Forums Latest Members

(200th post) A comparative analysis: Eterna Czech Air Force watch and Eterna Heritage Military 1939

  1. Braindrain Jun 11, 2019

    Posts
    735
    Likes
    1,279
    I was thinking what to do for the 200th post and also how to share my newest acquisition. While it's easy enough to just say "Hey, here's my 200th" or "Hey, here's my newest", I wanted to do something a bit different.

    So, I thought I'd share my newest with a comparison against a re-issue.

    For your consideration is an Eterna Czech Air Force (CAF) watch, commonly known as a Majetek. In 2014, Eterna decided to reissue this watch in both a SS and PVD version. While there have been many posts dedicated to either, there hasn't really been any post comparing them side by side.

    First off, I won't be going into the history of the Eterna CAF. Donkii did an excellent job of that, as well as fredchrono.
    https://omegaforums.net/threads/eterna-majetek-a-journey-thru-time-ww2.35055/
    https://chronographes.net/2018/02/22/eterna-type-majetek/

    Long story short, there were 3 watches issued to the CAF - Longines, Lemania, and Eterna. While past thinking was that only the Longines was issued, that thinking has evolved. Current thinking is that Eternas with the crossed swords at the 11pm lug are issued.

    For the comparison itself, I'll start off with an archive photo from Eterna.
    Eterna-Heritage-Military-limited-edition-watch-1 copy.jpg


    Next, a photo of my newest. This photo is courtesy of tmw57 (Todd) as he obviously possesses photog skills that I don't have.

    XowYm9W copy.jpg

    Next, time to find an Eterna reissue in the flesh. It's actually harder than it sounds but I tracked one down at my local Eterna AD (Time & Gold, in Vancouver). They had the PVD version, which was fine. Just a warning that my (previously mentioned) poor photog skills didn't allow great pictures of the PVD case.
    P1360275 copy.jpg

    P1360278 copy.jpg


    Here they are side by side. The CAF is 38.5mm wide (40mm with crown) with lug-to-lug of 48mm. The reissue is 40mm wide with 50mm lug-to-lug. Sorry, didn't have a digital calipers with me so couldn't measure the width with crown.

    While it doesn't sound like much, you can see the difference when they're together.
    P1360265 copy.jpg


    The thickness gets a little hairy. I have, what I believe to be, an original (top hat, to borrow Rolex terminology) crystal on my CAF. Donkii's post also has a similar crystal. Many out there have a domed crystal, which may be a replacement. Of course, nobody is 100% sure. With my crystal, thickness is approximately 11mm. The reissue has a thickness of 11.7mm, so not much difference there.
    P1360241 copy.jpg


    Strangely enough, lug width on the CAF is 21mm while the reissue is 20mm. It's personal preference which is in better proportion.
    P1360257 copy.jpg
    P1360262 copy.jpg


    The reissue tries to recreate the shape of the original crown, but adds the distinctive Eterna 5 star logo.
    P1360270 copy.jpg
    P1360269 copy.jpg


    The caseback? Well, it's what you'd expect it to be. CAF to be an issued number while the reissue commemorates the watch.
    P1360284 copy.jpg

    P1360281 copy.jpg


    Lastly, is lume. On many of the CAF, the radium lume has been removed. Luckily, the lume on mine remains. Of course, the radium has long since burned out the luminous paint but it still glows under UV. Although faded to a nice yellow patina in daytime, it glows a strong green under UV. For the reissue, SL is used and also glows green under UV.
    P1360287 copy.jpg

    P1360288 copy.jpg


    I don't have a movement shot of my CAF as I don't want to screw around (pun intended) opening casebacks with radium dials. However, the CAF used the Eterna Cal 852S while the reissue uses a modern ETA 2824.

    And, a parting shot with them side-by-side, glowing brightly.
    P1360317 copy.jpg


    And, to add that I'm far from an expert on these watches so will happily make any corrections in my post.

    I hope you've enjoyed my 200th.

    Kendall
     
  2. Ludi Jun 11, 2019

    Posts
    2,109
    Likes
    27,122
    Great 200th post, and very interesting reading :thumbsup:

    Yours is a killer watch rarely seen in this condition. Congrats ^^
     
    Braindrain likes this.
  3. Dan S Jun 11, 2019

    Posts
    18,952
    Likes
    43,573
    The Eterna is actually my favorite of the Czech pilots. It's a better size to wear compared to the Longines, and more appealing than the Lemania.

    eterna_czech1.jpg
     
    Braindrain likes this.
  4. Braindrain Jun 11, 2019

    Posts
    735
    Likes
    1,279
    Thanks! I'm surprised I was able to get it, really.