Forums Latest Members

Constantinople Greco-Turkish War 1922 Trench

  1. Seiji Jan 21, 2023

    Posts
    1,000
    Likes
    1,859
    I don't know the story behind this watch. Having great difficulty reading this person's handwriting.

    40mm is a rare size in 1920s even for a caliber 15.26. Production appears to be about 1913-1914.

    Similar to one appearing in "Longines Watches" by John Goldberger page 22

    CF8F8E1C-E0A2-44BD-8584-DE25E5641E92.jpeg A7C8AFAD-DC22-4E0D-9F6D-E439791F6F33.png 13D0DB17-2EDE-4197-9384-12FF58715E63.jpeg DCE31A50-2F38-463F-A386-25D7FB8960EB.jpeg
     
    Edited Jan 21, 2023
    michael e, Syrte, Maybe and 6 others like this.
  2. joeshoup Jan 21, 2023

    Posts
    459
    Likes
    2,002
    Clearly a dated dedication in French, as I see "le 4 Nov... / Constantinople" at the bottom. The reflection makes it so that I cannot read the upper two lines, I wonder if a picture from a different angle would help?

    It really is a strangely large size for this period! A similar example, but with different hands, sold at Antiquorum in 2005. https://catalog.antiquorum.swiss/en/lots/lot-104-246

    I would love to know more about the Djezvedjian business in Istanbul, as they seem to have had a long relationship with Longines, at least from the 1890s to 1920s. Anytime know a good source?
     
  3. mcemeren Jan 21, 2023

    Posts
    322
    Likes
    2,248
  4. Seiji Jan 22, 2023

    Posts
    1,000
    Likes
    1,859
    A few of these traded in recent years.

    53B9946E-66F5-42C0-A997-0D47B8B25F57.png 1B553169-6EDD-4CC6-BB24-4F56DB0B9212.png 0A3B1DA2-C18E-4D4B-B146-D9334B12D3BF.png
     
  5. joeshoup Jan 22, 2023

    Posts
    459
    Likes
    2,002
  6. Seiji Jan 24, 2023

    Posts
    1,000
    Likes
    1,859
    7FB4E45B-DF2D-4AC1-930B-CC5AA13F3D30.jpeg

    Still not sure what the writing says. Any guesses?
     
  7. joeshoup Jan 24, 2023

    Posts
    459
    Likes
    2,002
    I see:

    Damasios / Phylo??polous / le 4 Nov 1922 / Constantinople

    The top two lines are definitely a Greek personal name, though I may not have it quite right. At that time, ethnic Greeks were a plurality of the population in Constantinople.

    It was a troubled time: Constantinople was still under occupation by the British, French, and Greek armies, but Ataturk's Republican armies had just destroyed the Greek armies in Asia Minor - this watch was engraved just a few weeks after the armistice in late October 1922. It is easy to imagine its Greek buyer having having some trepidation about the political situation, which was not unreasonable considering the huge forced migrations of Greeks and Turks after the treaty of Lausanne in July 1923. An interesting time in an interesting place.
     
    Edited Jan 24, 2023
  8. joeshoup Jan 24, 2023

    Posts
    459
    Likes
    2,002
    I hope I won't bore you all with more historical sociology, but it is also interesting to think about the use of French by an ethnic Greek in such a personal inscription at this place and time. Surely he spoke Greek, probably Turkish as well. But French was (literally) the lingua franca of educated Turks, Jews, Armenians, Greeks, and foreigners in the Ottoman period, and anyone who was educated would learn it (not unlike the rest of Europe at the time). It's plausible that the whole watch transaction took place in French, though then as now the merchants of the Grand Bazaar would no doubt speak to you in pretty much any language you like.

    France had a long relationship with the Ottoman state going back to the 1550s, and cultivated a political relationship that had both an economic dimension (playing a large role in financing the Ottoman debt) and a religious dimension (in France's desire to play the protector of Christians in Jerusalem and Ottoman Christians more generally). Inasmuch as the Ottoman elite were looking to Europe in the 19th century, they looked to France for education. For instance Osman Hamdi Bey, the great Ottoman painter, archaeologist, and administrator, spent 9 years in Paris first as a law student, then as an apprentice to the painters Gerome and Boulanger. In a sense Paris was one of the most important sites of Ottoman modernisation.

    Anyhow, this is all to point out the extent to which educated Ottomans of any ethnicity internalized the French language as a marker of class and identity. So that when Mr. Phylo??polous bought this lovely watch from Dzevedjian, he chose to memorialize his watch purchase in that language, rather than Greek. In a personal inscription that hardly anyone but him would see, we have to imagine that using French was meaningful to him as a marker of his identity as an educated person of the metropolis.

