Community Stories

1958 Ranchero 2990-1 HELP / ADVICE / GUIDANCE

T
Posts
43
Likes
26
I have come across this 2990-1 Ranchero . I’m needing some help to identify any signs of it being a FAKE . the movement is correct as per my research “ 267 “ and “16621004” when searched is coming up with 1958 as it should just wanting any help / stand out details about this particular watch / dial that is standing out to be fake / Vietnam special ??

What I’ve learned so far but I could be wrong ??

-The numbers are painted on and not lume
- Swiss made ( no T’s )
- possibly the sub seconds hand should be white ( but from other angles looks between black and white but I think it’s silver to be fair )
- case looks polished but possibly fake special ?
- no signed crystal ( read that these 2990 - 1 sometimes came without and sometimes with but no certainty with that )


the seller has only replaced the crown with a generic one as when he received it that was the only issue . But if anyone has anything to point out please do any more photos just let me know

Thanks heaps . Any help is very appreciated!
Edited:
 
IMG_7890.jpeg IMG_7889.jpeg IMG_7877.jpeg IMG_7876.jpeg IMG_7875.jpeg IMG_7874.jpeg IMG_7866.jpeg IMG_7865.jpeg IMG_7869.jpeg IMG_7868.jpeg IMG_7870.jpeg IMG_7871.jpeg IMG_7872.jpeg IMG_7926.jpeg IMG_7928.jpeg IMG_7920.jpeg IMG_7919.jpeg IMG_7917.jpeg IMG_7911.jpeg IMG_7914.jpeg IMG_7926.jpeg IMG_7929.jpeg IMG_7918.jpeg IMG_7919.jpeg IMG_7920.jpeg IMG_7912.jpeg IMG_7914.jpeg IMG_7913.jpeg IMG_7917.jpeg IMG_7916.jpeg IMG_7910.jpeg IMG_7909.jpeg IMG_7911.jpeg
gbesq
Posts
9,737
Likes
54,440
Movement and serial number are correct for a Ranchero, but you would need an extract from the archives to make sure that you don't have a swapped movement. The EOA serial number should match the movement and should specifically state that the watch is a Ranchero. I think that the dial is authentic, but I suspect that the markers have been relumed because the lume color is quite bright and differs from the lume on the hands. Typically, the lume on a black dialed Ranchero is pumpkin or rust colored. Also, the markers don't look uniform to me and the ends are rounded instead of coming to a point. The hour and minute hands look correct. The subsecond hand should definitely be white in color. I can't tell whether it's simply an incorrect replacement or whether it's the original and the paint has worn off. The case doesn't necessarily look polished to me, but it's not in the best of shape. Typically for a Ranchero, you have high polish on the top of the lugs and a satin finish on the sides of the case, but I have seen some examples where the top has a grained texture. The crown is also incorrect and should be the bowler hat type. You are correct that the crystal need not have the etched Omega logo. Many legitimate examples do not. The inscription on the case back is a negative in my opinion. Typically, there should only be the circular brushing and the word WATERPROOF in capitals. Because the lume should be radium based, I would suggest that you have the watch tested with a Geiger counter. If the lume is radium, the Geiger counter should be quite active when exposed to the dial. Are there any service records and what's the asking price? I've attached a few photos of my Ranchero for comparison.
IMG_6994.jpeg IMG_6993.jpeg IMG_6992.jpeg IMG_6991.jpeg IMG_6995.jpeg
Edited:
 
T
Posts
43
Likes
26
gbesq gbesq
Movement and serial number are correct for a Ranchero, but you would need an extract from the archives to make sure that you don't have a swapped movement. The EOA serial number should match the movement and should specifically state that the watch is a Ranchero. I think that the dial is authentic, but I suspect that the markers have been relumed because the lume color is quite bright and differs from the lume on the hands. Typically, the lume on a black dialed Ranchero is pumpkin or rust colored. Also, the markers don't look uniform to me and the ends are rounded instead of coming to a point. The hour and minute hands look correct. The subsecond hand should definitely be white in color. I can't tell whether it's simply an incorrect replacement or whether it's the original and the paint has worn off. The case doesn't necessarily look polished to me, but it's not in the best of shape. Typically for a Ranchero, you have high polish on the top of the lugs and a satin finish on the sides of the case, but I have seen some examples where the top has a grained texture. The crown is also incorrect and should be the bowler hat type. You are correct that the crystal need not have the etched Omega logo. Many legitimate examples do not. The inscription on the case back is a negative in my opinion. Typically, there should only be the circular brushing and the word WATERPROOF in capitals. Because the lume should be radium based, I would suggest that you have the watch tested with a Geiger counter. If the lume is radium, the Geiger counter should be quite active when exposed to the dial. Are there any service records and what's the asking price? I've attached a few photos of my Ranchero for comparison.
IMG_6994.jpeg IMG_6993.jpeg IMG_6992.jpeg IMG_6991.jpeg IMG_6995.jpeg

