Forums Latest Members

Seiko Aftermarket Dial Identification Thread

  1. R3D9 Sep 1, 2019

    Posts
    1,288
    Likes
    3,306
    As requested, I’m posting a couple of dials that I recently identified (with the help of a few experienced Seiko collectors) as aftermarket.

    I am far, far from an expert on this subject, so please correct anything you see mentioned here that is incorrect.

    I’m also hoping others will contribute their own findings to the thread so we can build up a bit of an archive for members to refer to. In particular, I’ve heard that examples of 6138-8020 Pandas with AM dials are everywhere now, but have yet to see a good breakdown online explaining how to identify them.

    The AM dial industry for vintage Seiko seems to be very robust and the dials are getting incredibly good... good to the point where you can easily own one and have absolutely no idea the dial isn’t original.

    We’ll start with this beautiful 6117-6400:

    75BDA77F-6BA8-4076-80A9-8A8FC9F48DEF.jpeg

    What is scary about this one is that you would assume the linen dial would be very difficult to reproduce.

    Below is a comparison of four World Time dials... the one on the left is the dial above. The others are known-correct, taken from Instagram.

    12C692BD-37CB-46E0-A7BD-A60614E665DB.jpeg

    The telltale sign is the hours track. Notice the font of the number two in particular. Also notice how on the original dials there is little to no space between the numerals and the linen section of the dial... they butt up against it much more closely.

    I think the applied indices are also slightly different as well... the top flat section on the AM dial seems to be slightly narrower.

    Next up is a 6138-3002, commonly referred to as the Jumbo.

    The one I was considering purchasing had the very desirable Petrol dial. When I showed it to a couple of collector friends, they all immediately identified it as an AM dial.

    There are more signs with this one than the World Timer above, but it still presents extremely well and I would not blame anyone if they owned it and considered it 100% authentic.

    8A3CF455-9009-42CD-84C8-2EAA2E8B4B70.jpeg

    310123F0-6753-4EE6-9EF0-A939D1424DA5.jpeg

    F0FA3D9A-22E1-4FA2-91DE-1F2E33A88D8A.jpeg

    BD1A0B12-26FB-4CF8-8668-B0208500F5DE.jpeg

    4FF0435A-1B03-4E05-8B9E-B3CD702CD301.jpeg

    F701B24B-5545-48C7-B58F-51F65A2DF108.jpeg

    Things that give this one away:

    a) the sun-ray effect across the dial is very pronounced. Genuine petrol dials seem to have a blotchier sheen... and there is a much more pronounced undertone or black in the dial of genuine examples.

    b) the O in Seiko is more circular than a genuine dial and is evidently a common trait amongst many AM dials.

    c) the sub-dials are the dead giveaway... the example above has circular grooves. Genuine examples are smooth.

    d) both of my experts felt the chrono sweep hand (and possibly the sub dial hands as well) are AM. The sweep hand is definitely shorter, however I have trouble distinguishing what makes the sub-dial hands different.

    e) the Farsi date wheel... at first I thought it was a very cool and rare detail, but there are no examples of this model that anyone I spoke to knew of... so a red flag from the jump.

    For reference, here are two Jumbo dials I believe to be correct and a closeup of a genuine subdial:

    48A2EEEE-A9E8-47F5-9087-575C6AFC666A.jpeg

    DBA4EA11-2582-436F-A3EE-45E411093817.jpeg
     
    5F343599-4DC1-4F1E-BF47-847720E08F97.jpeg
    Edited Sep 1, 2019
  2. Yak1 Sep 1, 2019

    Posts
    305
    Likes
    1,981
    Thanks for putting this out. I was curious what the tip off was for that worldtimer—the am dial looked great to a casual observer like myself. @Nathan1967 shared with me a side by side comparison with an original dial—it’s hard to spot.
     
    R3D9 and Nathan1967 like this.
  3. loniscup Sep 1, 2019

    Posts
    334
    Likes
    420
    Really hard to spot the differences if you are a novice!! And the market is flooded with Seikos. Thank you for this thread!!!
     
    R3D9 likes this.
  4. Walrus Sep 1, 2019

    Posts
    8,916
    Likes
    41,908
    Do you happen to know where these dials are coming from they are quite remarkable whoever is doing them. I don’t want to assume it’s China. A few people here showed world timers I always like the looks of them and keep a casual glance at the stock of a guy I know who sells vintage seikos. Now one more thing to worry about
     
    R3D9 likes this.
  5. R3D9 Sep 1, 2019

    Posts
    1,288
    Likes
    3,306
    I’m not sure where they are all coming from... hopefully someone with a bit more insight will stumble across the thread and let us know :)
     
  6. sdre Sep 1, 2019

    Posts
    2,460
    Likes
    7,448
    appreciate the education. Damn, the AM makers are getting really close to the real thing!
     
    R3D9 likes this.
  7. JesterP Sep 1, 2019

    Posts
    251
    Likes
    264
    Thanks for the great post. Brilliant info for guys like me learning what's what.
     
