Forums Latest Members

Column – The Swiss Watch Industry Is Bankrupt

  1. Robert-Jan #SpeedyTuesday Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    1,498
    Likes
    5,337
    Fratellowatches starts with a new series of articles as of today, columns written by others as well as by ourselves. Columns about the watch industry, watch collecting, trends, design and so on. We start our first column with a publication by Professor of Turnaround Management Jan Adriaanse. Imagine Imagine a world without Rolex. Imagine a world without Breitling. Imagine a world without Swatch. Can you? We can. But are most of the 140,000 visitors of Baselworld 2014 able to do so? We doubt it. When we asked international acclaimed watch blogger-journalist Robert-Jan Broer he implicitly confirmed: “I haven’t seen smart […]
    Click here to read the entire article:
    Column – The Swiss Watch Industry Is Bankrupt
     
  2. blufinz52 Hears dead people, not watch rotors. Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    2,757
    Likes
    6,935
    Excellent article. Thanks for posting.
     
  3. citizenrich Metal Mixer! Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    2,617
    Likes
    5,515
    When Tesla stops offering leather and wood trim or when custom home builders stop putting $55,000 commercial kitchen appliance "packages" in custom wood and organic kitchens, then maybe the Swiss should worry. Wealthy people, and especially nouveau rich love spending as much money as conspicuously possible on the rarest metals, trees and other organic
    endangered materials.

    Ceragold for me, not for thee...
     
    lenny, AuBuyer and Jimmy Jim like this.
  4. ulackfocus Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    25,983
    Likes
    26,974
    The article was obviously written by someone who is a tech geek. They don't understand people who love luxury items made with old world craftsmanship. The industry survived the worst tech wave back in the 70's when battery powered wrist gear was introduced. This next wave won't be anywhere near the threat that quartz watches were because it's not as huge of a novelty. The mechanical watch industry is thriving precisely because it's NOT another battery powered iGadget. Men who can afford a nice mechanical watch will wear a nice mechanical watch, just like they wear nice shoes, belts, ties, etc.
     
    dantaspaulo, AuBuyer and citizenrich like this.
  5. MSNWatch Vintage Omega Aficionado Staff Member Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    6,533
    Likes
    10,835
    Swatch is actually well positioned - continue with the luxury products with omega, breguet etc and enter the smart watch trends with all the technological benefits with the swatch brand. Perhaps have a few crossover products like the modern x-33 but I don't think the high end mechanical watches are going away anytime soon.

    After all the paper bag didn't exactly put hermes or chanel out of business.
     
    gatorcpa and citizenrich like this.
  6. Jimmy Jim Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    194
    Likes
    127
    I can just see some dude flashing his wrist "My jeweler told me that the insides of this watch are an exact replica of a famous one from the 30's with a modern update. That and it is made with platinum, diamonds that were pooped from a rare monkey in Africa, and the strap is made from orphaned baby seals who live on the Isle of Naboombu. A steal at $415k if you ask me, I will probably buy another because I can."


    All joking aside, I see the industry as being stronger than ever. If anything, it looks like most manufactures are rebooting vintage looks and designs driving people like me to dig deeper into the history and discover what this amazing world is all about.
     
    citizenrich likes this.
  7. SpikiSpikester @ ΩF Staff Member Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    3,185
    Likes
    3,774
    Academics often try to stir things up with these sorts of positions. I don't think the author is doing anything different here.

    As far as collecting watches goes, it's hard to see the market for the top end and rare pieces going away - people with money will always spend it on their chosen luxury items. The market for mid-priced watches would probably be where prices are vulnerable if the predicted collapse in interest occurs. Even that would likely be seen as good news for many of us here :)
     
    citizenrich likes this.
  8. MSNWatch Vintage Omega Aficionado Staff Member Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    6,533
    Likes
    10,835
    Also, the fact the popularity of this forum where the majority of the discussion is focused on mechanical and modern vintage omegas is exhibit #1 in support of the strength of the mechanical watch industry.
     
    citizenrich likes this.
  9. AuBuyer Posh Nouveau Yank Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    351
    Likes
    170


    Makes me think of Kopi Luwak coffee. :cool:
     
    citizenrich likes this.
  10. Lex4TDI4Life Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    538
    Likes
    212
    Two boos for the clickbait headline.

