What Makes a Watch High-End? Haute Horlogerie Criteria

Posts
884
Likes
1,700
Hi all,

Just as the title asks, what is the criteria for a high end watch? Is it just price?
Or level of finishing and decoration to movement, dial etc? Also, no conventional springs like the click etc.

I would love to hear everyone’s opinion on this. A great diverse group we have.
 
Posts
13,841
Likes
53,903
Finishing level, complications, build quality, materials, watchmaker reputation, # produced. Hype and marketing of course play a role in the ability to command high sales and re sale prices.
Edited:
 
Posts
884
Likes
1,700
the reason I ask is where does the line start at for watches that could be considered high horology? What are the specific details needed?
 
Posts
35,462
Likes
39,773
It's a bit of a case of I'll know it when I see it. One of the major factors is not just initial purchase price, because there are JLCs that fall into Omega or even Longines pricing yet are definitely high end watches.

I think high end maintenance cost is more indicative, brands that cost a lot to service and maintain as there is no independent option or parts availability often (but not always, as micribrands and some junk brands do the same) indicate a high end watch. Sort of like how a Maserati 3200GT can be bought for less than a used Corolla, yet the maintenance keeps it will and truly in that high end classification.

High end also doesn't necessarily mean good, there are several high-end watch brands that are high-end but lacking in quality, reliability or after sales service (a major watch conglomerate that isn't Swatch Group or LVMH comes to mind).
 
Posts
884
Likes
1,700
It's a bit of a case of I'll know it when I see it. One of the major factors is not just initial purchase price, because there are JLCs that fall into Omega or even Longines pricing yet are definitely high end watches.

I think high end maintenance cost is more indicative, brands that cost a lot to service and maintain as there is no independent option or parts availability often (but not always, as micribrands and some junk brands do the same) indicate a high end watch. Sort of like how a Maserati 3200GT can be bought for less than a used Corolla, yet the maintenance keeps it will and truly in that high end classification.

High end also doesn't necessarily mean good, there are several high-end watch brands that are high-end but lacking in quality, reliability or after sales service (a major watch conglomerate that isn't Swatch Group or LVMH comes to mind).
I appreciate the in depth and thought out response. It is tricky to see where the blurred line begins.

maintenance costs though can be tricky. Rolex for example charge quite a bit for standard work on watches that are not considered HH, and around the same pricing of some HH brands for similar work.

Standard servicing here in Australia using AUD as a currency has brands like JLC at $2,000 for basic service and Rolex pushing $1,500 ish.
But point taken using a broad brush.

Reliability is something you would expect at such a high margin, but like an AP royal oak easy to break and expensive to repair.


The whole service was to see if my own watch makes the cut.
My jaeger lecoultre reverso 976.
Still not sure I guess. I think it would be entry to HH?
 
Posts
3,108
Likes
6,471
Buffet would say: price is what you pay, quality is what you get 😉

High end for me is NOT a rischaaa miiill. Or watches in tuna-can size with 65 diamonds and 35 complications.

Unfortunately, I haven't had a Lange in my hand yet. Or a Breguet...
 
Posts
884
Likes
1,700
Buffet would say: price is what you pay, quality is what you get 😉

High end for me is NOT a rischaaa miiill. Or watches in tuna-can size with 65 diamonds and 35 complications.

Unfortunately, I haven't had a Lange in my hand yet. Or a Breguet...
I completely agree. I have seen much nicer finished watches in 36mm than larger monsters.
 
Posts
1,414
Likes
758
Hublot mdm professional/super professional and iwc ocean bund/2000 were high end diving watches. Submariner date and sea dweller were very common diving watches.

None of them were examples of haute horlogerie.
 
Posts
13,841
Likes
53,903
I’ve PP and Lange in hand. Yes, the quality is most definitely very fine. The highest level I own however is my JLC Master Moon Triple. I could not bring myself to pay the ticket for anything beyond that. Yes, I think the Reverso is the beginning of HH. I own one of those too. JLC is rather unique in that regard where they play well at the highest level and still produce reliable and “affordable” watches.
 
Posts
884
Likes
1,700
I’ve PP and Lange in hand. Yes, the quality is most definitely very fine. The highest level I own however is my JLC Master Moon Triple. I could not bring myself to pay the ticket for anything beyond that. Yes, I think the Reverso is the beginning of HH. I own one of those too. JLC is rather unique in that regard where they play well at the highest level and still produce reliable and “affordable” watches.
I fell in love with the reverso about a year after entering the hobby. It took me a couple years to pick the model I wanted as there are so many to choose from, and I wanted to make sure what I picked would be a keeper.

I settled on the 976. It then took about a year for the exact one to come up for sale in decent condition. I’m very happy with it and it is a keeper. Had it for about 6 years now. I plan on getting a Patek for a major milestone or retirement. A 5035 annual calendar.
I have a bunch of watches which will go to the kids, but a 5035, reverso and explorer 1 will be my final 3. Just missing the Patek.

I was curious what others thought was the key indicators to HH if there were any as I see the line a tad blurred at the fringes.
 
Posts
167
Likes
245
Went to the boutique and tried these on yesterday. Absolutely beautiful.
The new Master Control Chronometre is fantastic. That case, size, dial - all a bit subtle it the best way possible.
 
Posts
884
Likes
1,700
The new Master Control Chronometre is fantastic. That case, size, dial - all a bit subtle it the best way possible.
I think it’s understated brilliance. Totally agree.
 
Posts
1,509
Likes
4,376
Have you considered the Genève Seal as the starting point for HH?

Manufacturing:
My criteria is all hand made, hand assembled, hand adjusted, hand finished , case hand polished , and made of all locally sourced materials. The watch should be designed by a notable person or lead by a notable designer.

"Swiss Made" since that has too much allowances:
Nothing Chinese or other foreign soured materials on a Swiss or German watch, accessories, etc it is 100% Swiss or German and not 40% outsourced. Ideally the manuals and documents should also be locally manufactured.

Performance:
Beyond COSC certified. Everything is precision made to NASA program tolerances. The standards are higher than required for COSC.

Boutique Experience:
If we are discussing true Haute Horlogy, the boutique is the start. It must be elegant, exclusive, and fully staffed with passionate boutique staff that wear suits and ties. Champagne, cake, chocolates are available. Private viewing rooms are available. Exact copies of the branded shopping bags in non-branded versions so you can walk to the car without a big Vacheron or Patek logo on the side of a big bag. There are weekly or monthy gatherings for invitation buyers to see watches that have come in recently. A product ambassidor assigned to you and you have access to visits to the manufacturing or museums with the concerge services. There are luxury items given as gifts for visits which are co-branded with the manufacturer. Sometimes these gifts are more expensive than other entry level luxury brand watches.

Finally, it must cost more than a new vehicle. Unfortunately, this also may include priority lists /waitlists to get to the models you really want.

It would also be prefererable for the maison to be at least 100 years old. The maison should be noted for having implemented several of the grand complications on their regular watches using in house movements.


Edited:
 
Posts
1,474
Likes
2,149
Mostly based on marketing and the perceived socioeconomic status of those who tend to buy them.
 
Posts
1,509
Likes
4,376
A true HH maison has capabilities a moon watch or crown does not. Being able to sit with a designer and requesting a moonphase, a power reserve indicator, a turning bezel, and an enamel dial on a watch with your own dial face is a true HH
 
Posts
1,509
Likes
4,376
I expect this to be the proper treatment for guests. Bottles of Champagne, Cake, gifts, and private rooms.