166.024 Authentication Help Please

Posts
12
Likes
5
Sorry to see that. Is it just the lume that has fallen out or has the handling damaged other parts. I ask as most damage to a movement wouldn't be seen to this untrained eye.
Damaged the lume, rusted the hour hand and likely resulted in rust to the movement and elsewhere. And the movement no longer runs. I should have kept the case back off for an extended period of time and or applied supplemental air to make sure there was no lingering moisture. In the past I've never had an issue with any other watch I've handled in this way as I've always given ample time to allow air flow to properly dry out whatever moisture may have remained. This time I didn't as I was hasty and got sidetracked. The resulting destruction is sobering reminder of my regrettable decision and a heavy price to pay for making such a silly mistake. A painful lesson learned.
 
Posts
238
Likes
288
Sorry to see this.

So this damage was caused just from moisture in the air? Or can trapped IPA draw in moisture and actually make the situation worse? Assuming the IPA wasn’t contaminated.
Edited:
 
Posts
3,013
Likes
4,780
If the alcohol sits about a bit the parts left over are mostly water. One excuse why high proof alcohol is banned for retail sale in California. Once the seal is broken 20 to 40 percent evaporates and causes smog. This is called the Angel's share, and around distilleries when is settles out it is called the Devil's mold.

Still the watch is not completely ruined I have watches in much worse shape... There are a lot more homeless movements than nice cases.
 
Posts
238
Likes
288
If the alcohol sits about a bit the parts left over are mostly water. One excuse why high proof alcohol is banned for retail sale in California. Once the seal is broken 20 to 40 percent evaporates and causes smog. This is called the Angel's share, and around distilleries when is settles out it is called the Devil's mold.

Still the watch is not completely ruined I have watches in much worse shape... There are a lot more homeless movements than nice cases.

That makes sense. So if you heat the parts after contact with IPA the rapid evaporation of the alcohol simultaneously draws away the water? But if it is left at room temperature only the alcohol content evaporates quickly?
 
Posts
12
Likes
5
Sorry to see this.

So this damage was caused just from moisture in the air? Or can trapped IPA draw in moisture and actually make the situation worse? Assuming the IPA wasn’t contaminated.
This is strictly the result of the isopropyl not fully drying out before I put the case back on. Additionally I'm guessing that the trapped moisture reacted negatively to the melted gasket remnants that I couldn't get to which set off a slow reacting chemical reaction as everything appeared fine a few hours after the watch had been closed up. Had I simply been cautious and left the case back off overnight or for a day to help ensure the movement had fully aired/dried out there likely wouldn't be any issues. Sure wish I could go back in time.....
 
Posts
238
Likes
288
This is strictly the result of the isopropyl not fully drying out before I put the case back on. Additionally I'm guessing that the trapped moisture reacted negatively to the melted gasket remnants that I couldn't get to which set off a slow reacting chemical reaction as everything appeared fine a few hours after the watch had been closed up. Had I simply been cautious and left the case back off overnight or for a day to help ensure the movement had fully aired/dried out there likely wouldn't be any issues. Sure wish I could go back in time.....

That is really unfortunate. But I don’t think you should be too hard on yourself. Seems like an unlucky accident.
 
Posts
307
Likes
230
First of all, congrats to expansive fail! Cleaning gasket residue with movement in the case was an absolutely nonsense action. The movement is rusted anyway and needs to be completely serviced.
The dial and hands were relumed in teh past, so it makes the damage less painful.
You can see the genuine lume only on the second hand tip.
As the watch is based on serial number late 1968, should have the greenish lume.
My guess is, that there was a moisture damage in the past and the dial/hands were relumed to match the bezel.
The restamped caseback is okay, they used older HF 165.024 cases in stock to finish the run of this date model.
 
Posts
1,126
Likes
1,731
First of all, congrats to expansive fail! Cleaning gasket residue with movement in the case was an absolutely nonsense action. The movement is rusted anyway and needs to be completely serviced.
The dial and hands were relumed in teh past, so it makes the damage less painful.
You can see the genuine lume only on the second hand tip.
As the watch is based on serial number late 1968, should have the greenish lume.
My guess is, that there was a moisture damage in the past and the dial/hands were relumed to match the bezel.
The restamped caseback is okay, they used older HF 165.024 cases in stock to finish the run of this date model.
Hello,
Are you sure it was relumed? To me it looked genuine.
 
Posts
12
Likes
5
First of all, congrats to expansive fail! Cleaning gasket residue with movement in the case was an absolutely nonsense action. The movement is rusted anyway and needs to be completely serviced.
The dial and hands were relumed in teh past, so it makes the damage less painful.
You can see the genuine lume only on the second hand tip.
As the watch is based on serial number late 1968, should have the greenish lume.
My guess is, that there was a moisture damage in the past and the dial/hands were relumed to match the bezel.
The restamped caseback is okay, they used older HF 165.024 cases in stock to finish the run of this date model.
I clearly owned my mistake...your initial comment says everything I need to know about you. And I don't believe the hands or dial were relumed. This pic was taken after I polished the crystal....the lume was glorious and emitted a quick burst glow, along with the bezel, after being exposed to bright light.

 
Posts
4,517
Likes
11,119
Don't be hard on yourself for knocking the lume out. Not sure what you could have done. There are people who stabilize it but it could have gotten knocked out during shipment or simply on your wrist. Lume falls out over time. It happens. Get new put in and have it match the patina of the rest of the watch. Easy peasy.
I've had beautiful patina watches fall apart simply by cracking the case open.