Case openers, torque, and how tight is needed?

Posts
6,689
Likes
21,599
I’ve been using my Pahawi case opener on my Speedmaster, which I really like.





I had my Speedmaster at the watchmaker, and noticed he was using a three-prong tool similar to this one, with a handle to open and close the case back:



When I got the watch home, I realized I forgot to ask him to record the movement number, so I went to open it with the Pahawi. It was really difficult. When I closed it up again, I was certain that, while firm, it was very likely not as tight as the watchmaker left it.

This type of tool I also see used by professionals. My guess? Again, it offers greater torque than the Pahawi.



So the question is, how tight is really needed? I guess there are torque specs somewhere, but in lieu of that, does my little palm device, without as much levels the others, close the watch case tightly enough?
 
Posts
2,443
Likes
4,229
O-rings are marvelous, and protect against moisture with minimal torque. Watchmakers routinely over-tighten casebacks, for reasons that elude me. Reasonable hand-tightening using the Pahawi opener is quite sufficient.
 
Posts
6,689
Likes
21,599
I don’t have a torque wrench, so still interested in the subjective experiences of others who may have used one or more of the devices noted.
 
Posts
16,702
Likes
151,178
Sticky ball can occasionally work wonders without the risk of causing any damage,

 
Posts
418
Likes
2,121
I don’t have a torque wrench, so still interested in the subjective experiences of others who may have used one or more of the devices noted.
Let's say your wrench has a lever length of ~10 cm. If you apply a force of 30 N to the end of the lever, you will generate a torque of ~300 cNm (as above). An object with a mass of 3 kg will exert a force of ~30 N when you place it on a scale (assuming you're working at the surface of the earth 😀).

I'm glad you asked -- I was wondering myself.
 
Posts
377
Likes
667
at school they told us to use a tool to close is such that you wouldnt be able to open it with a sticky ball or your thumbs alone.
They DID however say that its still always worth using a ball first to try to open it as its the safest choice.

we were also taught how to both use the jaxa style tool and the desktop style tool.