Omega Seamaster 600 “Technical Dial” - Need Advice on Authenticity Before Paying

Posts
9
Likes
2
Hi everyone,


I recently won an auction for an Omega Seamaster 600 ref. 135.011 from the 1960s - to my surprise, at only €550.


The listing states that the watch has been "restored," but doesn't specify what that entails - it doesn't mention repainting. The dial looks very vivid and clean, so I'm wondering whether it might actually have been refinished. Still, it looks great overall, and if the restoration was done properly, I wouldn't necessarily mind at this price.


According to the listing, the watch has been "checked, cleaned and tested" (not fully serviced). The movement is a Cal. 601, serial 25,045,670, and the case reference 135.011 checks out. However, the movement doesn't look particularly clean to me from the photos.


The seller also claims there's a Hippocampus logo on the case back, but in the photos it appears to be plain (no logo) - which makes me wonder if the case back might have been replaced or over-polished.


I haven't provided payment details yet and would like to make sure everything matches the description before committing.


You can see the full listing and high-resolution


I'd really appreciate your help and opinions on:


Whether the dial looks original, restored, or repainted.


If the movement appears correct for this reference.


Whether the plain case back is a red flag.


And if this is still a fair buy at €550, given these details.


Thanks very much in advance for your insights!


BR Anders

 
Posts
23,022
Likes
51,468
Repainted dial, case very aggressively polished and refinished. The shallow indents for the opening tool in the back suggests that the back was polished down and re-brushed. I can't see a hippocampus. No lume in hands. Case and movement pitted and corroded.
Edited:
 
Posts
12,841
Likes
22,166
It’s utter crap I’m afraid.

The dial is repainted - I can say with 99% certainty this had a standard silver dial before it was refinished, the case is corroded and overpolished and the movement looks tired.

Absolutely return if you can but really you should ask these questions before you bud, not after you’ve won.
 
Posts
13,081
Likes
17,935
Here’s a picture of an original dial for comparison.
It’s actually not a huge difference here. That alone is scary.

gatorcpa
 
Posts
9
Likes
2
It’s utter crap I’m afraid.

The dial is repainted - I can say with 99% certainty this had a standard silver dial before it was refinished, the case is corroded and overpolished and the movement looks tired.

Absolutely return if you can but really you should ask these questions before you bud, not after you’ve won.
Thank you for the quick reply. I won't buy it then.
How can you tell that it was originally a silver dial?
 
Posts
9
Likes
2
Here’s a picture of an original dial for comparison.
It’s actually not a huge difference here. That alone is scary.

gatorcpa
Thank you very much. Definitely has been repainte.
 
Posts
9
Likes
2
Repainted dial, case very aggressively polished and refinished. The shallow indents for the opening tool in the back suggests that the back was polished down and re-brushed. I can't see a hippocampus. No lume in hands. Case and movement pitted and corroded.
Thank you so much Dan. I really appreciate it. Great to be able to get expert advice on here.
 
Posts
12,841
Likes
22,166
Thank you for the quick reply. I won't buy it then.
How can you tell that it was originally a silver dial?
It’s an assumption based on:

1. There are probably 30-50 silver dials to every 1 technical dial.
2. Even a patina’d, original technical dial is worth more than one that’s been repainted.
3. Sellers often buy dirt cheap, crapped out silver dialled Seamasters and repaint them with black/technic dials.
 
Posts
68
Likes
28
Just to add.

If the movement has obvious signs of corrosion like this one,but the dial is immaculate,it normally means the dial isn't authentic.
 
Posts
2,644
Likes
5,328
For future reference the lugs on this reference should be quite sharp.

When you say you won’t buy it, it sounds like you already did.
If the listing disclosed it was restored that is seller-speak for redialed. you should have solid grounds for return or renege on payment other than buyer remorse.
No one thinks this is a good watch to buy, but that info would have been available to you if you asked before buying. Next time…..