Hello all, my first Omegas arrived today and I'd like your opinion please.
I set out to find an early 1950s Constellation but have gravitated towards the 1960s 5xx models. I don't really know what I'm talking about yet so please forgive any clangers!
They are both steel - a 1961 14393 with lyre lugs (thanks to @dsio and the fantastic Ebay recommendations thread) and a 1962 14900 with dogleg lugs (that was a bit of a punt).
I took them to a watchmaker where I live in Bristol today (Horological Underground) for an initial assessment, to get the backs opened and see what was inside and to book a service. Case back and movement pics thanks to them. I've been struggling to take pics in the night-time kitchen lighting on my phone so any tips would be welcome - probably take them in the day time!
The 14393 first - it's the original crystal, would you have it polished or replaced? Not the original crown, would you replace with an original? Not the original strap or buckle, would you search for an Omega buckle? My initial thought is polish the crystal, don't replace the crown, nice new strap, non Omega buckle and wear it

 

Now the 14900 - it's not the original crystal, would you search for a nos Omega replacement? Not the original crown, would you replace with an original? Not the original strap but could be the original buckle, or I presume it's Omega. Can anyone please confirm?
I'm also really pleased with this purchase. It came with the original box in really good condition and the certificate matching the serial number noting it had "exceptionally good results". The seller's photos were really bad, but like I said in my original post I have a better understanding of how difficult it is to take good ones! The lugs look really sharp but it's difficult to capture in the pics.
My initial thought is replace the crystal with nos signed, replace the crown with the thin decagon, transfer the buckle to a new strap. As I've got the box and cert, I thought to get this closer to factory specification and keep it for special

 

Perfect advice, thank you! And thanks again for the recommendation .. that thread is great viewing

 

Great start to your collection!
Take pictures in daylight. It's perfectly possible to take decent pictures with an iphone depending on the generation. Close ups in focus is the test.


If you want the watch to be desirable to collectors, DO NOT HAVE THEM POLISHED.

DO try to find the right crown. Interesting that @dsio disagrees with me here.

DEFINITELY have the crystal polished if it's original. If you're not satisfied with how it turns out have it replaced. It's not a big deal but I think always nicer if the original crystal is still there, but not if it's knackered. Those pictures would suggest the crystal will polish up OK. If it has any cracks change it.

Strap and buckle is a matter of personal choice. I think most collectors would say that an original buckle is a nice to have, with or without an Omega strap. Where a watch might have originally been sold with a bracelet many will look to pair the head up with a bracelet, but again, it's not crucial. Many people prefer to use a particular type or brand of strap that they find comfortable.

 

Those dogleg edges are really sharp!

On vintage Omega watches the originality of parts add value to the watch so I would tend to look for original crystal and crown. In the case of the 14900 the crown is already original so leave as is. The crystal is quite banged up so probably worth changing instead of refurbishing.

 

Nice catches! The dogleg case seems to be pretty sharp, too - more often than not they’ve lost their awesome shape.

Personally, I wouldn’t worry too much about a non-original plexi, but ask your watchmaker. If he can source one, why not.

I politely disagree - a thin decagonal would be correct. Again, a matter of personal taste but especially with the doglegs the right crown makes a difference to me, as it mirrors the edgy case style. Doesn’t have to be a flat foot logo one (which would set you back ~100$ or so), but service replacements / repros (same shape) can be found on eBay regularly for 20$ or so. Imo that’s worth it.

 

@Engee Thank you! The watchmaker thought the 14393 crystal would polish up ok. Does that mean you lose the logo? Yeah pleased one came with an Omega buckle. I don’t think I’ll be able to resist searching for another one

 

@Deafboy @MtV thank you yes the dogleg facets look really good to me in the flesh. Hard to capture in the pics. The watchmaker said he thought it was unpolished but did hmmm afterwards and say maybe a little. He also said the movement was in excellent condition which was great to hear.
I guess the damage on the lugs is from changing the strap? I wouldn’t have the case polished but would you have localised repairs of nicks like that?
My research so far agrees with @MtV that it should be a decagon crown.

 

Never mind a little nick on the case. It’s 60 years old - let it have a scar here and there.

 

Even better

 

Not sure if the logo is etched onto the inside or outside of the crystal - I think the outside so you may lose it, depending on how it’s polished up. For sure, keeping the Omega symbol on the crystal is the reason to preserve it, for me at least. Crystals are not expensive, so you’re weighing the cost of the watchmaker or their assistant spending time polishing an original against paying for a replacement.

 

Logo is inside the crystal so no problem when polishing.

 

@Engee ok thanks, appreciate the advice!

 

Excellent, thank you.

 

So true. Although pretty, those things are so difficult to grab.

 

Well done, nice watches.

My personal approach to scratched crystals is to have a good whack at them myself with Polywatch. Mostly that works just fine; if it doesn’t (because the scratches are so deep) I get them replaced.

 

Took a few pics in daylight today. Gone for it a bit - got new crowns, a more period buckle and a bracelet. Didn't mean to buy the bracelet, just kind of happened.