No papers Omega Planet Ocean 42mm titanium 232.90.42.21.03.001

DanD · Mon. 2:26am

What are the risks or downsides to purchasing a watch from a shop that does not have any papers with it, other than lower resale value? This watch looks good and I think it's authentic because of the movement "looks" correct to my eyes.

They are asking 99,000 THB or about $3,100 depending on the current conversion rate.

DLT222 · Mon. 3:00am

Just hold out and the right one will come along with papers.

zinterz · Mon. 3:51am

It's a lot of money to "risk". The watch does look good, but it depends how bothered you are about the papers... I think it's fair to say that a more modern piece such as this should have papers, whereas an older watch would come with an expectation of a lack of papers.

Archer · Mon. 5:39pm

Serial number appears to match the reference...

Serial number: 86754773
Article ref: 23290422103001
Version of movement: 8500B

Dan S · Mon. 5:41pm

If it's a fairly new watch, the manufacturer warranty is important, so you want to make sure that it will be honored. For older watches, papers are less important.

One thing about reselling is that things like papers not only bring more money, but they make the watch easier to sell. Some buyers won't consider a watch without papers, making the market smaller.

ErichPryde · Mon. 6:23pm

It looks incredibly sharp, that's one heck of a dial.

If you pass on it today, it's probably going to be available tomorrow or the next (and probably the next, but who knows, maybe I'm wrong)- you've still got some time on your vacation to hunt around for the right piece.

This is a bit different than the other two options you've been looking at- What do you want? Right now all I've got pinned is "blue" and "omega." This is going to be a much, much bigger watch than the others you were eyeing.

DanD · 2025-12-30T00:11:23-0600

Archer
Serial number appears to match the reference...

Serial number: 86754773
Article ref: 23290422103001
Version of movement: 8500B

Thank you! I’m much more confident that it is authentic now.

DanD · 2025-12-30T00:17:29-0600

ErichPryde
It looks incredibly sharp, that's one heck of a dial.

If you pass on it today, it's probably going to be available tomorrow or the next (and probably the next, but who knows, maybe I'm wrong)- you've still got some time on your vacation to hunt around for the right piece.

This is a bit different than the other two options you've been looking at- What do you want? Right now all I've got pinned is "blue" and "omega." This is going to be a much, much bigger watch than the others you were eyeing.

Yes, a blue dial and Omega, I’m more partial towards the Seamaster line. I have to admit that I’m a price conscious shopper and seeing a watch like this at this price point is the primary reason for liking it. It’s about $2,500 less than one for sale with papers in California. Could this have been a grey market watch where the original owner didn’t get a warranty card?

ErichPryde · 2025-12-30T00:33:34-0600

D DanD
Yes, a blue dial and Omega, I’m more partial towards the Seamaster line. I have to admit that I’m a price conscious shopper and seeing a watch like this at this price point is the primary reason for liking it. It’s about $2,500 less than one for sale with papers in California. Could this have been a grey market watch where the original owner didn’t get a warranty card?

Dan, I think you're possibly falling a bit for a discount value fallacy here because of your price consciousness. You see this as a "good deal" because it's so much cheaper than you think it should be, but what makes it a good deal if you can't resell it (or find that very difficult) and more importantly it's not exactly the watch you want?

The 3,500 Seamaster you want and will love is a much, much better deal than the 3,100USD seamaster you actually don't want.

I can't say what you want. The best advice I can give you is to narrow it down to the reference you want within your budget. Then (and this may seem paradoxical) buy the best example of that reference at the top of your budget. You'll get a better example in better condition that you will be happier with and it will feel like it was worth what you paid and, although the psychology here might be a bit odd, I bet you'll feel much better knowing you paid more for quality in the long run, than knowing you saved $500 and got the watch you didn't want.

Luxury items like this, especially if they are supposed to be special, supposed to be keepers- they shouldn't feel cheap. Because if they feel cheap, well- they feel cheap.

That's my (any many others) philosophy, and my general advice.

Find the ref you want and start from there. Keep asking questions and sharing pictures, and good luck in your search.

