2913 FAP from Phillips - from swan to ugly duckling

Posts
215
Likes
923
I think this post clearly shows that paying the most at auction doesn't necessarily equate to coming home with the best possible watch!
Indeed. Still it is the only way for some people. Great watches are rarely available on the open market so if you don't know collectors or get super lucky; quality auctions is your best bet.

You can find anything if you put in enough time, have enough patience, and gather enough knowledge.
To a certain point yes. 😀
 
Posts
2,578
Likes
11,935
Not wanting to find my collar felt by anyone’s legal team, and having skirted around this in both my posts... I suspect that the auction house knew exactly what they were selling... or at least enough to no longer have plausible deniability... and listed it as “genuine” anyway.

It’s disappinting, but then hardly shocking... where there’s buckets of money with the possibility of making more, you find people willing to do questionable things to keep those buckets filling.

If the "respectable" auction houses are doing this I don't want to know what goes on at other less "respectable". Or I kind of know since I worked at one when in high school. One of the staff knew a very capable booze runner, so lots of single malt at great prices for everybody 😒
 
Posts
4,114
Likes
16,316
I guess the fun is having the best possible watch. Not all of us are able to find these in the wild.

I believe all of us are able to find these in the wild. And sorry but buying a watch from an auction house isn't finding, it's simply buying and buying is boring. 😒
 
Posts
8,890
Likes
28,366
If the "respectable" auction houses are doing this I don't want to know what goes on at other less "respectable". Or I kind of know since I worked at one when in high school. One of the staff knew a very capable booze runner, so lots of single malt at great prices for everybody 😒


I’m not sure that being very well financially backed, and having swanky offices in expensive locations necessarily means they’re respectable. 😉

Who’s smoke and mirrors are these? 😁
 
Posts
215
Likes
923
I believe all of us are able to find these in the wild. And sorry but buying a watch from an auction house isn't finding, it's simply buying and buying is boring. 😒
Depending on what you hunt for I can promise you that not everyone is able to find the watch "in the wild". For quite common things; yes. For very rare examples in excellent condition; most likely no.

Buying from an auction house is more difficult than buying from a dealer or fellow collector. For what it is worth. That said I usually don't buy through auction houses but depending on what you hunt; it could be an as good channel as any. You need luck to find certain watches. Regardless if it is "in the wild", through collector buddies/dealers or from auction houses.

In this case I think the seller is responsible for the bad description. The watch was put together to make the most money. It is naive to think the auction house would have gotten the watch if they described it correct. Then it would have bounced to Christies and if they also wanted to describe it as a put together piece it would have ended up at AQ where anything goes. Phillips did a shit job but the seller is the real crook.
Edited:
 
Posts
5,298
Likes
24,229
I believe all of us are able to find these in the wild. And sorry but buying a watch from an auction house isn't finding, it's simply buying and buying is boring. 😒


show me the last in the wild examples of A racing dial, a soleil dial or an Alaska project

unfortunately only with the auctioneers.

incidentally if you want to know how good the people at the auction house are…watch what happens to them when they leave to become independent

some survive.
 
Posts
2,548
Likes
6,996
Naive question from someone not familiar with auctions, but is the seller publicly known?
 
Posts
2,548
Likes
6,996
........, it's simply buying and buying is boring. 😒

Hey, that is called retail therapy and here in the US is an acknowledged phenomenon.

😁😀
Edited:
 
Posts
461
Likes
353
Not employing experts for verification purposes is one thing but neglecting due diligence is entirely another

Kox’s exemplary data base garnered from the public domain is a minimal starting point for any house ,and given their unrivalled access to other private and privileged sources they should be more than capable of establishing reasonable provenance

In the art world, confirmation of authenticity is almost always sort from outside subject matter experts

I submit they could do no better then asking the forum whose members are unquestionably the pinnacle of such knowledge

One small point is that if ever anyone is consulted it might be best not to end the consultations with the word ‘dibs’ ..just a thought
 
Posts
8,890
Likes
28,366
Not employing experts for verification purposes is one thing but neglecting due diligence is entirely another

Agreed... which leads me to believe that they knew exactly what they were selling...
 
Posts
215
Likes
923
Not employing experts for verification purposes is one thing but neglecting due diligence is entirely another

Kox’s exemplary data base garnered from the public domain is a minimal starting point for any house ,and given their unrivalled access to other private and privileged sources they should be more than capable of establishing reasonable provenance

In the art world, confirmation of authenticity is almost always sort from outside subject matter experts

I submit they could do no better then asking the forum whose members are unquestionably the pinnacle of such knowledge

One small point is that if ever anyone is consulted it might be best not to end the consultations with the word ‘dibs’ ..just a thought
Just speculating here but I would hold it highly likely that the Davidoff brothers as well as other dealers consult auction houses reguarly.
 
