Omega Seamaster back cover. Should I polish it?

Posts
121
Likes
24
Hello friends. I bought a new watch today. I will have a general cleaning, but should I have the back cover polished? What do you recommend? What kind of maintenance would be appropriate? Thank you in advance.
 
Posts
24,252
Likes
54,001
The case is in rough shape, but personally I would probably just live with it. If you have it polished, most likely they will put the whole thing on a buffing wheel and ruin it.
 
Posts
121
Likes
24
The case is in rough shape, but personally I would probably just live with it. If you have it polished, most likely they will put the whole thing on a buffing wheel and ruin it.
What if I polish the back cover a bit and leave the rest of the watch untouched? Or should I just have it cleaned? Do you think the cover is too bad?
 
Posts
24,252
Likes
54,001
If you want them to get all those dents and scratches out, be prepared for the bevel edge and hippocampus to lose their sharpness, and for the finish of the inner circle to be polished. It's your choice, and maybe you just need to give it a shot and learn from trial and error.
 
Posts
17,939
Likes
37,516
Before I saw the pic I was going to suggest that you just chuck it on a lathe and use a backing block with 2000 grade polishing media.

Then I saw that somebody has already done that, but must have used a chunk of gravel instead.

It's too far gone for an amatuer to attempt so just live with it.
 
Posts
16,863
Likes
47,901
Depends on the front of the watch really….No use putting lipstick on a pig 😉
 
Posts
9,737
Likes
54,454
Why not search for a donor watch with a decent case back that you can swap out for the damaged one?
 
Posts
53
Likes
195
Nah, just stick the original in a drawer. If you ever want to sell it, just put it back on. Polishing rarely adds value.

My advice is to maybe wear it for a month, and then see how much it really bothers you.

It's a vintage watch that's had a bit of a hard life, but that isn't to say you can't appreciate for the tough little sonofabitch it is, and take better care of it than the previous owner.
 
Posts
121
Likes
24
Why not search for a donor watch with a decent case back that you can swap out for the damaged one?
Yes, this is the most logical but it is not easy to find a watch with the same reference.
 
Posts
121
Likes
24
Nah, just stick the original in a drawer. If you ever want to sell it, just put it back on. Polishing rarely adds value.

My advice is to maybe wear it for a month, and then see how much it really bothers you.

It's a vintage watch that's had a bit of a hard life, but that isn't to say you can't appreciate for the tough little sonofabitch it is, and take better care of it than the previous owner.
I see I will take your advice into consideration thank you
 
Posts
121
Likes
24
Why not search for a donor watch with a decent case back that you can swap out for the damaged one?
Nah, just stick the original in a drawer. If you ever want to sell it, just put it back on. Polishing rarely adds value.

My advice is to maybe wear it for a month, and then see how much it really bothers you.

It's a vintage watch that's had a bit of a hard life, but that isn't to say you can't appreciate for the tough little sonofabitch it is, and take better care of it than the previous owner.
Depends on the front of the watch really….No use putting lipstick on a pig 😉
Before I saw the pic I was going to suggest that you just chuck it on a lathe and use a backing block with 2000 grade polishing media.

Then I saw that somebody has already done that, but must have used a chunk of gravel instead.

It's too far gone for an amatuer to attempt so just live with it.
The case is in rough shape, but personally I would probably just live with it. If you have it polished, most likely they will put the whole thing on a buffing wheel and ruin it.

I had it cleaned. What do you think?
 
Posts
16,863
Likes
47,901
The back of the lugs could do with a clean 😉
 
Posts
121
Likes
24
The back of the lugs could do with a clean 😉
Yes, yes, I will. I think I can clean the lugs myself.
 
Posts
9,737
Likes
54,454
That looks like more than a clean. You’re saying that it was not refinished?
 
Posts
121
Likes
24
That looks like more than a clean. You’re saying that it was not refinished?
I dont know ı asked the watchmaker if I should have it polished and he said he would do better than polishing and delivered it this way.