I owe you a follow-up and am glad to report a happy ending.
Short story is the pusher just needed to be screwed on tighter with some locktite applied.
Longer story is that I met with RGM yesterday at 100. I arrived a little early so had lunch at Amato's, couple buildings down from RGM. If you like wood fired pizza, you should try them if you visit RGM.
Roland met with me to see for himself what was up with the watch, while a watchmaker also started looking at the watch.
I planned to drop off the watch and visit NAWCC museum to give them space to look at the watch and to determine if it would be a quick fix, or if it needed to be left for awhile.
They gave me two comp tickets for the NAWCC museum, which was super nice of them. The museum is less than a 15 minute drive from RGM through beautiful Pennsylvania farmland so a must see while in the area.
Before I went, Roland offered to show me some of his collection. I had previously watched several of his videos and developed an opinion that this accomplished and well spoken man seemed devoid of ego. He clearly loved watches and loved making them. While he was showing me his watches, he also seemed to be just another collector who was enjoying sharing his collection. I was conscious that he must be a busy man who was sharing a lot of time with me, but he never indicated any need to rush. He was incredibly generous with his time and it was super fun to run through some of his collection. It was a blast, I have to say again.
A couple take aways from his collection are that he appears to enjoy all types of chronometers and pocket watches. He has unique pieces that were in contests and not placed into production. (There also may be a future RGM watch based on a vintage chronometer, which is all that is my place to share. I hope to see it in the future.)
His other interest in pocket watches has sparked in me an interest in looking more into pocket watches. I have one Hamilton caliber 992 railroad grade PW and love it, but didn't think I wanted more. Now I'm thinking I am missing out on some beautiful watches.
So after about an hour, the watchmaker had finished with the watch. He was able to hold the screw in the pusher tube to tighten the cap without needing to take the movement out of the case, which saved him some time. He also said the movement was in excellent shape without much wear, but it looked like it had never been serviced. As some may recall, the watch had come back from Gallet Service Center, which had claimed they had serviced it. This is the final evidence I needed to deter anyone from dealing with the Gallet Service Center.
On the other hand, RGM is fantastic. The pusher cap looks exactly like the other original cap.
It was such a privilege to be able to spend time there and to be in their workspace while three of the watchmakers were building new watches. There is a real old world artisan vibe about the company.
I did go to the NAWCC museum afterwards,
https://www.nawcc.org/visit/exhibits/, where I saw some watches Roland had serviced, as well as a fascinating special exhibit, which might be of interest to anyone who lives a few hours drive from the museum.
SPECIAL EXHIBIT
Before ‘S-Town’ Made Him Famous, Clock Lovers Knew Him Well
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/07/...unlocked_article_code=1.xk0.3xY_.9VNqr9_RhJSe
The Patek Philippe that Roland serviced for the museum:
https://hs-ny.org/schedule/patek-philippe-grand-complication
The watch maker gave me a hat (made in the USA), which I of course loved. After I went to the museum, it occurred to me that I had missed a great opportunity. So I drove back to RGM and Roland was nice enough to sign it for me. Why not, athletes sign gear, why not a watchmaker? Let your inner watch geek shine!
Here's the final product:
I am extremely grateful to the forum members for offering me comfort and support, as well as for suggesting I ask RGM to repair the watch.
And of course, to everyone at RGM for their excellent skills and sharing their time and love of watches.
It was a long three years but this watch lives again.
(My Glycine Airman and his RGM watch.)
May all your watch dreams and projects come true.