Posts
4,114
Likes
16,316
show me the last in the wild examples of A racing dial, a soleil dial or an Alaska project

unfortunately only with the auctioneers.

Let me kindly disagree. But here are my arguments 😀

@MaiLollo bought a racing dial from a Craigslist like website in France. I have been offered one Grey and one black in the last twelve months.

A friend of mine here in CH bought a soleil dial as well as a Grey dial from old people (no clue if they were first owners or not and I don’t care) both in 2017.

Alaska radial dial with engraved numbers on the case back has been offered to my watchmaker’s sales guy at the store by gypsies here in CH - the sales guy didn’t know what it is and declined the offer. No BS - the guy made photos, I saw them, he also almost got fired because of that 😁 Also in 2017.

What a year !!! Not really... they are simply out there. 😗
 
Posts
5,298
Likes
24,229
Wow, that’s good to hear!
 
Posts
603
Likes
2,567
Let me kindly disagree. But here are my arguments 😀

@MaiLollo bought a racing dial from a Craigslist like website in France. I have been offered one Grey and one black in the last twelve months.

A friend of mine here in CH bought a soleil dial as well as a Grey dial from old people (no clue if they were first owners or not and I don’t care) both in 2017.

Alaska radial dial with engraved numbers on the case back has been offered to my watchmaker’s sales guy at the store by gypsies here in CH - the sales guy didn’t know what it is and declined the offer. No BS - the guy made photos, I saw them, he also almost got fired because of that 😁 Also in 2017.

What a year !!! Not really... they are simply out there. 😗

They are...but seem to be much more frequently out there in Europe than in the States.
 
Posts
1,560
Likes
4,419
Let me kindly disagree. But here are my arguments 😀

@MaiLollo bought a racing dial from a Craigslist like website in France. I have been offered one Grey and one black in the last twelve months.

A friend of mine here in CH bought a soleil dial as well as a Grey dial from old people (no clue if they were first owners or not and I don’t care) both in 2017.

Alaska radial dial with engraved numbers on the case back has been offered to my watchmaker’s sales guy at the store by gypsies here in CH - the sales guy didn’t know what it is and declined the offer. No BS - the guy made photos, I saw them, he also almost got fired because of that 😁 Also in 2017.

What a year !!! Not really... they are simply out there. 😗
Hello there 😁
I think that the main difference between watches found in the wild and watches found in auction houses are the people looking at them. I'd bet that I'm not the target audience for Aurel Bacs' auctions. And that's cool. You can find gems and turds both in the wild and in prepared auction houses 😉
The wild is much more time consuming, much more boring since you have to go through a lot of crap. Sometimes it pays off, and if you enjoy the hunt, then you're all set 😀
 
Posts
168
Likes
126
They are...but seem to be much more frequently out there in Europe than in the States.

I was about to say, it seems the lesson here is to live in Switzerland to be able to get more chances at those hard to find watches 😁. Or Italy for that matter, as I see a lot of Omega watches come out of there for sale.
 
Posts
5,054
Likes
15,573
I was about to say, it seems the lesson here is to live in Switzerland to be able to get more chances at those hard to find watches 😁. Or Italy for that matter, as I see a lot of Omega watches come out of there for sale.

No it’s not. The lesson is : knowing the right people - your network. I live in Switzerland and I haven’t seen nor been offered Soleil dials, racings, Alaska’s or the like. I don’t know any old people, nor do I have watchmaker or dealer friends, or even have friends who care about watches. I hunt all the regular channels here, same as most people and there is 99.9% crap.

Edit : ...and persistent wolf-like hunting -> being the first person to snap up the 0.1% that’s not crap.
Edited:
 
Posts
1,300
Likes
3,086
No it’s not. The lesson is : knowing the right people - your network. I live in Switzerland and I haven’t seen nor been offered Soleil dials, racings, Alaska’s or the like. I don’t know any old people, nor do I have watchmaker or dealer friends, or even have friends who care about watches. I hunt all the regular channels here, same as most people and there is 99.9% crap.


I totally agree but I am lucky enough to be friends with a well respected watchmaker and get contacts or pieces through him.
 
Posts
4,114
Likes
16,316
I live in Switzerland and I haven’t seen nor been offered Soleil dials, racings, Alaska’s or the like. I don’t know any old people, nor do I have watchmaker or dealer friends, or even have friends who care about watches. I hunt all the regular channels here, same as most people and there is 99.9% crap.

Let me smile @eugeneandresson ::stirthepot:: - this year you've snapped a superb 105.002, a 105.003, a 145.022-82, a #ST, a Tintin - stop trolling 😉

Well done, dude 👍