If you like how this looks, then great, but there are many who don't want any polishing done to a vintage watch like this, because they prefer it to be as original as possible.
But that aside, even those who don't mind a refinished watch would not necessarily be happy with the result here. For me the case back work in particular is very poorly done (I can't see the rest well enough to judge it, but worry a little seeing the case back work). It looks like someone was attempting to put a circular grain on it, but somehow ended up with brushing lines in all directions. I'm not sure how the person who did the work accomplished this - although there are many ways to get the proper finish, if the circular grain is what you are after then something like this is needed:
The chuck grips the inside of the case back allowing you to refinish all the way to the edge as needed...many abrasives can be used depending on the desired finish and how bad the damage to the case back is (including taking a skim cut with a graver in extreme cases) but this one only required a light touch up:
Again if you are happy with the work that's great, but I think most here would hold the watchmaker to a higher standard.
Cheers, Al
Click to expand...