Thanks a lot for the response , correct I had
My issues because it was in such good condition . I will attach some more photos in my eyes atm it’s looking a lot more pumpkin colour than rust I think . I have another omega 1967 seamster 300 I will be getting extracts for also so I will probably go that route I think at the same time drop this one in .

I will attach another photo of the sub second hand and to me it kind of looks like the white has flaked off of it possible but I will get experts opinions .

and yes I agree the caseback inscription is an afterthought from someone perhaps but is not too bad but yet just making sure of a few things before I get to deep and fall in love with a fake
 
IMG_7982.jpeg IMG_7980.jpeg
Dsplash
Posts
738
Likes
1,023
Lume looks possible to me but I would ask for either a video under uv light (radium should glow green progressively but stop immediately when the uv is turned off) and/or a Geiger counter video (it should go quite high with radium)
 
T
Posts
43
Likes
26
Dsplash Dsplash
Lume looks possible to me but I would ask for either a video under uv light (radium should glow green progressively but stop immediately when the uv is turned off) and/or a Geiger counter video (it should go quite high with radium)

appreciate the comments mate , I have a friend on Monday I will take over a put it past the Geiger , and I will try to find a if torch
 
Davidt
Posts
13,199
Likes
22,952
Do you have any more pictures?

Just kidding - I’d forgot your question by the time I managed to scroll to the end!

The dial looks original and I’d wager the lume is too. Radium in such good condition does set alarm bells ringing, particularly if there are areas that look heavily worn of shoe moisture ingress. However, the movement looks very clean and bright with very little tarnish or evidence of water ingress.so, if I had to say one way or another, I’d say all original.

The mid-matched colour on the hands wouldn’t concern me. Many hands have original lume which has aged a different shade to the dial (often darker). I’m more concerned with perfectly matching lume on the dial and hands which is commonly seen in many dealer prepared vintage Rolexes.

Depending on the price it could be a good buy. What’s the seller say about it?
 
T
Posts
43
Likes
26
Davidt Davidt
Do you have any more pictures?

Just kidding - I’d forgot your question by the time I managed to scroll to the end!

The dial looks original and I’d wager the lume is too. Radium in such good condition does set alarm bells ringing, particularly if there are areas that look heavily worn of shoe moisture ingress. However, the movement looks very clean and bright with very little tarnish or evidence of water ingress.so, if I had to say one way or another, I’d say all original.

The mid-matched colour on the hands wouldn’t concern me. Many hands have original lume which has aged a different shade to the dial (often darker). I’m more concerned with perfectly matching lume on the dial and hands which is commonly seen in many dealer prepared vintage Rolexes.

Depending on the price it could be a good buy. What’s the seller say about it?

ahahaha I won’t flood anymore I don’t want to be one of those guys with not enough pictures and some half assed questions aha .

that was my concern mate mainly was the condition of the lume being basically unworn on the makers and like u say the difference in wear between the hands and markers . also quality/finish of the dial for its age It had me seconding guessing it a bit as I heard these are faked a lot ? also if it was a refinished / painted dial I think they have done an amazing job aha with the print etc from my research so far spacing looks ok and from some friends eyes but ultimately I think this is the best place to have it posted from the experts .

The seller is later 60s small watch collector and i was just asking about a 552 movement if he had one and then replied “I have an older omega from 1959 but dont know the movement number but will send photos when I get home “ . He did inform me that he got it in a trade with another vintage watch + $2000 ( can’t remember how many years ) and that person was the original buyer so the story goes aha . ( I asked for a chance at a receipt but he did say he wouldn’t remember the guys name or where to start but when he got the watch it had a missing crown so he had the Swiss generic crown put into it and serviced and been with him ever since .

