Is this an original dial?

Posts
13,273
Likes
31,370
What do your investigations so far tell you about it?
 
Posts
4,593
Likes
10,786
Are you saying the star is not correctly aligned?

Yes I'm also curious why someone would post something like that without explaining whatever he/she was getting at. The dial looks fine to me.
 
Posts
2,026
Likes
4,326
Yes I'm also curious why someone would post something like that without explaining whatever he/she was getting at. The dial looks fine to me.
The starting-post had eleven (!) words. I started with a picture. :)
@avd: What is YOUR opinion concerning the star?
 
Posts
918
Likes
1,433
avd88, welcome to the forum.

What do you see that on this dial that leads you to ask this question?
 
Posts
205
Likes
455
It looks original to me: fonts, min markers etc look ok. The indices appear to be in gold. I don't have any gold watches to compare to, but suspect its fine.

I'm intrigued by the line drawn across 4 and 8 o'clock. If I put a line across mine the star sits on the line, rather than transecting the star as in the OP dial.
 
Posts
2,424
Likes
2,765
It looks original to me: fonts, min markers etc look ok. The indices appear to be in gold. I don't have any gold watches to compare to, but suspect its fine.

I'm intrigued by the line drawn across 4 and 8 o'clock. If I put a line across mine the star sits on the line, rather than transecting the star as in the OP dial.

There are different star sizes too, and sometimes the stars turn on their own (assumably, maybe temp changes etc.)
 
Posts
2,709
Likes
5,531
While I am unsure of the redial issue (I lean toward redial), I am strongly leaning toward a lume job. The lume dots over hanging the edge of the dial suggest to me that the dial did not have lume dots to originally. The indices would have been moved slightly forward to accommodate the lume. Furthermore, I believe we would see tritium "T's" adjacent to the SWISS MADE if the dial was lumed.originally.