Is this normal for an almost new watch?

Posts
18
Likes
6
I bought a slightly used (July 26) white dial speedy on Friday and by Sunday noticed it’s running a bit slow. 5 seconds a day. I hit up Claude ai and it said to make sure it was fully wound and lay it face up at night. It ran perfectly fine all day Monday. This morning I picked it and it was off by 4 minutes!
So I wound it again, as I do every morning and set it down while I got ready for work. I picked it up to put it on after less than an hour and it was off by 5 seconds! After I put it on, it kept time fine. I went to the dealer to have it checked and all the time tests were fine.
Has anyone else ever experienced something like this?
 
Posts
8,890
Likes
62,989
welcome, have you experienced manual movement watches in the past?
 
Posts
18
Likes
6
welcome, have you experienced manual movement watches in the past?
Absolutely, I have several. 5 seconds slow is no reason to be overly concerned, but 4 minutes? Yeah.
 
Posts
18
Likes
6
So I guess it’s not normal. I called Omega support, he said it definitely needs to come back and since I just bought it and it’s this far off, they should replace it or give a refund so I don’t have to wait two to three months to be able to water a very expensive watch I just bought. It’ll be interesting to see how that plays out.

 
Posts
24,844
Likes
55,271
So you wound it and let it run for two days and it was off by 4 minutes? Or did you wind it again after 24 hours?
 
Posts
18
Likes
6
So you wound it and let it run for two days and it was off by 4 minutes? Or did you wind it again after 24 hours?
I wound it every morning. With a 50 hour reserve, that should be adequate.
 
Posts
10,824
Likes
16,844
Are you winding until the hard stop, by which I mean until you physically can’t wind it any further? I ask since we have had multiple instances of people just not winding enough. Some stop when they feel increased resistance. It takes about 60-80 twists to fully wind one if these and they won’t run well with little reserve.

If you are then it is not a healthy watch but you could try sitting it crown high and crown low to see what effect that has.

I’d be surprised if they replace it if they can’t detect a fault. Particularly since you bought it used but dealers vary so I guess you’ll find out. My guess is a service will be offered. I’ve had very good after service from an AD when faults occur as they can do.
Edited:
 
Posts
1,677
Likes
5,950
I've never found any of my Speedmasters to be like 4 mins off. They either run close to the correct time, or they stop. I wind them sometimes daily or sometimes every other day, and when I dont plan to wear them further, then I just let them run down. But I dont think I've ever picked up a watch which had been low on power and found it 4 mins off.
Edited:
 
Posts
961
Likes
517
So off by 5 seconds is out of spec.
If this is a common occurance with this watch, then it would seem to be displaying a degree of precision so a simple adjustment may remedy the situation.

Now the minutes thing is something else.
Just one question.
Is that a once off occurance?
If so, it could be that you were mistaken when doing a reset of the watch.
I would be more diligent in that regard and check for it happening again. Mistakes happen.
 
Posts
47
Likes
36
Has anyone else ever experienced something like this?
Had a similar thing happen when I first got mine. It was the atomic clock I was using that was off though. It had something to do with the computer I was using and how often it phoned home if I remember correctly. I at first thought my watch was off 30 seconds a day for a couple days as the atomic clock couldn't be wrong, right?
 
Posts
18
Likes
6
Are you winding until the hard stop, by which I mean until you physically can’t wind it any further? I ask since we have had multiple instances of people just not winding enough. Some stop when they feel increased resistance. It takes about 60-80 twists to fully wind one if these and they won’t run well with little reserve.

If you are then it is not a healthy watch but you could try sitting it crown high and crown low to see what effect that has.

I’d be surprised if they replace it if they can’t detect a fault. Particularly since you bought it used but dealers vary so I guess you’ll find out. My guess is a service will be offered. I’ve had very good after service from an AD when faults occur as they can do.
That’s exactly how I wind it. That’s why I started the thread. And it wasn’t exactly 4 minutes off, it was a rough estimate, it was closer to 3:40 off but I rounded it. The other odd part is that after fully winding it and accurately setting it yesterday morning, it was off be 5 seconds after running for less than an hour.
 
Posts
18
Likes
6
Ok, so I bought it a the local Rolex dealer. Their expert wants to keep it for a week to see if he can replicate the issue and try and fix it. Will Omega void the warranty if he does?
 
Posts
10,824
Likes
16,844
Why would you take it to a Rolex dealer? Yes having a third party mess about with it would give the AD an excuse to tell you to go to hell, though it is doubtful that they would in my experience.
 
Posts
18
Likes
6
Why would you take it to a Rolex dealer? Yes having a third party mess about with it would give the AD an excuse to tell you to go to hell, though it is doubtful that they would in my experience.
I bought it there, used. It was purchased new in July of this year at an Omega boutique in Chicago, then traded later at this Rolex dealer. It still has over 4-1/2 years on the warranty.
I decided to pick it up today before they have a chance to open it and potentially void the warranty. I'll give it another week before sending it in for Omega service.
 
Posts
18
Likes
6
Isn’t this one METAS? METAS watch shouldn’t even run slow.
You are correct. When I picked it up today, their tech guy had been testing it and it was 2 second slow so far today.
I'm not all that worried by a couple seconds, but still...
 
Posts
2,684
Likes
2,873
Isn’t this one METAS? METAS watch shouldn’t even run slow.
That isn't correct, a single position can definitely be running 'slow'. 0-5s/day is the average of 6 positions in 2 temperature zones over 4 days.

The delta between teh worst 2 positions can be up to 12s/day.

The Omega 'check my watch results' site has the details on these.
 
Posts
24
Likes
39
-5 sec day could also be result of poor isochronicity: Fully wound watch having good accuracy but after a day accuracy falling if not winded. Also speedmaster cal 3861 consume a lot of power while running chronograph. With cal 9300/9900 you can run chronograph all the day without any problem. Cal 3861 with cronograph running can eat power in one and half day, not 50h promised for watch only running. Breightling B01 often have poor isochronicity, for omega it's more rare but still may happen.
 
Posts
2,684
Likes
2,873
-5 sec day could also be result of poor isochronicity: Fully wound watch having good accuracy but after a day accuracy falling if not winded. Also speedmaster cal 3861 consume a lot of power while running chronograph. With cal 9300/9900 you can run chronograph all the day without any problem. Cal 3861 with cronograph running can eat power in one and half day, not 50h promised for watch only running. Breightling B01 often have poor isochronicity, for omega it's more rare but still may happen.

Basically all of this is false. Particularly the bit about chronographs 'consuming' power. That is not actually possible with how watches work.
 
Posts
24,844
Likes
55,271
Basically all of this is false. Particularly the bit about chronographs 'consuming' power. That is not actually possible with how watches work.
LOL, you should ask him about the purpose of the escapement.