What is a sector dial? An abridged, arbitrary guide

Posts
2,823
Likes
4,928
Over the years, I have seen the term "sector dial" applied to an increasing number of dial designs. I do not know where the term originated from, but my association with it is certain dials from the 1930s and 1940s. These dials combine at least some linear hour markers with a circular element. In my view, the linear hour markers should connect or come very close to the circular element. Of the designs below, I consider Type 1, Type 2, and Type 3 to be archetypal sector dials. On the other hand, Type 4 is on the edge of what I would count as a sector dial. This is because the circular elements of the dial look more like a minute track than part of the hour markers. Dials that are similar in design to Type 4 are prevalent, and I would be reluctant to uniformly call them sector dials.



Moving on to dials that I would not consider to be sector dials. Obviously, this category is vast so I have chosen a few dials that might cause confusion. Immediately below are dials that either lack close proximity between the linear hour markers and a circular element (below left), or lack linear hour markers altogether (below right). Further below are the same dials but with the addition of crosshairs. In my view, the presence or absence of crosshairs should have no bearing on whether or not a dial is considered to be a sector dial. Feel free to disagree!

 
Posts
643
Likes
980
Hmmm... I mostly agree but I would say, from your first set, that type 4 is more of a sector dial than type 1. But I wouldn't put up much of a fight if someone had a watch of type 1 or 4 and considered it a sector dial.

Cross hairs are irrelevant, I 100% agree with that.
 
Posts
2,959
Likes
6,317
Ah, a discussion as old as time and the Calatrava.

How would you qualify dials segmented only at certain indices within your scheme?

 
Posts
2,823
Likes
4,928
Ah, a discussion as old as time and the Calatrava.
Haha!
How would you qualify dials segmented only at certain indices within your scheme?
Thanks for posing the question and sharing those two examples. To me, the Zenith looks like an inverse variant of a Type 1. The Patek does not fit in as neatly. I think that this is because there are no hour markers that are simply straight lines. Funnily enough, I was thinking about another Patek dial when I was composing this thread (see below). I am torn as to whether or not linear hour markers are strictly necessary. In a way, both the dial you posted and the "roulette dials" below look like variants of a Type 2.

Source: John Nagayama, https://www.instagram.com/p/CfZ_4JNhU26/
 
Posts
4,053
Likes
11,487
I agree with your classification. I refrained from posting either of these two in the sector dial thread because I didn't feel they fit.
 
Posts
2,823
Likes
4,928
I refrained from posting either of these two in the sector dial thread because I didn't feel they fit.
Two fantastic dials! I agree, neither is quite what I associate with a sector dial.
 
Posts
4,827
Likes
12,218
Baltic calls this a sector dial, and I tend to agree with them. It seems that you would not classify this as a sector dial, correct? I feel like the two-tone feature pushes a dial towards a sector dial. The fact that a watch has cross-hairs does not disqualify it as a sector dial in my book. Thoughts?

 
Posts
2,823
Likes
4,928
Baltic calls this a sector dial, and I tend to agree with them. It seems that you would not classify this as a sector dial, correct? I feel like the two-tone feature pushes a dial towards a sector dial. The fact that a watch has cross-hairs does not disqualify it as a sector dial in my book. Thoughts?
Firstly, Baltic also calls the watch below a "Bicompax" so it is difficult to take their naming very seriously.

Source: https://www.instagram.com/p/BveCFtFAeCP/


Jokes aside, I certainly see the close resemblance that Baltic's dial has to a typical sector dial such as the Patek below. As you mentioned, the two-tone finish really gives the dial a 1930s/1940s look. However, I am still inclined to classify the dial as "not a sector dial" due to the absence of linear hour markers. I think that, if I were to accept the Baltic dial as a sector dial, then I would also have to accept the Omega Suverän dial below. Although, maybe an argument could be made that there is a relevant difference between the printed circles containing the hour numerals on the Baltic dial versus the black ring on the Suverän dial. I agree with you about crosshairs.

Sources:
https://baltic-watches.com/en/products/hms-002-silver
https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-6200189
https://omegaforums.net/threads/omega-suverän-ref-2400-from-1944-now-850eur.142247/

A final point is that, by my criteria, dials such as the one below would be considered sector dials. I acknowledge that such a dial is a far cry from the 1930s/1940s dials that most people associate with the term. While I do think that the Genève Dynamic dial shares certain key design elements with typical sector dials, I can accept that my definition might not be the most useful.

Source: https://www.ebay.com/itm/134575647922?epid=10046015524&hash=item1f55556cb2:g:~m8AAOSwu55kZOEV&amdata=enc:AQAIAAAA0MNCQv3SukF0XwpoOEyFpFssLedC9Pyz/F1MqIOjZmFesPc+gJsiCa963rT4GyVXhwJkZSbFlatd+tHcwa+6vulAYoLUrJ/A7R0zKrcjYWohuGp4mAUIQrIi4FEO1u21u0zF7Xz8gUzstzObE5kb8nX3llkWDKJEt0x7k4KYQPguAA97QTnvfK7XTXdfwtbd8H8UCHfFaCSQDcasgILN2JA7bOv1E6Dzwa3R4NJAgF+D3LL7eK5ngKPrmQuskOWP/l95tZWlJB6P0zolwokA7Ag=|tkp:Bk9SR-rDk-OPYg
 
This website may earn commission from Ebay sales.
Posts
4,827
Likes
12,218
While I do think that the Genève Dynamic dial shares certain key design elements with typical sector dials, I can accept that my definition might not be the most useful.

I think your definition could be shored up by addressing color. Something like a sector dial should be two tones of silver or neutral color.
 
Posts
2,823
Likes
4,928
I think your definition could be shored up by addressing color. Something like a sector dial should be two tones of silver or neutral color.
I would say that many typical sector dials are not two-tone. Also, some can be found in unusual colors. Below are a couple of neat examples.

Source: 2022 eBay listing
1369753-e0ebba2f207687cb83e1870038b70e37.jpg

Source: https://omegaforums.net/threads/vulcain-chronometre-sector-dial-w-stepped-case-500usd.85865/
img_2755-jpg.685642