Lode_Runner · 2025-12-30T15:53:59-0600

The fact that the serial number matches the reference would not give me much comfort that the watch is authentic. This is because good replicas almost always bear a serial number from a real watch. The same is true for having the supposedly original "box and papers," a lot of people fall for that as an indicia of authenticity, but those are even more easily faked than the watch itself.

I'm not saying this watch is fake (it looks real from the pictures, assuming they are of the actual watch being sold). But most people will tell you, when buying used watches, that "you're buying the seller," which means the reputation and trustworthiness of the seller are far more important factors than what you can glean from online photos. I will say the condition appears outstanding for a watch that is likely at least a decade old (as that second gen Planet Ocean model was discontinued by 2016), but there's no way to know if that's because the watch was never worn or because it was polished (although the pictures show that someone bought a NATO strap for it in 2018, which suggests it got at least some use). In any case, it's an outstanding price for a piece in outstanding condition, but if I didn't have a relationship with this seller, or the seller does not have a ton of positive reviews online, I'd think twice about purchasing.

bsowers34 · 2025-12-30T15:59:58-0600

Buy the triple date speedmaster. IMHO anyway.

Archer · 2025-12-30T17:15:59-0600

Lode_Runner
The fact that the serial number matches the reference would not give me much comfort that the watch is authentic. This is because good replicas almost always bear a serial number from a real watch.

They do, but it’s nearly always the wrong model…

ErichKeane · 2025-12-30T22:44:55-0600

Lode_Runner
The fact that the serial number matches the reference would not give me much comfort that the watch is authentic. This is because good replicas almost always bear a serial number from a real watch.

I'd VERY much need evidence of this claim. "Replica" with a serial number that matches the reference is basically unheard of unless the buyer specifically/custom orders a serial, and even then, most rep sellers don't offer that as a service.

DanD · 2025-12-30T23:41:04-0600

Well someone obviously thought that it was a great deal, as I just took a look at their web site and it is no longer listed.

No idea on how long it had been siting in their shop, but it's gone for now.

padders · 2025-12-31T06:58:33-0600

ErichKeane
I'd VERY much need evidence of this claim. "Replica" with a serial number that matches the reference is basically unheard of unless the buyer specifically/custom orders a serial, and even then, most rep sellers don't offer that as a service.

This. I’ve never heard of a single example of a fake or replica where the so called serial passes the Archer test ie the serial gets a hit for the correct ref when looked up on the extranet.

The other point above about a recent watch without box and papers being hard to sell is fair but where is the line beyond which it doesn’t matter? 5 years, 10, 20? As long as the watch is priced to reflect the lack of warranty or collateral items it still can be a good deal. I’m talking generally, maybe this one isn’t quite cheap enough.

Lode_Runner · 2025-12-31T14:33:28-0600

ErichKeane
I'd VERY much need evidence of this claim. "Replica" with a serial number that matches the reference is basically unheard of unless the buyer specifically/custom orders a serial, and even then, most rep sellers don't offer that as a service.

To be clear, I am not using the term "replica" to refer to an homage watch, but a watch that bears the manufacturer trademark but is a counterfeit. No reputable company that does watch authentication would declare a watch "authentic" simply because it bears a serial number that matches the reference, without lots of other indicia of its authenticity.

If you'd Google'd this, you'd have seen websites of many jewelers who say exactly that, although the problem seems far more pronounced with Rolex superfakes than with Omega. (See <https://www.ecijewelers.com/blogs/recent-posts/how-to-authenticate-rolex-watches> ("Can You Tell If A Rolex is Real by the Serial Number Alone? In a word, no. A serial number is a crucial part of the puzzle, but on its own, it's not enough to confirm a watch is genuine. The reality is, counterfeiters have gotten incredibly good at copying real serial numbers—or even just lifting them from photos of real watches—and slapping them on their fakes.").) I know some ADs that will do watch authentication, and they will consistently tell you that (1) a fake (or missing) serial number basically guarantees it's a fake watch, but (2) a real serial number is at best an indicator, but does not by itself guarantee it's authentic.

