Forums Latest Auctions Members
  1. DRjre086

    DRjre086 Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    296
    Likes
    541
    Hi folks,

    I wanted to get some general opinions on the value effects of a relumed vintage watch.....let’s stick to Speedies for the sake of conversation.

    Also, would like to point out that i am strictly using the SM101 pricing chart for reference.

    If the relume has been done tastefully, does it really affect value that much? I have seen countless watches for sale that have been relumed and yet still command prices higher than the chart.

    So basically I’m asking how much you weigh relumed hands/dial against value as long as it is disclosed?
     
  2. Rochete

    Rochete Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    787
    Likes
    1,467
    Show us your relumed watch :rolleyes:
     
  3. Davidt

    Davidt Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    5,412
    Likes
    8,297
    Depends entirely on how the watch looked prior to the relume.

    A good relume on a mouldy dial will add value.

    A poor relume on an original dial will remove significant value.
     
    tzachi, marco, Gefa and 1 other person like this.
  4. rfordo

    rfordo Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    52
    Likes
    57
    I would be interested to see watches that are relumed and you see selling over sm101 ranges. I'm not saying there are none, I am just curious. Most sellers I see ask a lower price for watches where a relume is stated clearly in their listing (even if they name some special re-lumer, which I always find funny)
     
  5. Gefa

    Gefa Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    210
    Likes
    489
    ... IMO a watch with relumed dial or hands is comparable with a watch with a polished case ...may be it has a better optical look, but it's a big loss of originality...
     
    tzachi and Millenary Watches like this.
  6. DRjre086

    DRjre086 Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    296
    Likes
    541
    If you browse the current private sellers listings, I found 3 145.022-69 that are currently FS with relumed dials/hands. Each is head only, and all asking at the “Good” or 2nd price tier.

    It could also be that I am misreading the chart, but wouldn’t a head only watch that is not “all original” be priced closer to “running” or the 1st tier?
     
  7. DRjre086

    DRjre086 Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    296
    Likes
    541
    Likewise, that was my take. I would assume pricing closer to “running” on SM101 chart in this case.
     
  8. DRjre086

    DRjre086 Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    296
    Likes
    541
    I don’t have one, I’m merely asking in reference to how it affects value.
     
  9. padders

    padders Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    4,773
    Likes
    6,681
    The $400k 2915 which set the bar as the most expensive on the chart was relumed....
     
  10. Dan S

    Dan S Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    4,601
    Likes
    11,379
    In all honesty, I'm having trouble finding three examples of this in the private sales listings, but maybe I'm just not looking carefully enough. Let's use sales prices - not asking prices. Sometimes watches will sit in that forum for months.
     
    Edited Nov 9, 2018
  11. DRjre086

    DRjre086 Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    296
    Likes
    541
    :eek:
     
  12. DRjre086

    DRjre086 Nov 9, 2018

    Posts
    296
    Likes
    541
    I will see if I can find any actually sold but that’s also why I’m asking if these are respectable prices.
     
  13. tzachi

    tzachi Nov 10, 2018

    Posts
    228
    Likes
    141
    As long as looks untouched even if faded or markers gone, I’d go with original over relume at similar price