That's a tough question. The replacement marker is really bad on the eyes, and I wish I could replace it somehow without replacing the whole dial. Other than that, it seems that I can either get used to the rest, or fix it to my satisfaction. Still, the upside is that the gold cap is fully intact, the dial is not refinished, and that a good clean might do this piece wonders.
I guess I need to see it with my own eyes to decide, at least after it is treated by my watchmaker.