for free. They also said they could replate all with rhodium while we went to lunch for a reasonable fee; they really needed this, so we said sure. It was only then that I decided to buy the Explorer. When we came back after lunch to pick up the rings, they told me they had decided not to charge me for the replating since I bought the watch! Now that’s service.

I agree. The fact they were being so nice really made me feel like I wanted the watch. If they had been cold and had “don’t bother me” attitude like so many shops I’ve been in, I probably would have passed.

Great story and love the watch. Congrats!

Thanks, everyone. I put this story out there to remind everyone that Rolexes aren’t particularly rare plus every town probably has at least one jeweler that deals in used Rolexes. Many of these shops aren’t up to speed on internet sales, so if you are patient enough and stop by enough of these shops, you can probably find the watch you want for a reasonable price.