Forums Latest Members

Tudor Black Bay Black Vs Ceramic SMP

  1. sdre Jul 24, 2017

    Posts
    2,460
    Likes
    7,448
    Hey all.

    So I'm letting go for my 45.5mm PO and looking to fund either the above mentioned watches.

    I'm leaning towards the Tudor because of the hands are more unique as compared to the hallowed ones of the SMP.

    However I like the SMP height as compared to the Black Bay...

    Anyone who has both or was in the same situation as me... which did you choose?

    Any regrets?

    Cheers
     
  2. 67ViP Jul 24, 2017

    Posts
    177
    Likes
    318
    I would go with the black SMPc...it's the perfect size, and you won't see any knockoffs. Tudor is a great watch with a respectable reputation, but it has the Submariner look...which Omega does not. If you have your heart set on a Tudor Black Bay, I'd consider the S&G...that's a much better looking piece. Good luck with your selection.
     
    PSX_20170626_153528.jpg
    mikechi22 and Foo2rama like this.
  3. wilfreb Jul 24, 2017

    Posts
    382
    Likes
    1,026
    The highly original design, like no other, ceramic bezel and overall feel and beauty of the watch, I would pick the SMPc [​IMG][​IMG]
     
  4. R3D9 Jul 24, 2017

    Posts
    1,288
    Likes
    3,306
    My aesthetic preference leans towards the Black Bay. If you're concerned about the height, try and pick up an ETA version, which is noticibly thinner than the new, in-house model. As a bonus, the rose on the dial and circular script looks awesome, IMHO.

    I also think that the BB has a better chance of retaining its value long-term, particularly if you can buy the ETA Black Bay Black at a reasonable price.

    All that said, the SMPc is a killer watch as well. I escpecially like the black dialled version.
     
    frederico and sdre like this.
  5. w.finkenstaedt Jul 25, 2017

    Posts
    680
    Likes
    728
    I'd go SMPc and not think twice about it. It's a much more iconic watch, and with the adjustable clasp, is the perfect dive watch.
     
    River and Foo2rama like this.
  6. Foo2rama Keeps his worms in a ball instead of a can. Jul 25, 2017

    Posts
    17,045
    Likes
    25,211
    All personal preference. I thought I liked the eta BB until I tried it on. Once I did I had a strong reaction to it on my wrist and realized it's not for me. Right now I'd go 300mc(Spectre preferred), 2500d 42mm PO maybe the ceramic? Then SMPc.
     
    BenjaminT and River like this.
  7. w.finkenstaedt Jul 25, 2017

    Posts
    680
    Likes
    728
    I'm torn between the blue dial Globemaster and the Seamaster 300 in steel for my next watch. Both amazing, and I have a ton of dive watches, but the Seamaster 300 is just special I think.
     
    Foo2rama likes this.
  8. Foo2rama Keeps his worms in a ball instead of a can. Jul 25, 2017

    Posts
    17,045
    Likes
    25,211
    Well... when we open it up to non dive/everyday watches.. yeah I tried the Blue Globemaster on... yeah it's short listed for my next buy.

    But I agree the 300mc is pretty much perfect
     
    Edited Jul 25, 2017
  9. Benjo74 Jul 25, 2017

    Posts
    21
    Likes
    61
    Of the two watches you are considering, I would choose the Black Bay in black (I am biased, I have one). As others mentioned, try to find the ETA version - it looks great on a NATO and I also love mine on the new RubberB strap. Whilst the SMP is undoubtedly a great watch, I just can't get past the aesthetics of the bracelet (personally I don't think it looks good) and I'm not a fan of the bezel shape.

    As for those thinking of getting the Globemaster in blue, I am wearing one right now so I figured I ought to attach an enabling photo...
    IMG_0008.JPG
     
  10. RDK Jul 25, 2017

    Posts
    13
    Likes
    24
    Bought this:
    [​IMG]
    Black Bay Blue (ETA)

    And after that I sold this:
    [​IMG]
    PO 2500D XL

    I have a 7" wrist, the size and weight of the Planet Ocean bothered me for everyday wear.
    Lug to lug is 52mm for the PO, 50mm for the Black Bay.

    No regrets here!
     
  11. base615 Jul 25, 2017

    Posts
    1,024
    Likes
    3,926
    The blue SMPc is one of the best watches in history and, as an added bonus, is superb value for money.

    IMG_0662.JPG
     
  12. wilfreb Jul 25, 2017

    Posts
    382
    Likes
    1,026
    Just to help you decide [​IMG]
     
    DJG2645, drhombus24, Shailor and 2 others like this.
  13. 67ViP Jul 25, 2017

    Posts
    177
    Likes
    318
    I kinda like mine...
     
    PSX_20170724_172029.jpg
  14. wkimmd Jul 25, 2017

    Posts
    518
    Likes
    958
    I mentioned this in another post as well - but for me, even the ETA version of the Tudor was too thick. Would go SMPc!
     
    sdre likes this.
  15. vitriol Jul 31, 2017

    Posts
    982
    Likes
    2,913
    Couldn't agreed more. Had both and sold BB after 5 days, on a wrist this watch was everything but comfortable. Case side is huge, long and massive lugs work on the wrist like nails. Perhaps in-house model with almost 2mm extra height caseback is more comfortable, have no idea. Still BB is a beatiful watch, if I ever rebuy it will be the model with in-house.
    Frankly I do not understand why SMPc and BB have some many duels, apart of the budget they are totaly different watches.
    With regards to wear&feel I would confront BB with PO, though PO is still a winner for me.

    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
     
    Foo2rama likes this.
  16. wilfreb Jul 31, 2017

    Posts
    382
    Likes
    1,026
    In my experience, nothing beats the SMPc in the comfort department [​IMG]
     
    Ssunnylee24 and 67ViP like this.
  17. jzzmusician Jul 31, 2017

    Posts
    138
    Likes
    160
    I was in the same boat until last Friday. Bought a 300 in black. Should be here in a couple of days.
     
    pault8084 likes this.
  18. w.finkenstaedt Jul 31, 2017

    Posts
    680
    Likes
    728
    You wear your NATOs the wrong way around, just FYI. Also check out Haveston straps if you don't like the bulk of the tail.
     
    Seanovice likes this.
  19. Shailor Jul 31, 2017

    Posts
    415
    Likes
    480
    I tried on both. Preferred the 300m. I've actually forgotten to take it off before going to bed. I also didn't care for the Tudor's hour hand.
     
    IMG_0296.JPG
  20. mikechi22 Jul 31, 2017

    Posts
    921
    Likes
    730
    Wow! That thing is a monster! On my dainty wrist, it would look like a shackles!