    R3D9 likes this.
  8. Dr. Skridlow Sep 1, 2019

    Posts
    7
    Likes
    10
    Fantastic post. Super helpful!
     
    watchcollect and R3D9 like this.
  9. ConElPueblo Sep 2, 2019

    Posts
    9,587
    Likes
    26,961
    I would really like to know what makes these (unoriginal) aftermarket and not just dial variations? Are they seen placed in wrong cases for the ref, are there any marks on the rear of the dial that gives the game away, etc? In the Certina world there is a huge variety of dials within the same reference (probably) because of small batches being produced at the time, whereas brands such as Rolex and Omega seem to have less variation.

    Just a few weeks ago, I discovered that a Certina DS hands variation that I had previously put down to aftermarket replacements was correct for that particular watch and some of the most characteristic dials in the series have three or more slightly different iterations.

    I am not saying that this is all a made up issue, but I would love to know what underlying research has been done.
     
    Sidnos, KingCrouchy, Foo2rama and 3 others like this.
  10. R3D9 Sep 2, 2019

    Posts
    1,288
    Likes
    3,306
    @ConElPueblo you raise a very interesting point. The AM dial market for Seiko is particularly robust... I think partly because of the active modding performed by Seiko enthusiasts, but I’m speculating.

    Examples of AM dials are continually being sold on eBay... I should have searched for them and added them to the original post. Here is a current listing for the World Time dial referenced above for sale right now:

    123F6A12-98CB-41A8-927D-691D8F1DD78B.jpeg

    https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https://www.ebay.com/ulk/itm/223052087046

    Here is the Jumbo dial for sale right now:

    78653E87-016E-4B58-8FDD-E2076403CB13.jpeg

    https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https://www.ebay.com/ulk/itm/222678016060

    As I said in my post, I’m far from an expert on these matters, but I vetted both of the dials above with three long-time Seiko collectors. Each of them reached the same conclusion, citing the same reasons for believing the dials were AM.

    That said, I’m completely open to the possibility that these could be manufacturing variations, if other experts come forward with that info.
     
    inchpincher and ConElPueblo like this.
  11. sxl2004 Sep 2, 2019

    Posts
    2,302
    Likes
    5,985
    Great info here!
    There are a few IG accounts dedicated to Feikos
    @seikobusters
    @vintageseiko
    #feiko
    @feikofriday
    #feikofriday

    Best
     
    loniscup, ConElPueblo and R3D9 like this.
  12. R3D9 Sep 2, 2019

    Posts
    1,288
    Likes
    3,306
    @sxl2004 thank you for sharing that!!! Insta-follows for all those accounts :thumbsup:
     
    sxl2004 likes this.
  13. vienna Sep 2, 2019

    Posts
    618
    Likes
    891
    Very helpful thank you,

    kind regards Max
     
    pongster and R3D9 like this.
  14. ewand Sep 4, 2019

    Posts
    1,287
    Likes
    5,845
    There's a tell-tale with Seiko 6139s that I presume is common to other models too, though it's hard to check unless you have photos of the service and they've bothered to picture the back of the dial - the first 2 digits of the case serial number are printed on the back of the dial, eg this Pogue:

    IMG_20190723_130116.jpg

    I had it serviced and explicitly asked the watchmaker (who hadn't heard of this previously, I think) to take a pic of the dial back:
    P1210517.JPG
    upload_2019-9-4_15-0-8.png
    P1210524.JPG
     
    inchpincher, Jim W, R3D9 and 7 others like this.
  15. Yak1 Sep 16, 2019

    Posts
    305
    Likes
    1,981
    That’s pretty cool to know. Does that occur for other models?
     
  16. ewand Sep 20, 2019

    Posts
    1,287
    Likes
    5,845
    Yes, I believe it does - though it's not exactly handy information to know since you'd need detailed photos of the service to know it's genuine ;)
     
  17. ConElPueblo Nov 25, 2019

    Posts
    9,587
    Likes
    26,961
    Bringing this thread back to show the rear of the dial that was in my $3 flee market Seiko 8110:

    P1370032.jpg

    As you can see this one has the case digits on the back of the dial and I'd be surprised if it was a fake...
     
  18. Larry S Color Commentator for the Hyperbole. Nov 25, 2019

    Posts
    12,468
    Likes
    49,489
    Great thread...
     
  19. R3D9 Nov 25, 2019

    Posts
    1,288
    Likes
    3,306
    We’re gonna need to see the front of that dial please! A $3 8110 find!!! :eek::)
     
  20. ConElPueblo Nov 25, 2019

    Posts
    9,587
    Likes
    26,961
    Before, during and after service:

    P1370025.jpg

    P1370050.jpg

    P1370053.jpg

    There is massive aging visible, but I chose to keep it as original as possible. Now tested water resistant to 100m, plenty enough for snorkeling :whistling:

    The service was about 130 times as expensive as the watch...