    Ok, now back to your regularly scheduled watch programming!
     
  9. Seiji Jan 24, 2023

    Posts
    1,000
    Likes
    1,859
    Thank you so much! This is a wonderfully educational reply giving me the historical context of the watch, it's place, culture, and political environment. Perhaps the person who owned the watch may not have been a significant person in history, but the background of the time is great to know.

    If you have anything else you would like to share about Constantinople, I would enjoy further reading. Watches are my window into the past. It gives me an incentive to study cultures and histories that I may never otherwise study.

    Best Regards

    S.
     
  10. Seiji Jan 24, 2023

    Posts
    1,000
    Likes
    1,859
    The name appears to be
    Anastasios Phylactojsoulos. Not sure about the last name.


    Anastasius (Latinized) or Anastasios (Greek: Αναστάσιος, romanized: Anastasios) is a masculine given name of Greek origin derived from the Greek word ἀνάστασις (anastasis) meaning "resurrection".

    A phylactery, seems to be associated in ancient Greek to protection of the souls. Maybe something like an amulet. It is also found in Hebrew where the person in mourning wears a small box like item strapped to their forehead.
     
    Edited Jan 24, 2023
  11. joeshoup Jan 24, 2023

    Posts
    459
    Likes
    2,002
    Of course, it does look like Anastasios. The last name is Phylactopoulos. The root 'phylak-' refers to watching or guarding, and I would suspect that the name means something like 'son of a watchman' or 'son of a guard'. It's an unusual name in Greek. You're right that a phylactery is an amulet of sorts, but the meaning is of a container that protects something. In English 'prophylactic' (a "guard-against") comes from the same root.
     
    Seiji likes this.
  12. Seiji Jan 25, 2023

    Posts
    1,000
    Likes
    1,859
    Ah! I think you got the name correctly! It does look like your spelling. Perhaps confirmation bias, but I do believe you figured it out. Now how to find a person's history assuming we have the correct name?
     
  13. joeshoup Jan 25, 2023

    Posts
    459
    Likes
    2,002
    Well, if we were in the US I would have shared it already! (I do that sort of research professionally).

    But Turkey is tricky; official documents are not readily accessible online and those that are are in Ottoman Turkish before 1924. I read Turkish OK, but even most Turks can't read Ottoman since it's written in the Arabic alphabet and has different grammar and vocabulary.

    Probably Turkish phone books of the late 1920s-1930s would be helpful, assuming Mr. Phylactopoulos didn't leave Istanbul in 1923 like many Greeks. I am out of my depth in modern Greek, but if there are any interested members with a command of local history research there, please chime in!

    One advantage is that the surname is very uncommon! There is a George Phylactopoulos born 1907, who studied at Robert College in Istanbul and helped to found Athens College in Greece:

    https://www.thenationalherald.com/t...ebuilt-their-lives-and-built-a-better-greece/

    George would be the right age to be Anastasios' son. (George's father would likely be in his 40s in 1922, and if he was prosperous enough to send his son to an elite school, he must have been prosperous enough to buy a nice watch as well.)

    But that is just a tantalizing guess. It would be interesting to talk with George's descendants to see if they had a grandfather named Anastasios.
     
    Edited Jan 25, 2023
    Seiji likes this.
  14. Seiji Jan 25, 2023

    Posts
    1,000
    Likes
    1,859
    I thank you again :)

    Seems limited information. It seems the name could be written:

    Αναστάσιος Φυλακτόπουλος
     
    Edited Jan 26, 2023
  15. Seiji Jan 26, 2023

    Posts
    1,000
    Likes
    1,859
    I am beginning to understand the possible significance of 1922 Constantinople and why on such a nice
    watch, the inscription was most likely done by hand by the owner of the watch.

    I found on the outter side of the cuvee another name and date.
    Phy Phylactopoulos ( a female name?)
    ( )
    24 Nov 1922

    The inner side said
    Anastacios Phylactopoulos (a male name)
    ( ) 4 Nov 1922

    I don't think they survived the Greek Genocide and someone wanted to remember the day they possibly died.
    The watch seems to have witnessed a mass exodus of a Greek population from Istanbul in 1922.


    ==============================================================

    upload_2023-1-26_13-24-42.png

    upload_2023-1-26_13-30-36.png
     
    upload_2023-1-26_12-14-0.png
    Edited Jan 26, 2023
  16. Seiji Jan 26, 2023

    Posts
    1,000
    Likes
    1,859
    Edited Jan 26, 2023