I should mention that this watch wasn’t listed anywhere for sale or didnt pitch it to sell to me he just mentioned that he owned and omega from 1959 and sent me a few photos when he got home . He didnt know the model number or the movement numbers and I had to have him open the back and send photos The rest is history slipped and my bank card fell in the atm .
 
tritto
Posts
369
Likes
555
I think the dial is spot on. There are fake dials out there but they're easy to spot. This one is all good. I'd say the lume is also good. While they can be relumed, relume jobs don't usually get the grainy texture of the original radium lume right. If you got it somewhere near the $2k mark you did incredibly well. The engraving wouldn't bother me at all b
 
blubarb
Posts
3,861
Likes
8,804
A bit of a barn find by what I can see here from the pics and the story - looks good to my eyes as well, but you are right asking here on the ΩF. 👍
Edited:
 
T
Posts
43
Likes
26
tritto tritto
I think the dial is spot on. There are fake dials out there but they're easy to spot. This one is all good. I'd say the lume is also good. While they can be relumed, relume jobs don't usually get the grainy texture of the original radium lume right. If you got it somewhere near the $2k mark you did incredibly well. The engraving wouldn't bother me at all b

This fills me with confidence and you speaking with confidence is the sugar on top . I will have a uv light over it shortly and will check back in but will put it passed the Geiger counter from trusted eyes on Monday .

ultimately from the responses so far I am feeling pretty confident we may have a winner and Almost feels like I think I know what I’m talking about now
 
T
Posts
43
Likes
26
blubarb blubarb
A bit of a barn find by what I can see here from the pics and the story - looks good to my eyes as well, but you are right asking here on the ΩF. 👍

I agree mate , trust the gut sometimes . Appreciate the help mate . Blood worth bottling
 
gbesq
Posts
9,737
Likes
54,440
If the Geiger counter reacts to the lume, I think you’re good to go - and at what sounds like a bargain price!
 
T
Posts
43
Likes
26
Dsplash Dsplash
Lume looks possible to me but I would ask for either a video under uv light (radium should glow green progressively but stop immediately when the uv is turned off) and/or a Geiger counter video (it should go quite high with radium)

https://youtube.com/shorts/LJb5SJPRQlE?si=czaNs3E-drczOnoX - video link of lume under uv in the dark as per guidances. I have another next to my 165.024 I will share and attacht also as I think it shows the tritium holding its glow and the radium fading quite quickly as it should ?
 
Dsplash
Posts
738
Likes
1,023
That’s exactly how I would expect the lume to react.
If it was my call, I would consider it ok even without the Geiger test and pull the trigger!
How much is the owner asking?
 
gbesq
Posts
9,737
Likes
54,440
Dsplash Dsplash
That’s exactly how I would expect the lume to react.
If it was my call, I would consider it ok even without the Geiger test and pull the trigger!
How much is the owner asking?
Yep. I was skeptical of the lume at first, but I’m sold. Good to go.
 
24 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

S

Help identifying this Omega Ranchero 30mm 2996 / 2990 - 1 SC

soern6 Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
SOG53
SOG53
Posts
5
Views
4K
gbesq

1958 Omega Seamaster "Seachero" 2990-1 In Really Beautiful Condition And Fully Serviced 2 Years Ago - Shipped And Insured $1,750 For USD

gbesq Private Watch Sales
gbesq
gbesq
Posts
2
Views
950
Sa Calobra

Omega Ranchero 2990-1

Sa Calobra Private Watch Sales
gbesq
gbesq
Posts
4
Views
5K
Dsplash

Omega white ranchero 2990-1

Dsplash Private Watch Sales
gbesq
gbesq
Posts
3
Views
5K
Galloping_Geezer

Seeking advice/ guidance regarding trying to get a signed crystal

Galloping_Geezer Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
Galloping_Geezer
Galloping_Geezer
Posts
17
Views
3K
fizz

Advice, guidance or thoughts on this PAF Seamaster Ranchero

fizz Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
Flip
Flip
Posts
18
Views
6K