Someone got a bargain from Peru.... or did he?

Posts
489
Likes
2,017
I think some generalisations are sensible to be aware of when buying, though of course they are just that and don't apply to every example.

Korea is a hotbed of fantasy redials. Ukraine is the home of the recased pocket watch. Speedmasters from Italy are often messed about and sold by closet dealers. Watches from India are often frankens and redials. Japanese listings are often from resellers llsting watches internationally they have seen on domestic sales platforms. There seem to be 10 times more watches issued by the Pakistani military than soldiers and airman who ever actually served. Watches from Eastern Europe have often been maintained on the cheap if at all. UK listings that say 'serviced by retired Omega trained watchmaker' usually run like crap. Need I go on?

super like! please go on

possibly include the germany seller near nos / mint rolex BIN listing below market price shipped with two USPS tracking number not requiring signature one to a phantom address and anoher to a public address at your zipcode, thailand seller who has omega vintage constellation black dials more than omega has ever produced etc (those are my first hand experiences)
 
Posts
61
Likes
47
Japanese listings are often from resellers llsting watches internationally they have seen on domestic sales platforms.

Sorry—could you explain why this is problematic? I’m curious generally about the reputation of Japanese sellers among watch collectors/experts. I know Japan well, and would think that the combination of high social efficiency/order, intense detail orientation, and a very prosperous past (especially 1960s-1980s) would make it a good source. That said, any society is full of scammers, plus the last 20+ years have created a lot of new poverty there…
 
Posts
9,500
Likes
14,985
Sorry—could you explain why this is problematic? I’m curious generally about the reputation of Japanese sellers among watch collectors/experts. I know Japan well, and would think that the combination of high social efficiency/order, intense detail orientation, and a very prosperous past (especially 1960s-1980s) would make it a good source. That said, any society is full of scammers, plus the last 20+ years have created a lot of new poverty there…
It is a problem since in the scenario I describe, which is seemingly more common in Japan than elsewhere the seller advertising the watch internationally ie in English or another Euro language doesn't actually have the watch in hand. They think they can make an arbitrage buck by adding, say 25% to the local price then telling you you have bought it. The problems start because often there are multiple re-sellers doing this with the same item and as such it isn't always still available for local sale after you have paid and the funds arrived in the re-sellers account which can take time. This is a common complaint about Japanese ebay sellers, often sales are cancelled with no good explanation and your funds are tied up for days. Imagine ebay where everything was listed 10 times with different prices, but the cheapest are in code and you get the gist.

There are ways to avoid this. Do a reverse image search on any images to see if they are listed elsewhere, particularly on a Japanese language site. This will indicate either a scammer or a chancer ( ie a reseller, exploiting your lack of Japanese skills).
 
Posts
520
Likes
409
my seiko 6309-7040 from the phillipines

my raketa world timer from ukraine

my 176.007 from argentina

....
none are collector's topshelf pieces, some may have paid a noob tax for originality or condition, but i didn't pay topshelf prices. they are my beloved watches that i wear and enjoy.

... and many south american countries have long had watch wearing culture and the income inequality to have supported it.
caveat emptor
Edited: