Hi,
What do you think, a little scratched, but is the dial original?
I am quite confused on the differing Seamaster "S's".
Best,
Ian

 

Redial I believe.

 

Redial. You don't even have to look at the fonts – the lume dots are obviously new.

 

Why? "Swiss Made" or "Swiss" Is somehow visible under the 6 Hour marker. "Flat" top "A"'s in Automatic. And this 1958 could already be post-coathanger "S".

Could be legit. I Could be wrong also... By no means an expert on these.

What raises more concerns/doubts to me are the lumen Dots. They just look to prestine for 58 years old radium.

 

Could well be a relume/refurbished dial. I'd question why there seems to be a discrepancy between the lume dots next to the numbers and those in the notches of the other hour markers. Another discrepancy/warning might be that the hands do not appear to have any lume which kind of defeats the purpose of having lumed hour markers

Also, no details/shots of caseback and movement.

Overall, and in my opinion only, not unattractive (then again, I've nothing against good redials/refurbishment), but a risk without further information and probably not a "collector" piece.