AD Watchmaker polished my watch against my express wishes—how to resolve?

Posts
7,536
Likes
13,916
When I see problems like this I wonder why people don't use their trusted independent watch marker. Cheaper and you often speak directly to the person doing the work
Most people don't have access to a 'trusted independent watchmaker', especially if you need specific parts. No parts account often means a compromised repair.

Good ro see Oris stepping up here.
 
Posts
167
Likes
428
Most people don't have access to a 'trusted independent watchmaker', especially if you need specific parts. No parts account often means a compromised repair.

Good ro see Oris stepping up here.

Not wishing to get too much off topic here but there so many good independent watch makers. Many on here that I just have to politely disagree with you that most don't have access to trusted independent watch makers
 
Posts
29,136
Likes
75,290
When I see problems like this I wonder why people don't use their trusted independent watch marker. Cheaper and you often speak directly to the person doing the work

Oris doesn’t sell parts to independent watchmakers...
 
Posts
572
Likes
754
This is an interesting take by ORIS, and one I’ll need to sleep on.
It's not a superb customer service angle, is it? We want to see new dents and knocks so we can void the warranty. ::facepalm1::
 
Posts
572
Likes
754
When I see problems like this I wonder why people don't use their trusted independent watch marker. Cheaper and you often speak directly to the person doing the work
Because, as has been pointed out at least twice above, Oris don't supply parts to independent watchmakers.
 
Posts
23,183
Likes
51,747
Because, as has been pointed out at least twice above, Oris don't supply parts to independent watchmakers.

Yeah, but you could still send it to your trusted independent watchmaker and enjoy a direct conversation with them. 😉
 
Posts
1,144
Likes
3,111
When I see problems like this I wonder why people don't use their trusted independent watch marker. Cheaper and you often speak directly to the person doing the work
I agree, but also shouldn't have to find an independent watchmaker to service your watch. Especially when it's a modern watch. It's been said a bunch of times, this was 90% a communication/understanding issue. Someone should have seen 'do not polish' and sent the watch back unserviced if their policy is to polish watches (to me a silly policy).
Edited:
 
Posts
1,144
Likes
3,111
I'm relieved they have come around on this, and very much look forward to having my Oris back in its original state.
Glad they came to this conclusion 😀
 
Posts
376
Likes
541
That sounds good. U happy with that?
If this all materializes as stated and intended, then yes, very much.
 
Posts
553
Likes
2,760
If this all materializes as stated and intended, then yes, very much.
Happy for you.
 
Posts
177
Likes
169
If this all materializes as stated and intended, then yes, very much.
If you need it distressed, just ask..
 
Posts
228
Likes
2,027
Glad to hear they are finally trying to make it right. It's a shame it took so much effort on your part to convince them to do so.
 
Posts
3,998
Likes
9,015
It's not a superb customer service angle, is it? We want to see new dents and knocks so we can void the warranty. ::facepalm1::

not feeling terribly superb, no 😁

from the perspective of ‘don’t expect too much from a business’ I couldn’t blame them for thinking it, but rather silly of anyone to say it

 
Posts
29,136
Likes
75,290
Well in this example and 90% of services that parts arent needed? Clean, lub and adjust? Isn't this the movement https://calibercorner.com/sellita-caliber-sw200/

Not made by Oris so parts available?

Well, not sure where you get that statistic from, but in my experience as a watchmaker, it’s actually the opposite. I would say 90% or more of the watches I service needs parts of some kind. This is excepting the mainspring, which is replaced at every service.

People very often make the same mistake you are here, looking at just the movement. But case parts are the real problem when you have a watch that uses a common movement and the brand won’t sell parts. So if a new crown, case tube, crystal, dial, hands are needed, you are out of luck. Sometimes things like seals are non standard as well. As I’ve said already in this thread, I used to buy Oris specific parts from them when they did sell them, but that all changed maybe 10 years ago or so.
 
Posts
376
Likes
541
*final update*

AD called me over the weekend, telling me I could come collect the watch—including its new case. Happy to end this saga on a positive note, glad Oris was willing to make things right. Thanks to @joshshanks for initiating contact, @tyrantlizardrex for blowing the whistle on this and all your kind and encouraging posts here.

So happy to have my beater back—pictured below on a NOS vintage RRL nato 😎

 
Posts
1,698
Likes
1,653
So glad this worked out as well as possible!

Clearly the real lesson is to avoid watches made by brands that don't sell parts to independent watchmakers...
 
Posts
365
Likes
1,079
Clearly the real lesson is to avoid watches made by brands that don't sell parts to independent watchmakers...

Unfortunately, I anticipate this list will only continue to grow longer…
 
Posts
553
Likes
2,760
*final update*

AD called me over the weekend, telling me I could come collect the watch—including its new case. Happy to end this saga on a positive note, glad Oris was willing to make things right. Thanks to @joshshanks for initiating contact, @tyrantlizardrex for blowing the whistle on this and all your kind and encouraging posts here.

So happy to have my beater back—pictured below on a NOS vintage RRL nato 😎


Congratulations. The main thing is you are happy with the outcome. You can now enjoy your watch again.