ErichKeane · 2025-12-31T14:39:31-0600

Lode_Runner
To be clear, I am not using the term "replica" to refer to an homage watch, but a watch that bears the manufacturer trademark but is a counterfeit. No reputable company that does watch authentication would declare a watch "authentic" simply because it bears a serial number that matches the reference, without lots of other indicia of its authenticity. If you'd Google'd this, you'd have seen websites of many jewelers who say exactly that, although the problem seems far more pronounced with Rolex superfakes and Omega. (See <https://www.ecijewelers.com/blogs/recent-posts/how-to-authenticate-rolex-watches> ("Can You Tell If A Rolex is Real by the Serial Number Alone? In a word, no. A serial number is a crucial part of the puzzle, but on its own, it's not enough to confirm a watch is genuine. The reality is, counterfeiters have gotten incredibly good at copying real serial numbers—or even just lifting them from photos of real watches—and slapping them on their fakes.").)

I know exactly what you're referring to. I've yet to see any of them actually have a serial number that matches the reference, no matter what a jeweler who uses some pretty questionable claims on their website says. I'm mildly familiar with the 'replica' scene. A VAST majority of reps all use the same number (to the point you can google their serial numbers and identify a fake that way).

None of the super fakes claim (nor, IMO, have attempted) to get a serial that even matches the reference. No one who has made this claim has ever produced a fake with a serial number that matches the reference number. I've heard RUMOR that you can get a fake with a custom number from very few sellers, so perhaps one exists that way, but the claims made in that article do not reflect reality.

Archer · 2025-12-31T14:43:20-0600

Lode_Runner
To be clear, I am not using the term "replica" to refer to an homage watch, but a watch that bears the manufacturer trademark but is a counterfeit. No reputable company that does watch authentication would declare a watch "authentic" simply because it bears a serial number that matches the reference, without lots of other indicia of its authenticity. If you'd Google'd this, you'd have seen websites of many jewelers who say exactly that, although the problem seems far more pronounced with Rolex superfakes and Omega. (See <https://www.ecijewelers.com/blogs/recent-posts/how-to-authenticate-rolex-watches> ("Can You Tell If A Rolex is Real by the Serial Number Alone? In a word, no. A serial number is a crucial part of the puzzle, but on its own, it's not enough to confirm a watch is genuine. The reality is, counterfeiters have gotten incredibly good at copying real serial numbers—or even just lifting them from photos of real watches—and slapping them on their fakes.").)

Here's the difference - Rolex will not correlate the serial number to the model number. This leaves their customers and potential customers in a position where they cannot tell what model reference a specific serial number pertains to, so very much open to fraud.

Omega is quite different - anyone with access to the Omega Extranet can simply enter the serial number of a watch, and see what reference number is refers to. I do this for people daily - some days many times per day. You can also just call Omega with a serial number and ask them to do the same.

This is how I tell people who are considering buying that limited edition Mauri or Mitsukoshi, that it's either a genuine LE or just a conversion watch that has the dial and hands changed on it. It's also how I can easily tell that a men's Seamaster someone might be wanting to buy is fake, because the serial number comes back to a ladies quartz Constellation. The fakes never match, at least not any that I have searched in the last nearly 20 years...you can't broadly apply what might be perfectly accurate to one brand, to all brands.

Archer · 2025-12-31T15:35:46-0600

Lode_Runner
A serial number is a crucial part of the puzzle, but on its own, it's not enough to confirm a watch is genuine.

And just to address this one - read the thread - literally no one has said that a matching serial number is enough...

No papers Omega Planet Ocean 42mm titanium 232.90.42.21.03.001

DanD

DLT222

zinterz

Archer

Dan S

ErichPryde

DanD

DanD

ErichPryde

Lode_Runner

bsowers34

Archer

ErichKeane

DanD

padders

Lode_Runner

ErichKeane

Archer

Archer

Similar threads

Planet Ocean 42mm Titanium

Omega Planet Ocean 8500 - 42mm - Blue Titanium 232.90.42.21.03.001 (mint )

Omega Planet Ocean 8500 - 42mm - Blue Titanium 232.90.42.21.03.001 (mint )

Omega Planet Ocean 8500 - 42mm - Blue Titanium 232.90.42.21.03.001 (excellent)

Omega SeaMaster Planet Ocean Titanium 42MM Blue Dial - 232.90.42.21.03.001 B&P

Omega SeaMaster Planet Ocean Titanium 42MM Blue Dial - 232.90.42.21.03.001 B&P