Explorer 6610 with service dial/hands (OR not?)

Posts
39
Likes
76
Hi everyone,

I'm considering to buy this Explorer 6610 locally.

It's a 6610 (case and movement) and the seller tells me that the dial and hands are (original Rolex) service replacements. Based on the famous explorer1016 website, the dial would correspond to a Mark 2 matte dial of the 1016. The watch basically doesn't have any radioactivity (measured with a Geiger counter) and I don't see any lume reaction under a UV lamp.

Does it look legit -as in: as described-, or am I missing any red flags?

Personally, I can live with the service dial/hands (and the slight mismatch in lume colour) if they are Rolex-made the price is right. I know it won't be a proper collector's watch, but I can't afford one of those.

The movement definitely needs a service. It runs at about +50s/d, with high beat error (4.8ms) and low amplitude (204, fully wound).

Thanks and best,
CK

 
Posts
21,581
Likes
48,884
Perhaps there is some distortion in the images, but I am finding the printing to be extremely coarse in comparison with good photos of a legit Mark 2 dial. The E in Rolex almost closed, the UA almost overlapping, etc. The lume in the hands looks to have been painted over with white paint, but that's an afterthought compared to the dial. I would try to get better photos and carefully compare the quality of the printing.
 
Posts
39
Likes
76
Dear @Dan S ,

thank you very much for your reply!!

I took the photos myself with a phone camera and through a 5x loupe. This is as good as I can get it. What you describe is true and it's not a distortion. And you are right that it seems thicker and a bit less precise than the pictures I find on explorer1016. Then again, the details like the diagonal serif on the E in Rolex and the top dash in the first E in Explorer being a bit shorter (and longer in the second E) are all correct. I don't know about the variation in printing at the period. But maybe I really just WANT it to be fine and need to accept that it isn't...

I went through my photos again and below is the best shot I have of the logo etc.

 
Posts
21,581
Likes
48,884
I’m just not crazy about the dial. Since you are ok with a replacement dial anyway, one approach would be to see if you can purchase it a price where you price in the cost of a new service replacement dial. It will be a hard watch to sell, and not one that you need to jump on IMO.
 
Posts
39
Likes
76
If (you think that) the dial isn't an original factory service dial, I certainly won't be going for the watch.

Buying an original service dial is another mine field. Furthermore, this watch has a 1030 movement and I'd assume that the position of the dial feet needs to be different from a normal 15xx service dial. So it wouldn't be a simple swap.


I’m just not crazy about the dial. Since you are ok with a replacement dial anyway, one approach would be to see if you can purchase it a price where you price in the cost of a new service replacement dial. It will be a hard watch to sell, and not one that you need to jump on IMO.
 
Posts
815
Likes
2,223
I’d be careful of the movement as well as parts are quite scarce and expensive to fix them. If it needs any parts (and that probably likely) you are looking at big money. All that for a watch with a dial that has really sloppy printing. And in vintage Rolex, you buy the watch for the dial.