    The real inconvenient truth is that most mechanical watches, in an age where no less than 4 non-watch devices are telling me the time right now, are effectively jewelry. I do not see the market for jewelry diminishing absent a worldwide economic debacle making it irresistible to melt down cases en masse. That being said, I am sure someone will hybridize smartwatches and jewelry design (think iPhone in rose gold with diamond accents), in which case they will become part of, not a replacement of, the current horological landscape. The thing is, who wants a $20,000 smartwatch that will be technologically obsolete in 2 years? Mechanical watches are already obsolete. They are worn for completely different reasons.
     
    Event horizon and citizenrich like this.
  11. Event horizon faux seller of watches and complete knobhead Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    661
    Likes
    576
    I thought g shocks were a kind of multi function smart watch and theyve been around for years. Would any of us wear some monstrosity from google or samsung as a watch. Looking at all the high end watches on this forum alone i think the swiss watch industry is safe for a couple more years.
     
    citizenrich likes this.
  12. dsio Ash @ ΩF Staff Member Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    26,992
    Likes
    32,709
    I think what's going to be interesting is if Apple don't just develop battery tech, but actually manage to combine some of the Swiss / Japanese expertise in hybrid power systems (Think Seiko Spring-Drive / Omega's Omegamatic system) and can kinetically power a smart watch to some degree to give either very long, or perpetual energy, in high quality materials like finely finished steel and sapphire, you could have something very compelling. Its never going to threaten the Swiss watch industry though, and especially not the vintage watch world, any more than the Tesla Model S can threaten the classic car world.
     
    citizenrich likes this.
  13. Privateday7 quotes Miss Universe Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    5,753
    Likes
    2,903
    Mechanical watch is probably the ONLY acceptable jewelery a man can have beside wedding ring (well try gold neck lace, ear ring, or bracelet and suddenly rap music blast from background).
    A provocative professor who try to grab headlines by predicting doomsday will not be able to change that.
    Women mechanical is different animal. It is another reason to add jewellery to whatever they have put in their body.
    I think I will not see Swiss watch industry collapsed anytime soon. Not in my lifetime.
     
    Northernman and citizenrich like this.
  14. dantaspaulo Apr 3, 2014

    Posts
    511
    Likes
    429
    CdnWatchDoc and citizenrich like this.
  15. woodwkr2 Apr 4, 2014

    Posts
    1,366
    Likes
    819
    As a younger member who loves tech, I do wish I had two left wrists. I enjoy trying/wearing the latest fitness monitor gizmos (be it fit bit, jawbone up, or the like). They're damn ugly, but I like the data they track. They also look terrible next to a nice watch, so the Up band was out and the pocketable fitbit was kept. It can't do HR monitoring from the pocket though.
     
  16. STANDY schizophrenic pizza orderer and watch collector Apr 4, 2014

    Posts
    16,355
    Likes
    44,933
    Swatch have already started to claw back service charges via not allowing experienced watchmakers parts.

    We all know you will need a new smart watch every time a new iphone comes out.

    Cuff links were supposed to be obsolete 20 years ago with a similar doom and gloom of the young not going to bother ( they are bigger than ever with sales records recently)
     
  17. blackwatch wants tickets to the HyperBole. Apr 4, 2014

    Posts
    438
    Likes
    178
    There's no reason a smart-anything has to be on the wrist.
     
    Robert-Jan likes this.
  18. woodwkr2 Apr 4, 2014

    Posts
    1,366
    Likes
    819
    Careful, I think there's some union wrists up North that might take offense.
     
  19. Lex4TDI4Life Apr 4, 2014

    Posts
    538
    Likes
    212
    And let's not forget that Google glass and its progeny will make smartwatches obsolete in a matter of a few years.
     
  20. ulackfocus Apr 4, 2014

    Posts
    25,983
    Likes
    26,974
    Yes, and anti-gravity transports will eliminate vehicles with internal combustion engines.
     
    CdnWatchDoc and Northernman like this.