A friend of mine sold his for the same reason, it just looked so thick while feeling small and unrefined at the same time.
I would look into Zodiac, I really liked how it wore.
https://www.zodiacwatches.com/products/super-sea-wolf-53-compression-zo9250
Or Vostoks, they are quirky and great.
My Komandirskie is really comfy and wears great at 39mm.
Another option would be a Orient Ray II it's 41.5 but wears smaller.
Click to expand...