18k Pie Pan Constellation Dogleg vs 14393: Which to Keep?

Posts
39
Likes
188
Added another 18k pie pan to the collection. Probably only keeping one in the long run but looking forward to trying both to see which case I prefer.

Which one would you keep? (keeping both bracelets regardless)

 
Posts
2,267
Likes
3,094
Two reasons for the dogleg:

Black/gold combination gives a better contrast

Dial looks better balanced with an hour marker at 3

Just my 2 cents!
 
Posts
10
Likes
22
I wouldn't say no to either, but definitely favouring the dogleg as the lines are cleaner and the dial has more contrast. I'd keep them both given the chance though!
 
Posts
390
Likes
839
Dogleg. I agree with Passover, I like that it's non lume with black onyx indices and hands.
 
Posts
985
Likes
3,988
Maybe I need a better photo of each one, but from this picture, I choose the TURLER.
 
Posts
183
Likes
576
I would keep the Dogleg, the black gold gives more "colour" to the watch, the Türler I find it a bit "dull" in comparison.
 
Posts
6,614
Likes
10,207
In principle they are both nice references - and the one that appeals to you most when it's on your wrist is important.

If you must divest yourself of one of them - then, in condition terms, my vote is to keep the dogleg.

It's well known that I don't like retail names on dials (why would you want some shop - no matter how exalted - scrawling all over Omega's original design work?) but the dial on the 14393 has quite a lot of marks on the dial and bubbling in the lacquer.

Don't get me wrong (apart form the Turler name) it's a nice watch but the dogleg appeals more.

I would swap the bracelets as the one on the dogleg does little to enhance it IMHO.