Forums Latest Auctions Members

VC 1942 or PP 5416?

  1. Pun

    Pun Oct 23, 2019

    Posts
    1,040
    Likes
    4,194
    Friends, I wish to add one decent calendar complication watch from the Trinity and am considering Vacheron Constantin Triple Calendar 1942 and Patek Philippe Annual Calendar 5146G. They visually appeal to me though are in different price range. What would you take as a classic vintage looks watch?
     
    72C75EF9-5E74-4B2B-8633-6A9C315199CE.png AAC58D96-7560-4759-B43D-9374BBC69D95.png
  2. blufinz52

    blufinz52 Hears dead people, not watch rotors. Oct 23, 2019

    Posts
    1,508
    Likes
    2,255
    They're both beautiful, but the VC is a cleaner dial and more legible to my eye. Can't go wrong with either though.
     
    Archer, Larry S and Pun like this.
  3. Pun

    Pun Oct 23, 2019

    Posts
    1,040
    Likes
    4,194
    Patek has richer dial in cream and additional Moon phase.
     
  4. SeanO

    SeanO Oct 24, 2019

    Posts
    1,296
    Likes
    1,368
    what about the VC fiftysix Complete Calendar in SS? it's around 38K AUD with a choice of two dial colours.
     
  5. Pun

    Pun Oct 24, 2019

    Posts
    1,040
    Likes
    4,194
    Yes indeed but it’s 41 mm instead of 40 mm and without Geneva Seal. My preference is for a watch not exceeding 40 mm and VC should have Geneva Seal.
     
  6. ChetBaker

    ChetBaker Oct 29, 2019

    Posts
    2
    Likes
    0
    The 56 is 40mm and does have the Geneva seal. The blue one is particularly nice.
     
  7. Pun

    Pun Oct 29, 2019

    Posts
    1,040
    Likes
    4,194
    I failed to read Geneva Seal in specifications...
     
    C66139D5-AFC3-4C7A-90F1-957B86FC52F1.png 2D6973B2-AC5C-4722-B68E-01D24F19D1D0.png
  8. Larry S

    Larry S Color Commentator for the Hyperbole. Oct 29, 2019

    Posts
    8,056
    Likes
    30,757
    VC Historique all the way ... classic triple
     
    Pun likes this.
  9. Skipper_S

    Skipper_S Oct 29, 2019

    Posts
    150
    Likes
    140
    Buy BOTH;);)
     
    Pun likes this.
  10. Kwijibo

    Kwijibo Nov 8, 2019

    Posts
    1,593
    Likes
    1,477
    definitly love this VC
     
    Pun likes this.
  11. Pun

    Pun Nov 8, 2019

    Posts
    1,040
    Likes
    4,194
    I ordered Patek 5146 last week. I decided to play safe with an annual calendar Patek in noble metal as perhaps final watch in my collection. With this I’ll have 25 watch collection with 15 watches from major Swiss brands. It’s enough for me for now.
     
    WatchCor likes this.
  12. Kwijibo

    Kwijibo Nov 8, 2019

    Posts
    1,593
    Likes
    1,477
    You can't regret a PP :thumbsup:
     
    Pun likes this.
  13. steversaurus

    steversaurus Nov 13, 2019

    Posts
    30
    Likes
    9
    Can't really go wrong, but I'd go for the VC in this case.
     
    Pun likes this.
  14. Uniqez

    Uniqez Nov 13, 2019

    Posts
    1,293
    Likes
    3,303
    I would say Patek looks better an unique . VC has the same look as some other watches with calendar hand - Oris, Movado etc.
     
    Pun likes this.
  15. Pun

    Pun Nov 14, 2019

    Posts
    1,040
    Likes
    4,194
    Yes I also thought so. Now Patek is on the way.
     
  16. Geezer

    Geezer Dec 4, 2019

    Posts
    60
    Likes
    99
    Great choice! The 5146 is a classic, and uses an excellent movement. An annual calendar mechanism is a very useful complication, and your choice of annual calendar is probably one of the nicest available (as Patek was the first to introduce them in 1996).
     
    Pun likes this.
  17. Pun

    Pun Dec 4, 2019

    Posts
    1,040
    Likes
    4,194
    Thank you sir. I got it this week but I’ll wear it on 19th, my 58th birthday. Then I’ll post customary wrist shot as well. Regards
     
    WatchCor likes this.
  18. guaranteed.rohu

    guaranteed.rohu Dec 4, 2019

    Posts
    676
    Likes
    3,637
    definitely different price ranges,

    I think for the same price to the patek 5146, you'd have to consider:

    (personally i love the journe, but things like servicing costs, value retention, etc., are concerns because i'm not a millionaire)

    1. lange 1815 calendar

    [​IMG]


    2. fp journe octa lune

    [​IMG]


    [​IMG]
     
    Pun likes this.
  19. WatchCor

    WatchCor Dec 4, 2019

    Posts
    257
    Likes
    505
    Good stuff @Pun , having had the chance to try the 5146 PP on my wrist a month ago I definitely applaud your choice. It's a gorgeous watch. Well played sir. Awaiting for the customary wristshots though :D
     
    Pun likes this.
  20. Pun

    Pun Dec 4, 2019

    Posts
    1,040
    Likes
    4,194
    Your both suggestions are gorgeous indeed. I considered them before committing to 5146G.
    ALS has a busier dial and no lumes; it may cause strain to my ageing eyes as I want a watch to wear daily for a long time now after my retirement.
    FPJ is a killer but again don’t match the clarity of 5146G IMO. It’s not an Annual Calendar as well.
    Thanks indeed for providing great choice in similar price range. I’m sure someone else may benefit in future if one reads this thread.