Vintage Gold Filled vs Gold Capped

Posts
7,457
Likes
59,565
So much good advice but I suspect we’ve only made your task harder.

I hope you don’t regret contacting us in the first place.

Best,

Robert
 
Posts
21,019
Likes
48,033
I posted photos in my first thread about 2 watches I’ve been considering. Apparently one may have
a refinished dial - I’d love you opinion.
Here is a couple others. I may pick 2 - then on his birthday which is in a few days, show him and let him pick it out. The challenge is that they could sell in the meantime.
Thanks.

Yes, unfortunately, both of those have refinished dials.
 
Posts
9,072
Likes
47,171
OP, I know of a very nice vintage 18k solid rose gold manual wind Girard-Perregaux that’s for sale for $1,399. Trustworthy seller that I’ve purchased from in the past. The watch isn’t perfect, but it has a beautiful and unusual dial. Please message me if you’re interested and I’ll send you the link.
 
Posts
28
Likes
3
I would not recommend either a gold plated or gold filled watch. That being said, both gold capped watches and stainless steel watches with gold accents can be very attractive and age gracefully. Here are two examples from my collection. On the left is a 1962 Omega Constellation reference 14900 in gold cap. On the right is a 1959 Omega Geneve reference 2903 in stainless steel with gold accents. You can also find many Seamaster models from the 50’s and 60’s with these features. As another member suggested, run your prospective candidates by us for vetting before you purchase. Good luck and what a nice gesture and thoughtful gift for your husband.
 
Posts
9,072
Likes
47,171
^mychel53, did you have a question or a comment about my post? Anything that I can help you with?
 
Posts
28
Likes
3
Dan S watch shown above is a drop-dead 1950's dress watch.
Either way, please show us pictures of candidate watches before pulling the trigger. The people on this site will be helpful in vetting the watch. For instance, a dial that hasn't been tampered ("redialed") is worth quite a bit more than one that has been refinished. It takes years of looking at dials to become an expert at this skill.
Thanks for your help. I’m happy I found this forum before purchasing.
 
Posts
28
Likes
3
I would not recommend either a gold plated or gold filled watch. That being said, both gold capped watches and stainless steel watches with gold accents can be very attractive and age gracefully. Here are two examples from my collection. On the left is a 1962 Omega Constellation reference 14900 in gold cap. On the right is a 1959 Omega Geneve reference 2903 in stainless steel with gold accents. You can also find many Seamaster models from the 50’s and 60’s with these features. As another member suggested, run your prospective candidates by us for vetting before you purchase. Good luck and what a nice gesture and thoughtful gift for your husband.
 
Posts
28
Likes
3
So much good advice but I suspect we’ve only made your task harder.

I hope you don’t regret contacting us in the first place.

Best,

Robert
I’m glad for all the help. All this information certainly has given me more to think about. I love learning about these watches. I also had an extensive vintage jewelry collection that sadly was stolen with my husbands watch collection. There is something very special about vintage jewelry and watches I have a beautiful watch chain dated 1800’s that I wear as a necklace.
 
Posts
28
Likes
3
OP, I know of a very nice vintage 18k solid rose gold manual wind Girard-Perregaux that’s for sale for $1,399. Trustworthy seller that I’ve purchased from in the past. The watch isn’t perfect, but it has a beautiful and unusual dial. Please message me if you’re interested and I’ll send you the link.
 
Posts
28
Likes
3
Yes, unfortunately, both of those have refinished dials.

Both of them! Good to know.
Thanks.
 
Posts
28
Likes
3
I would love to see some pics of some examples of watches from your search that suit your tastes as a gift for your husband. And, not to pry to much, but if you told us a birth year, members may have some solid specific suggestions for you. (Given the generosity of many on these forums, you may even find a match here.)

Also, if you know if you prefer a manual wind vs an automatic, that may help with general suggestions.

If this is to be a "special" watch, to be worn on special occasions, rather than an every day watch, I prefer no-date models. I don't mind setting the time, but having to set the date on some of the vintage pieces when they come out of the watch box can be a pain. (Round and Round we go.)

Good luck in your search, this is a very thoughtful gift that I am sure your husband will appreciate.
 
Posts
28
Likes
3

I also was looking at these. I posted on another thread and one member thought one with a black strap had a refinished dial. Not sure if they are available anymore.
 
Posts
28
Likes
3
I posted pictures below. I’d love your opinion. Seems like I’m finding watches with refinished dials. Here’s another one I found. But I think it’s pricey. Not sure what the average prices are.
 
Posts
21,019
Likes
48,033
At first glance, these last three dials look ok to me. I'm not sure the hands are original on that last one. I hope you will get more opinions.
 
Posts
28
Likes
3
At first glance, these last three dials look ok to me. I hope you will get more opinions.
The last one with the brown strap is close to $2,700.?? Is that reasonable? Or too much. The other 2 are less. Thanks.
 
Posts
28
Likes
3
Maybe there is a collector on this forum who has a 1950 watch he is looking to sell or knows of someone. looks like this watch purchase is going to take some time!!
 
Posts
21,019
Likes
48,033
Maybe there is a collector on this forum who has a 1950 watch he is looking to sell or knows of someone. looks like this watch purchase is going to take some time!!

It's not easy. Many of the watches you're finding have probably been languishing on Chrono24 or dealers' websites for a long time, for good reason. Good collectible watches offered at fair prices don't last long. There are some dealers who have good watches available for premium prices, but when you're starting out, it's quite difficult to distinguish those high-priced sellers of good vintage watches from shady sellers who cobble together flawed watches and also put high prices on them.
 
Posts
86
Likes
167
Seems like I’m finding watches with refinished dials

Thats something that a lot of first time buyers seem to find. Which is understandable as refinished dials look 'newer' and sometimes even more attractive than a 50/60 year old original dial.

I'd go solid gold. The solid gold Seamaster De Ville models are great in my opinion.
 
Posts
27
Likes
263
I know you didn't ask for suggestions, but I will volunteer a photo of what, to me, is one of the most beautiful gold dress watches (not my watch, it was previously sold by Stetz & Co., but I know that several OF members keep these in their collections). It's a notch up from an Omega, but not insanely expensive. Unfortunately, not particularly easy to find, but it's worth keeping in mind other brands. I have a soft spot for the color of IWC pink gold, but there are a few other manufacturers to consider.

IMG_4850-2.jpg
That is a beautiful watch, love the shapes of the lugs! Can I ask what would be the best way to keep an eye out for something like this to come up, reference number, or by a nickname - I wouldn't know what to put on my watchrecon alerts!
 
Posts
21,019
Likes
48,033
That is a beautiful watch, love the shapes of the lugs! Can I ask what would be the best way to keep an eye out for something like this to come up, reference number, or by a nickname - I wouldn't know what to put on my watchrecon alerts!

Shark-fin lugs.