Sharing id

Posts
326
Likes
5,207
I don’t quite see it like that. As in business, diligence doesn’t have to be done 100% before making an offer that is accepted....everyone is entitled to do more checks before concluding a deal.

With respect, as a matter of law, and the fact remains that this is a matter of contract law, what you have stated is incorrect.

In effecting a contract, there must be a “meeting of the minds,” which means that the terms of the contract are to be mutually understood. Where there are ambiguities in a contract, these ambiguities are to be interpreted against the draftsperson of the contract, per the contra proferentem doctrine.

Perhaps you can assert there was an implied term of the agreement insofar as an ID exchange requirement prior to purchase. However, at least in my experience, this is not a common practice in eBay transactions, and thus an ambiguity to be interpreted against you in interpreting the terms of the contract.

I do not mean to lecture you, and am not providing legal advice, but noting a word of caution regarding the belief that one can alter the terms of a contract after the fact. Once an offer extended has been accepted, you are bound by the terms of that agreement.
 
Posts
24,604
Likes
54,639
I do not mean to lecture you, and am not providing legal advice, but noting a word of caution regarding the belief that one can alter the terms of a contract after the fact. Once an offer extended has been accepted, you are bound by the terms of that agreement.

In practice, it's unlikely that anything will be done about it, but it's definitely a violation of eBay T&C. And personally, I would be embarrassed to admit publicly that I reneged on an agreement.
 
Posts
326
Likes
5,207
In practice, it's unlikely that anything will be done about it, but it's definitely a violation of eBay T&C. And personally, I would be embarrassed to admit publicly that I reneged on an agreement.

Agree re: unlikely repercussion in practice insofar as the eBay transaction. My comment was more in response to OP’s indication that “As in business, diligence doesn’t have to be done 100% before making an offer that is accepted...
 
Posts
7,221
Likes
23,419
And personally, I would be embarrassed to admit publicly that I reneged on an agreement.

None of us are born into this world perfect, and even as adults, we sometimes do things that in retrospect we see clearly was a lapse of judgment, or from fear, etc. So I would only be embarrassed if there was resistance to change or a lack of understanding demonstrated after many here have clarified the problem.
 
Posts
108
Likes
186
Thanks all - lesson(s) learned. I appreciate the feedback.

P.s. Re comment from Dan S.....in no way am I embarrassed. We all make mistakes and learn from them!

pps turns out seller has a criminal record in the UK....albeit for violence but not for selling fake expensive toys!
 
Posts
7,221
Likes
23,419
pps turns out seller has a criminal record in the UK....albeit for violence but not for selling fake expensive toys!

Oh, well that would make me so much more comfortable...
 
Posts
5,001
Likes
18,563
I dont like to send my ID to someone I dont know. Luckily I never need to sell a watch. If someone does'nt like it, move on. Good luck with your search.